You should see a hand surgeon or an orthopedic specialist?
Four weeks ago, I accidentally pricked the tip of my right finger with a thorn from a winter melon.
I have been unable to remove it, and while there is no visible foreign body upon surface examination, I occasionally experience sharp pain when using my phone or turning on light switches.
During this time, I visited the dermatology department at Hsinchu Military Hospital (using a magnifying glass from a bookstore) and the orthopedic department (since it is not metal, X-rays were not possible), but to no avail.
I also consulted a private dermatology clinic with a handheld magnifying glass of higher magnification, but still found no results.
I am considering visiting a larger hospital like National Taiwan University Hospital in Hsinchu or Linkou Chang Gung Memorial Hospital (taking into account the differences in equipment).
Which department should I see? Dermatology? General Surgery? Plastic Surgery, or Family Medicine? Thank you!
alen, 50~59 year old female. Ask Date: 2022/11/26
Dr. Peng Xianwen reply Surgery
General surgery, plastic surgery, and orthopedics are all suitable, while dermatology is less appropriate.
Director Peng Hsien-Wen of the General Surgery Department at Nantou Hospital.
Reply Date: 2022/11/26
More Info
When dealing with an embedded thorn in the finger, especially when it has been present for an extended period and is causing pain, it is crucial to consult the appropriate medical specialty to ensure proper diagnosis and treatment. Given your situation, where the thorn is not visible on the surface and has not been successfully located by dermatologists or orthopedic specialists, the best course of action would be to consult an Orthopedic Surgeon or a General Surgeon.
Why Orthopedic or General Surgery?
1. Expertise in Soft Tissue Injuries: Both orthopedic and general surgeons are well-trained in handling soft tissue injuries, including foreign body removal. They have the skills necessary to explore deeper tissues if the thorn is embedded beneath the skin.
2. Advanced Imaging Techniques: While X-rays may not detect non-metallic foreign bodies, surgeons often have access to advanced imaging techniques such as ultrasound or MRI, which may help locate the thorn more effectively.
3. Surgical Intervention: If the thorn is indeed embedded and cannot be removed through non-invasive means, a surgeon can perform a minor surgical procedure to extract it safely. This is particularly important if the thorn is causing ongoing pain or risk of infection.
Other Considerations
- Dermatology: While dermatologists are specialists in skin conditions, they may not have the tools or experience to deal with embedded foreign bodies effectively, especially if they are not visible. However, if you have concerns about skin reactions or infections, a dermatologist can still provide valuable insights.
- Plastic Surgery: If there is significant damage to the surrounding tissue or if the thorn has caused complications that affect the appearance or function of the finger, a plastic surgeon may be involved in the repair process. However, this is typically a secondary consideration after the thorn is removed.
- Family Medicine: A family physician can provide initial assessment and referrals but may not have the specialized skills necessary for foreign body removal.
Recommendations
1. Seek an Orthopedic or General Surgeon: Given your symptoms and the history of unsuccessful attempts to locate and remove the thorn, I recommend making an appointment with an orthopedic surgeon or a general surgeon at a reputable hospital, such as National Taiwan University Hospital or Linkou Chang Gung Memorial Hospital.
2. Prepare for the Appointment: Bring any medical records from your previous consultations, including notes from the dermatologists and orthopedic specialists. This information will help the surgeon understand your case better.
3. Discuss Imaging Options: Ask about the possibility of advanced imaging techniques that could help locate the thorn before any surgical intervention.
4. Monitor Symptoms: Keep track of any changes in symptoms, such as increased pain, swelling, or signs of infection (redness, warmth, discharge), and report these to your healthcare provider.
Conclusion
In summary, for an embedded thorn in your finger that has not been successfully located or removed, consulting an orthopedic surgeon or a general surgeon is the most appropriate course of action. They have the expertise and resources to address your condition effectively, ensuring that you can return to your normal activities without pain.
Similar Q&A
Choosing the Right Specialist for Trigger Finger Surgery: A Guide
Xiaomin, unable to find a medical consultation website to ask questions, reluctantly turned to the mailbox for inquiries. The question: Xiaomin's wife is experiencing pain in her thumb, and after consulting a doctor, she was diagnosed with "trigger finger" inflamma...
Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
Trigger finger can be treated conservatively in addition to surgical intervention. This means reducing the use of the affected finger, performing rehabilitation exercises in warm water, or using medication for treatment. It may improve with these methods. If it does not improve, ...[Read More] Choosing the Right Specialist for Trigger Finger Surgery: A Guide
Dealing with Nail Issues: When to Seek Medical Attention
Hello, doctor. Yesterday while at work, I felt a slight pain in my little finger, but I didn't pay much attention to it. This morning, I noticed that the nail had embedded into the flesh, but it was at the edge of the nail. Normally, I only trim the white part of the nail. I...
Dr. Li Zhonghuai reply Surgery
Replied![Read More] Dealing with Nail Issues: When to Seek Medical Attention
Which Specialist to Consult for a Painful Finger Joint Lump?
Hello, I have a lump on the first joint of my right index finger. It's transparent and about the size of a mung bean. It hurts a lot when I bump it, and there is also internal bleeding. The skin peels off, and after peeling, it shrinks, but it grows back larger after two wee...
Dr. Ye Qianyu reply Family Medicine
Hello! Since the lesion could not be visualized, it is recommended that you first consult a dermatologist. If the physician has other diagnoses, they may refer you to a different specialty. Thank you for your inquiry, and I wish you a speedy recovery![Read More] Which Specialist to Consult for a Painful Finger Joint Lump?
Which Medical Specialty to Consult for Ingrown Toenail Correction?
Which department should I visit for ingrown toenail correction? Hello, as stated in the subject, I do not have athlete's foot or any past injuries; I suspect it may be caused by sports. I have an ingrown toenail on the left side of my right big toe, but there is no inflammat...
Dr. Lu Daokuan reply Plastic Surgery
If the ingrown nail is growing deeper into the nail groove, consulting a plastic surgeon is feasible. Whether to schedule another appointment for treatment will depend on whether surgery is necessary. Any hospital with a plastic surgery department should be able to assist.[Read More] Which Medical Specialty to Consult for Ingrown Toenail Correction?
Related FAQ
(Surgery)
Finger Fracture(Orthopedics)
Paronychia(Surgery)
Trigger Finger(Orthopedics)
Finger Joint(Internal Medicine)
Fingers(Dermatology)
Finger(Neurology)
Keloid(Surgery)
Lump On The Palm(Surgery)
Thumb(Neurosurgery)