Palpitations: Distinguishing Strong Heartbeats from Arrhythmias - Cardiology

Share to:

Inquiry Consultation


Dear Dr.
He,
I have a few questions to ask you:
Q1.
Recently, I came across a medical report stating that "a strong heartbeat can make us feel our heartbeat, which is completely normal without arrhythmia, yet we may still experience palpitations.
Therefore, palpitations do not equate to arrhythmia." Dr.
He, is the palpitations caused by a strong heartbeat similar to premature beats (atrial or ventricular ectopic contractions)?
Q2.
If they are not the same, what are the differences between premature beats (atrial or ventricular ectopic contractions) and palpitations caused by a strong heartbeat? Additionally, what are the main symptoms (or sensations) associated with premature beats (atrial or ventricular ectopic contractions)?
Q3.
In the past few days, I have experienced palpitations twice, feeling as if my heartbeat was slightly heavier for a moment, accompanied by some anxiety, but without any other discomfort.
Dr.
He, in your opinion, do these two instances of palpitations lean more towards the type caused by a strong heartbeat or those caused by premature beats?
Thank you, Dr.
He.

A-Xiang, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2022/07/31

Dr. He Dongjin reply Cardiology


Hello, that's correct.
Palpitations do not equal arrhythmias, but you cannot determine the presence of arrhythmias or premature beats solely from palpitations.
I'm not a fortune teller, and I cannot know if your last episode of palpitations was associated with arrhythmias or premature beats.
In fact, whether or not there are arrhythmias or premature beats is not that important; it's better to coexist peacefully with them.
Changhua Hospital cares about you.

Reply Date: 2022/07/31

More Info


Hello, thank you for your questions regarding palpitations and the distinction between strong heartbeats and arrhythmias. Let's break down your inquiries one by one.


Q1: Strong Heartbeats vs. Arrhythmias
You are correct in noting that strong heartbeats can lead to sensations of palpitations without necessarily indicating an arrhythmia. This phenomenon is often referred to as "palpitations due to increased cardiac output" or "physiological palpitations." When the heart beats forcefully, it can be perceived as a "thumping" sensation in the chest, which is normal and not indicative of an underlying arrhythmia.
In contrast, arrhythmias, such as premature atrial contractions (PACs) or premature ventricular contractions (PVCs), are characterized by irregular heartbeats that can feel like skipped beats or extra beats. While both conditions can cause palpitations, the underlying mechanisms differ. Strong heartbeats are typically a response to increased physical activity, anxiety, or stimulants, while arrhythmias arise from abnormal electrical conduction in the heart.


Q2: Differences Between PACs/PVCs and Strong Heartbeats
The primary difference between PACs/PVCs and strong heartbeats lies in their origin and sensation.
- PACs: These occur when an extra heartbeat originates in the atria. Patients may feel a "fluttering" sensation or a brief pause followed by a stronger beat. Symptoms can include a feeling of skipped beats or a racing heart, but they are generally benign in healthy individuals.

- PVCs: These arise from the ventricles and can feel like a sudden pause followed by a forceful beat. Patients often describe this as a "thump" or "jolt" in the chest. While PVCs can be alarming, they are common and usually not a cause for concern unless they occur frequently or are associated with other symptoms.

In summary, while both conditions can cause palpitations, PACs and PVCs are irregularities in heart rhythm, whereas strong heartbeats are typically a normal physiological response.


Q3: Your Recent Palpitations
Regarding your recent experiences of palpitations, where you felt a heavier heartbeat accompanied by a sense of anxiety, it is likely that these sensations are more aligned with strong heartbeats rather than arrhythmias. The absence of other symptoms, such as dizziness, chest pain, or shortness of breath, suggests that these episodes may be benign.
However, if you are experiencing anxiety or stress, this can also contribute to the sensation of palpitations. Anxiety can lead to increased sympathetic nervous system activity, resulting in stronger heartbeats and a heightened awareness of your heart's rhythm.

Conclusion
In conclusion, while both strong heartbeats and arrhythmias can lead to sensations of palpitations, they are distinct phenomena. Strong heartbeats are typically normal and can be influenced by various factors, including physical exertion and emotional states. In contrast, PACs and PVCs are irregular heartbeats that can also cause palpitations but may require further evaluation if they are frequent or symptomatic.

If your palpitations persist or worsen, or if you develop additional symptoms, it would be prudent to consult with a healthcare professional for further evaluation. They may recommend monitoring your heart rhythm through an ECG or Holter monitor to provide more insight into your heart's activity.

Thank you for your questions, and I hope this information helps clarify your concerns regarding palpitations.

Similar Q&A

Understanding the Differences Between Arrhythmia and Palpitations

Hello, Doctor He. Could you please explain the difference between arrhythmia and palpitations? Are the symptoms the same? Which one is more serious? Which symptom could potentially be life-threatening? When I sleep, my heart rate sometimes ranges from 60 to 65 beats per minute, a...


Dr. He Dongjin reply Cardiology
Hello, the difference between palpitations and arrhythmia is that palpitations refer to the sensation of feeling one's own heartbeat, which does not necessarily indicate an arrhythmia. Sometimes, when a person is anxious, the heart may beat more forcefully, leading to this s...

[Read More] Understanding the Differences Between Arrhythmia and Palpitations


Understanding the Difference Between Heart Palpitations and Exercise-Induced Heart Rate

Hello doctor, I previously visited a physician due to palpitations and irregular episodes of tachycardia, but the cardiac examination showed no significant issues. I was advised to exercise more to lower my resting heart rate. However, I am a bit confused about how the heart diff...


Dr. Wu Xueming reply Cardiology
Many factors in daily life can cause an increased heart rate, such as emotions, stress, irregular sleep patterns, or excessive consumption of caffeinated beverages. Life-threatening arrhythmias are usually associated with heart disease or structural problems in the heart. If you ...

[Read More] Understanding the Difference Between Heart Palpitations and Exercise-Induced Heart Rate


Understanding Heart Palpitations: Panic Attacks or Cardiac Issues?

Hello, I would like to ask about my previous experience of suddenly feeling my heart racing a few times, which led me to see a cardiologist. I underwent the following tests: echocardiogram and a 24-hour Holter monitor for continuous monitoring over several years. Here are the rec...


Dr. He Dongjin reply Cardiology
Hello, if there are no issues after 24 hours, it should be a panic attack. Sudden acceleration of the heart rate will not worsen, so don't worry. Changhua Hospital cares about you.

[Read More] Understanding Heart Palpitations: Panic Attacks or Cardiac Issues?


Palpitations and Arrhythmias: Understanding Your Heart Health Risks

Hello Doctor, recently I have experienced episodes during sleep where my heart beats strongly and accelerates (about twice a month). I underwent a 24-hour Holter monitor test, which only detected two instances of arrhythmia (however, the strong acceleration did not occur on that ...


Dr. He Dongjin reply Cardiology
Hello, anxiety can cause your heart to beat strongly and accelerate, which is known as palpitations. It's not a disease. A 24-hour Holter monitor showed no issues, so there's no need to worry about sudden cardiac death. Everything is fine. Changhua Hospital cares about ...

[Read More] Palpitations and Arrhythmias: Understanding Your Heart Health Risks


Related FAQ

Palpitations

(Cardiology)

Arrhythmia

(Cardiology)

Rapid Heartbeat

(Cardiology)

Heart Rate

(Cardiology)

Pulse

(Cardiology)

Tachycardia

(Internal Medicine)

Ectopic Beats

(Cardiology)

Electrocardiogram

(Internal Medicine)

Lightheadedness

(Cardiology)

Autonomic Nervous System Dysfunction

(Cardiology)