Shortness of Breath: When to See a Pulmonologist or Cardiologist - Pulmonology

Share to:

Take a deep breath?


Sometimes I feel like I can't get enough air, and I want to take a deep breath or hold my breath for a moment to expand my lungs, which makes me feel more comfortable.
I exercise 1 to 2 times a week, and my heart rate is about 90 to 160 beats per minute during exercise.
At night, my heart rate is around 50 beats per minute.
Doctor, what could be the reason for my feeling of not getting enough air and wanting to take a deep breath? If I need to get checked, should I see a cardiologist or a pulmonologist? Thank you!

A San, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2022/06/18

Dr. Huang Yiwen reply Pulmonology


Dear A-san: Taking a deep breath shows no particular abnormalities, but my heart rate is about 50 beats per minute while sleeping.
It may be necessary to consult a cardiologist at Changhua Hospital for further evaluation.

Reply Date: 2022/06/18

More Info


Shortness of breath, or dyspnea, can be a concerning symptom that may arise from various underlying conditions, including respiratory and cardiovascular issues. Based on your description, it seems that you experience episodes where you feel like you cannot get enough air, prompting you to take deep breaths. This sensation can be distressing and may lead you to question whether it is related to asthma, anxiety, or other medical conditions.

Given your history of asthma and allergies, it is essential to consider that your symptoms could be linked to bronchial hyperreactivity, which is common in individuals with asthma. Allergens or irritants in your environment may trigger bronchospasm, leading to feelings of breathlessness. Additionally, anxiety can exacerbate these sensations, creating a cycle where the fear of not being able to breathe leads to further anxiety and, consequently, more difficulty in breathing.

Your heart rate during exercise (90-160 beats per minute) suggests that you are engaging in physical activity, which is generally beneficial for cardiovascular health. However, a resting heart rate of around 50 beats per minute is considered bradycardic for many individuals, especially if you are not an athlete. This could indicate a need for further evaluation, particularly if you experience symptoms like dizziness or fainting.

When deciding whether to see a pulmonologist or a cardiologist, consider the following:
1. Pulmonologist: If your primary concern is related to breathing difficulties, especially if they are accompanied by wheezing, coughing, or a history of asthma, a pulmonologist would be the appropriate specialist to consult. They can perform pulmonary function tests, assess your lung capacity, and determine if there are any obstructive or restrictive lung diseases present.

2. Cardiologist: If you have concerns about your heart rate, particularly the bradycardia at night or if you experience chest pain, palpitations, or other cardiovascular symptoms, a cardiologist would be the right choice. They can conduct an electrocardiogram (ECG) and other tests to evaluate your heart's electrical activity and overall function.

In your case, it may be prudent to start with a pulmonologist, given your history of asthma and the nature of your symptoms. They can help rule out any respiratory issues and provide guidance on managing your asthma and any potential triggers. If they find that your breathing difficulties are not related to lung function, they may refer you to a cardiologist for further evaluation.

In summary, the sensation of not getting enough air can stem from various causes, including asthma, anxiety, or cardiac issues. It is crucial to seek medical advice to determine the underlying cause of your symptoms. A thorough evaluation by a pulmonologist can help clarify whether your breathing difficulties are due to respiratory issues, while a cardiologist can assess any potential heart-related concerns. Don't hesitate to reach out for medical assistance, as timely intervention can significantly improve your quality of life and overall health.

Similar Q&A

Shortness of Breath: Should You See a Cardiologist or Pulmonologist?

If you suddenly experience shortness of breath, should you see a cardiologist or a pulmonologist? Thank you.


Dr. Gao Qingyun reply Family Medicine
Dear Vivian: There are many causes of dyspnea and asthma, and the differential diagnoses vary with age and gender. It is recommended to consult a specialist in family medicine or pulmonology for evaluation. Wishing you safety and health. Sincerely, Dr. Gao Qingyun, Attending Phys...

[Read More] Shortness of Breath: Should You See a Cardiologist or Pulmonologist?


Chest Discomfort: Should You See a Cardiologist or Pulmonologist?

You are experiencing symptoms of left chest tightness, lack of appetite, weakness in your hands, and excessive sleepiness, but you do not have a cough or shortness of breath. Should I see a cardiologist or a pulmonologist for an examination?


Dr. Zhou Ziguang reply Pulmonology
Hello: You may first visit a cardiology clinic.

[Read More] Chest Discomfort: Should You See a Cardiologist or Pulmonologist?


Understanding Shortness of Breath: When to See a Cardiologist or Pulmonologist

The feeling of shortness of breath that improves with deep breathing or yawning has been present before, but not as frequently. Recently, it seems that I need to repeatedly take deep breaths and yawn almost all the time while awake. I have previously been diagnosed with mitral va...


Dr. He Dongjin reply Cardiology
Hello, the mitral valve prolapse may be related to autonomic nervous system dysfunction. You should consult a cardiologist. Peaceful Changhua Hospital cares about you.

[Read More] Understanding Shortness of Breath: When to See a Cardiologist or Pulmonologist


Understanding Shortness of Breath: When to See a Doctor

Recently, I've often heard my uncle mention that my grandmother gets short of breath after walking just a short distance, and her breathing is noisy. Regarding this situation, I'm really unsure which specialty to take her to first: thoracic surgery or cardiology?


Dr. Chen Bozhang reply Family Medicine
It is recommended to first consult a cardiologist.

[Read More] Understanding Shortness of Breath: When to See a Doctor


Related FAQ

Chest Pain

(Pulmonology)

Difficulty Breathing

(Pulmonology)

Breathing

(Pulmonology)

Chest Tightness

(Pulmonology)

Breathing

(Cardiology)

Which Department Should I See?

(Pulmonology)

Respiratory Distress Syndrome

(Pulmonology)

Pulmonary Obstruction

(Pulmonology)

Copd

(Pulmonology)

Gerd

(Pulmonology)