What to Do If a Dental File Breaks During Root Canal Treatment? - Dentistry

Share to:

What should be done if a file breaks inside the root canal during root canal treatment?


Dear Director,
I underwent root canal treatment at a local dental clinic, where the dentist performed the procedure five times over nearly two months and took four X-rays.
My tooth continued to be sensitive and painful until the sixth visit, when the doctor explained after taking another X-ray that a tool (needle) had broken inside the root canal.
He issued a referral for me to go to a larger hospital for what he called a "microscopic examination." I am very concerned and would like to ask you:
1.
Given that I have mitral valve regurgitation and mild thalassemia, is there any risk associated with having a broken needle inside the tooth root? Why is this a concern? What are the treatment options?

2.
What does a "microscopic examination" entail? Is it something that cannot be performed at a general hospital? Can I seek treatment at Taoyuan Hospital?
I apologize if my wording is inappropriate in my anxiety, and I sincerely hope you can take the time from your busy schedule to clarify my concerns.
I would be extremely grateful!

kitty, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2003/11/04

Dr. Liu Tiancai reply Dentistry


Hello! The files used in general root canal treatment are made of stainless steel.
If the root canal is curved, narrow, or if the file experiences elastic fatigue, there is a possibility of breakage within the canal.
The instrument itself will not have adverse effects on the body; however, a broken file can obstruct the canal, potentially leading to issues with debridement and inadequate filling.
It is advisable to seek treatment at dental clinics equipped with microscopes, such as National Taiwan University Hospital, Tri-Service General Hospital, or Veterans General Hospital.
A broken file does not pose a danger related to the condition you described.
Our hospital will be acquiring a microscope next year to better serve our patients.
Sincerely, Dr.
Liu Tian-Cai, Director of Dentistry, Taoyuan Hospital, Ministry of Health and Welfare.

Reply Date: 2003/11/04

More Info


When a dental file breaks during a root canal treatment, it can be a concerning situation for both the patient and the dentist. Here’s a comprehensive overview of what to do in such cases, especially considering your specific health conditions.

1. Understanding the Situation: The first step is to understand that a broken dental file, while unfortunate, is not uncommon in root canal procedures. Dentists use files to clean and shape the root canal system, and sometimes, despite their best efforts, a file can break. The critical factor is whether the broken piece is located within the root canal system and whether it can be safely removed.

2. Risks Associated with a Broken File: Given your medical history of mitral valve prolapse and mild thalassemia, it’s essential to approach this situation with caution. The presence of a broken file can lead to complications such as infection or incomplete cleaning of the canal, which may exacerbate any existing dental issues. However, the immediate risk of a broken file itself is generally low, as long as it remains within the canal and does not cause any acute symptoms like severe pain or swelling.

3. Next Steps in Treatment: Your dentist has recommended a referral to a larger hospital for a "microscopic examination." This is a prudent step. A microscope allows for a more detailed view of the root canal system, enabling the dentist to assess the situation accurately. They can determine if the file can be retrieved or if alternative treatments are necessary.
4. Microscopic Examination: This procedure involves using a dental operating microscope to visualize the root canal system in detail. It can help identify the location of the broken file and assess the condition of the surrounding tissues. Not all dental offices have this technology, which is why your dentist may have referred you to a specialized facility. Larger hospitals or dental specialty clinics are more likely to have the necessary equipment and expertise to handle such cases.

5. Potential Treatment Options: If the broken file can be retrieved, the dentist will proceed with that. If retrieval is not possible, they may consider other options, such as:
- Non-surgical retreatment: This involves re-entering the canal to clean and disinfect it, potentially using different techniques to manage the broken file.

- Surgical intervention: In some cases, an apicoectomy (surgical removal of the tip of the root) may be necessary to address any infection and to remove the broken file.

- Extraction: If the tooth cannot be saved, extraction may be the last resort.

6. Follow-Up Care: After the procedure, it’s crucial to follow your dentist’s instructions for care. Given your health conditions, maintaining good oral hygiene and attending regular check-ups will be vital to prevent further complications.

7. Consultation with Your Physician: Since you have pre-existing health conditions, it may also be beneficial to consult with your physician before undergoing any dental procedures. They can provide guidance on managing your health during dental treatments.

In conclusion, while the situation of a broken dental file can be alarming, it is manageable with the right care and expertise. Ensure you follow through with the referral for a microscopic examination, and maintain open communication with both your dentist and physician regarding your health and treatment options. Your proactive approach to seeking clarification and understanding your treatment is commendable and will serve you well in navigating this dental issue.

Similar Q&A

Impacts of Leaving a Broken Dental File in Root Canal Treatment

After undergoing root canal treatment for a cavity, the file broke during the procedure. Attempts to retrieve it microscopically were unsuccessful after 7 to 8 tries. Ultimately, surgery was performed to open the gum and remove the broken piece, but a small fragment remains fused...


Dr. Lin Jiayong reply Dentistry
Hello: 1. It is recommended to have long-term X-ray imaging to monitor for any lesions. 2. If there are significant concerns, you may undergo a CT scan of the head and neck at a medical center to confirm the position of the broken needle, and then assess whether general anesthesi...

[Read More] Impacts of Leaving a Broken Dental File in Root Canal Treatment


Dealing with Broken Dental Needles and Deep Cavities: What to Do?

About three years ago, I underwent root canal treatment. Since I experienced slight pain when tapping on the tooth, I have not had a crown placed. Later, I visited another clinic, and the dentist informed me that there is a broken file inside the tooth. What should I do? Addition...


Dr. Huang Zhicheng reply Dentistry
1. If there is a broken endodontic file and symptoms are present, it is advisable to seek treatment from an endodontic specialist. In some cases, the broken file may need to be removed using specialized ultrasonic instruments under a microscope, followed by disinfection and compl...

[Read More] Dealing with Broken Dental Needles and Deep Cavities: What to Do?


Is It Necessary to Remove a Broken File During Root Canal Treatment?

After taking an X-ray of the tooth, a suspected broken needle was found inside, and the X-ray showed severe inflammation. The dentist recommended redoing the root canal treatment. I would like to ask if it is necessary to remove the broken needle during the root canal treatment?


Dr. Huang Tingfang reply Dentistry
Dear Mr. AU: Hello! Of course, extraction is the best option! It is advisable to consult an endodontist! Please communicate more with the doctor! Thank you! Wishing you safety! Sincerely, Dr. Huang Ting-Fang, Dentistry

[Read More] Is It Necessary to Remove a Broken File During Root Canal Treatment?


Understanding Root Canal Treatment: Addressing Post-Procedure Complications

Hello, about three to four years ago, I had a root canal treatment. Since then, I have had a few cracks in that tooth, but there haven't been any significant issues. Recently, I noticed a small black spot on that tooth, and when I used an interdental brush to poke at it, it ...


Dr. Zeng Guanghui reply Dentistry
Teeth that have undergone root canal treatment can develop cavities in the crown area if proper oral hygiene is not maintained, leading to crown damage or fracture. Additionally, teeth that have had root canal therapy tend to have more brittle dentin, making them more susceptible...

[Read More] Understanding Root Canal Treatment: Addressing Post-Procedure Complications


Related FAQ

Root Canal Treatment

(Dentistry)

Root Fracture

(Dentistry)

Tooth Crack

(Dentistry)

Post-Extraction

(Dentistry)

Tooth Abscess

(Dentistry)

Dental Pulp

(Dentistry)

Gum Recession

(Dentistry)

Occlusal Splint

(Dentistry)

Retained Tooth

(Dentistry)

Pain

(Dentistry)