Wound management after a car accident?
There are sutures and abrasions (stage 2) on the elbow, and there are also abrasions on the knee.
Regarding wound care, I was initially advised by the doctor to keep it bandaged when I first visited.
When I went to the pharmacy to buy medication, they also recommended bandaging.
However, during my follow-up visit for a dressing change, the doctor only applied povidone-iodine and told me that the wound could be rinsed with water and should not be covered or bandaged, and that I didn't need to apply any ointment, just the povidone-iodine was sufficient.
Which method is correct? Should I bandage it or not?
Mr. Lin, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2023/01/12
Dr. Li Zhonghuai reply Surgery
Hello! The wound should be cleaned daily with sterile saline solution and a sterile cotton swab.
This method has its advantages, although it can be quite painful.
After cleaning, apply antibiotic ointment.
Of course, some physicians may have different approaches, such as allowing tap water contact and not covering the wound.
I observed various practices at another hospital, where they used antibiotics to press down on dirty scabs.
However, our hospital's principle is to perform daily debridement, maintain sterility, and properly dress the wound.
I cannot tolerate even a grain of sand in the wound, and contact with tap water is strictly prohibited.
Just for your reference! Take care! Changhua Hospital cares about you!
Reply Date: 2023/01/12
More Info
When it comes to wound care after a bike accident, particularly for abrasions and sutured areas, the approach can vary based on the type and severity of the wound. Your situation involves a stage 2 abrasion and a sutured area on your elbow, as well as abrasions on your knee. The conflicting advice you've received from different healthcare providers can understandably cause confusion.
Understanding Wound Care
1. Types of Wounds:
- Abrasions: These are superficial wounds that affect only the outer layer of skin (epidermis). They can be painful and prone to infection if not cared for properly.
- Sutured Wounds: These are deeper wounds that require stitches to close the skin. Proper care is essential to ensure healing and prevent complications.
2. Initial Care:
- After an injury, the first step is to clean the wound thoroughly. This usually involves rinsing it with clean water to remove debris and bacteria. Avoid using alcohol or hydrogen peroxide directly on the wound, as these can damage tissue and delay healing.
3. Dressing the Wound:
- For Sutured Wounds: It is generally recommended to keep sutured wounds covered with a sterile dressing for the first few days to protect them from infection and to absorb any drainage. After a few days, if the wound is healing well and there are no signs of infection, the dressing may be changed to a breathable bandage or left open to air.
- For Abrasions: The approach can vary. Some healthcare providers recommend keeping abrasions covered with a non-stick dressing to protect them from further injury and to keep the area moist, which can promote healing. Others may suggest leaving them uncovered to allow for air exposure, especially if the wound is healing well and not at risk for infection.
The Debate: To Wrap or Not to Wrap?
- Wrapping the Wound:
- Pros: Keeping the wound covered can protect it from dirt and bacteria, reduce pain from exposure to air, and help maintain a moist environment, which is beneficial for healing.
- Cons: If the dressing is too tight or not changed regularly, it can trap moisture and bacteria, leading to infection. Additionally, if the dressing adheres to the wound, it can cause pain when removed.
- Leaving the Wound Uncovered:
- Pros: Air exposure can help dry out the wound and may reduce the risk of maceration (softening of the skin due to prolonged moisture). It can also allow for better visibility to monitor for signs of infection.
- Cons: Uncovered wounds are more susceptible to dirt and bacteria, which can lead to infection, especially in areas that are prone to friction or movement.
Recommendations
Given the conflicting advice you've received, here are some general guidelines:
1. Follow Up with Your Doctor: Since your doctor has advised you to leave the wound uncovered after applying iodine, it is essential to follow their instructions, especially if they have assessed your wound and deemed it appropriate for open air exposure.
2. Monitor for Infection: Regardless of whether you cover the wound or not, keep an eye out for signs of infection, such as increased redness, swelling, warmth, pus, or increased pain. If you notice any of these symptoms, seek medical attention promptly.
3. Keep the Area Clean: If you choose to leave the wound uncovered, ensure that the area remains clean. You can gently wash it with mild soap and water during your daily hygiene routine.
4. Consider Moisture Management: If you find that the wound is drying out too much or becoming painful, you might consider using a non-stick dressing that allows for some moisture retention while still protecting the wound.
5. Consult a Wound Care Specialist: If you have ongoing concerns or if the wound does not seem to be healing properly, consider consulting a wound care specialist who can provide tailored advice based on your specific situation.
In conclusion, the best approach to wound care can depend on various factors, including the type of wound, its location, and your overall health. Always prioritize cleanliness, monitor for signs of infection, and follow your healthcare provider's recommendations.
Similar Q&A
Post-Accident Wound Care: Expert Advice on Stitch Management
Hello Dr. Lee, I had a car accident on December 11, resulting in an injury above my ankle. I received nine stitches in the emergency room. The photo below was taken on the morning of December 16 when I changed the dressing myself. https://lurl.cc/6wwvz I have consulted two doctor...
Dr. Li Zhonghuai reply Surgery
Hello! The photo appears to show cellulitis, and the blood circulation is not very good. After changing the dressing, clean the area with sterile saline solution; of course, the tissue fluid inside should be drained, apply ointment, and cover it with a gauze. The wound should not...[Read More] Post-Accident Wound Care: Expert Advice on Stitch Management
Understanding Slow Healing Wounds After a Motorcycle Accident
Hello Doctor, I had a bike accident recently and have been going to the clinic daily for dressing changes. Most of my wounds have healed, but the small wound on the top of my foot is deeper, so it is healing more slowly. The wound is shown in the image below: https://i.imgur.com/...
Dr. Li Zhonghuai reply Surgery
Hello! After an injury, it is recommended to apply scar gel for hyperpigmentation. Skin whitening is very important for women! Take care! Changhua Hospital cares about you![Read More] Understanding Slow Healing Wounds After a Motorcycle Accident
Understanding Lacerations: Treatment, Risks, and Recovery Insights
Hello Dr. Huang, I fell off my motorcycle on a rainy day and went to the emergency room. I received a deep laceration on the dorsum of my foot that required a single suture (using a stapler-like closure for a wound nearly 5 cm long) and I have severe bruising on my knee. I was n...
Dr. Huang Junxiong reply Surgery
Hello, Here are the answers to your questions: 1. There are many factors that can influence wound infection. Common causes include: 1. Incomplete debridement 2. Inadequate hemostasis during closure 3. Poor suturing technique 4. Inadequate wound care. As for using a specific su...[Read More] Understanding Lacerations: Treatment, Risks, and Recovery Insights
Understanding the Proper Use of Artificial Skin for Wound Care
Hello, doctor. I had a motorcycle accident a week ago, resulting in a scrape on my left knee that is about the size of half a palm. After returning home, I cleaned the wound, and my mother applied Neomycin ointment and sprayed a powder similar to talcum powder on it, then covered...
Dr. Huang Junxiong reply Surgery
Hello, the use of artificial skin is appropriate only when the wound is confirmed to be free of infection. Generally, for external injuries such as abrasions from motorcycle accidents, there is a high risk of infection in the early stages, making the use of artificial skin inadvi...[Read More] Understanding the Proper Use of Artificial Skin for Wound Care
Related FAQ
(Surgery)
Wounds From Car Accident(Surgery)
After Car Accident(Surgery)
Postoperative Care(Surgery)
Burn(Surgery)
Head Injury(Surgery)
Bruising(Surgery)
Scar(Plastic Surgery)
Toe Injury(Surgery)
Post-Inguinal Hernia Surgery(Surgery)