Navigating Conflicting Dental Treatment Recommendations: What to Do?

Q: Navigating Conflicting Dental Treatment Recommendations: What to Do?

Hello： According to what you mentioned, Clinic A did not provide you with a follow-up treatment plan. <br>Clinic B suggested that you undergo further periodontal treatment. <br>The attending physician at Hospital C stated that you can choose to proceed or not. <br>In other words,

What should I do when there are different treatment recommendations?

Hello.
In mid-November, I felt discomfort around the root of my first premolar and went to Clinic A for an examination.
The dentist performed a teeth cleaning (during the process, the dentist mentioned that my brushing was fairly good, but it was more painful when cleaning the first premolar, while the others were fine).
After the cleaning, the other three first premolars also started to feel uncomfortable, with persistent spontaneous pain, increased pain when biting, and weakness when chewing soft acidic foods.
(The affected areas all showed gum recession with exposed roots.
I had orthodontic treatment about ten years ago, and there were signs of gum recession with black triangles appearing, but recently I feel the recession has worsened.) Later, I went to Clinic B to see a periodontist, who diagnosed me with gingival inflammation and early periodontal disease.
They performed periodontal probing on two affected areas, finding a depth of 5mm and calculus beneath the gums; percussion testing on the affected areas was not very painful, but biting on cotton caused pain.
They prescribed anti-inflammatory and pain relief medications and suggested I undergo periodontal treatment afterward.
After taking the medication, one tooth felt somewhat better, but the other three still hurt.
Subsequently, I visited Hospital C for a periodontal specialist examination, where full-mouth X-rays and several small X-rays were taken.
The resident diagnosed me with severe gingival inflammation, no periodontal disease, thin and sensitive gums, and recommended gum graft surgery.
During the process, percussion and periodontal probing were performed on two affected areas.
The attending physician said that if surgery is to be done, it should proceed.
I have an appointment next week for a follow-up cleaning and evaluation.
What should I do regarding the different treatment recommendations? Thank you.

Orla, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2022/12/06

Dr. Lin Jiayong reply Dentistry

Hello: According to what you mentioned, Clinic A did not provide you with a follow-up treatment plan.
Clinic B suggested that you undergo further periodontal treatment.
The attending physician at Hospital C stated that you can choose to proceed or not.
In other words, it is optional.
Therefore, you should consider whether you would like to pursue the follow-up periodontal treatment at Clinic B.
Ultimately, medical decisions should be made by the patient to avoid excessive disputes and controversies in the future.
It is advisable to clarify the follow-up timeline, costs, advantages, and disadvantages of the periodontal treatment at Clinic B before making a final decision.

Reply Date: 2022/12/06

More Info

Navigating conflicting dental treatment recommendations can be a challenging experience, especially when multiple professionals provide differing opinions on the best course of action. In your case, you have received varying diagnoses and treatment suggestions from three different dental clinics regarding your dental issues, particularly concerning your first molar and associated gum problems. Here’s how to approach this situation effectively.

Understanding the Recommendations
1. A Clinic: Initially, you visited A Clinic for a cleaning, where the dentist noted some discomfort but did not provide a follow-up treatment plan. This suggests that while they acknowledged the discomfort, they may not have identified a significant underlying issue.

2. B Clinic: At B Clinic, a periodontist diagnosed you with gum inflammation and early-stage periodontal disease. They performed probing and found pockets of 5mm, indicating a need for periodontal treatment. They prescribed anti-inflammatory and pain relief medications, suggesting a more proactive approach to your gum health.

3. C Hospital: The evaluation at C Hospital led to a different conclusion, where the intern diagnosed severe gum inflammation but ruled out periodontal disease. They recommended gum surgery to address the thin and sensitive gums.

Steps to Take
1. Gather Information: Start by compiling all the information you have received from each clinic. This includes the diagnoses, treatment recommendations, and any diagnostic images (like X-rays) that were taken. Having a clear record will help you understand the differences in opinions.

2. Seek a Second Opinion: If you feel uncertain about the recommendations, it may be beneficial to seek a second opinion from another dental professional, preferably a periodontist or an oral surgeon. They can review your case and provide additional insights based on their expertise.

3. Ask Questions: When consulting with your dentist or periodontist, don’t hesitate to ask questions about the rationale behind their recommendations. Inquire about the potential risks and benefits of each proposed treatment, the expected outcomes, and the timeline for recovery.

4. Consider Your Symptoms: Reflect on your symptoms and how they have progressed. If you are experiencing persistent pain, discomfort, or other issues, it may indicate that a more aggressive treatment approach is necessary.
5. Evaluate Treatment Options: Discuss the treatment options in detail. For instance, if B Clinic suggests periodontal treatment, ask about the specific procedures involved, the duration of treatment, and the expected results. Similarly, inquire about the gum surgery recommended by C Hospital, including its necessity and potential benefits.

6. Make an Informed Decision: Ultimately, the decision should be based on a combination of professional advice, your understanding of the situation, and your comfort level with the proposed treatments. It’s essential to choose a path that aligns with your health goals and personal circumstances.

Additional Considerations
- Patient Autonomy: Remember that you have the right to make decisions about your dental care. If you feel uncomfortable with a recommendation, it’s okay to seek alternatives or delay treatment until you feel more informed.

- Long-term Health: Consider the long-term implications of each treatment option. Periodontal disease, if left untreated, can lead to more severe dental issues, including tooth loss. Therefore, addressing gum health proactively is crucial.

- Follow-Up Care: Regardless of the path you choose, ensure that you have a plan for follow-up care. Regular check-ups and cleanings are vital for maintaining oral health, especially if you have a history of gum issues.

In conclusion, navigating conflicting dental treatment recommendations requires careful consideration, open communication with dental professionals, and a proactive approach to your oral health. By gathering information, seeking second opinions, and asking questions, you can make informed decisions that align with your health needs and preferences.

Similar Q&A

Deciding Between Dental Treatments: A Patient's Dilemma

Recently, I received laser treatment for periodontal disease (costing 70,000 TWD), and the treatment has concluded (saying that laser treatment is painless is really misleading). However, there was no improvement (my teeth were very painful the week after the procedure), so I tra...

Dr. Wu Jinjun reply Dentistry
Hello: The treatment for periodontal disease currently relies on traditional methods such as plaque control, debridement of periodontal tissues, and effective oral hygiene education and training for better outcomes. The efficacy of lasers in the treatment of periodontal disease h...

Managing Dental Abscesses: Seeking Second Opinions and Treatment Options

Hello, Doctor. I would like to inquire about a situation I encountered three weeks ago. I discovered a pus-filled bump on the gum of my upper left incisor. That week, I made an appointment with a dentist who, within ten minutes of visual examination without taking X-rays, informe...

Dr. Lin Jiayong reply Dentistry
Hello: 1. Under the general health insurance system, root canal treatment requires pre- and post-treatment X-rays, so there should typically be a pre-treatment X-ray available, or there may already be an X-ray taken of that tooth at the clinic, along with established treatment in...

Switching Dentists: How to Address Poor Dental Work and Costs

Hello~ Recently, I went to a dentist for a filling, but each time I leave, I end up with new issues. The doctor always says, "Let's prioritize getting it filled before addressing aesthetic concerns," which results in the fillings looking worse than if I hadn't...

Dr. Lin Jiayong reply Dentistry
Hello: It is recommended to find a physician you trust. After stating your purpose, it is best if the physician is willing to assist you. If the issue exceeds the physician's scope of practice, asking the physician to issue a referral to a medical center for further manageme...

Essential Considerations for Orthodontics and Dentures: A Comprehensive Guide

1. Is it necessary to be free of periodontal disease in order to undergo orthodontic treatment (Invisalign)? 2. Should cavities be filled and a periodontal treatment plan completed before starting orthodontic treatment? 3. Can unhealthy last molars be extracted and bone anchors p...

Dr. Zeng Guanghui reply Dentistry
1. It is essential to complete the treatment of periodontal disease before orthodontic treatment. 2. Prior to orthodontic treatment, any cavities should be filled, and periodontal disease treatment must be completed. 3. It is advisable to consult an orthodontist regarding the...