Incomplete extraction of a decayed tooth?
Hello Dr.
Lin, during my orthodontic evaluation, the orthodontist suggested that I first see another dentist to extract my upper left cavity before proceeding with orthodontics.
After the extraction, the orthodontist discovered during the treatment that the previous extraction was not completely clean and there was residual tooth root left.
They recommended that I have it fully extracted and referred me to a specialist.
I would like to ask Dr.
Lin, does this mean that the initial dentist who extracted my cavity made a medical error?
Ivy, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2023/01/14
Dr. Lin Jiayong reply Dentistry
Hello: It is advisable to discuss this issue with your orthodontist.
Reply Date: 2023/01/14
More Info
Hello! Thank you for your question regarding the extraction of your tooth and the subsequent findings of a retained root. This situation raises important considerations about dental care responsibilities and the standards of care expected from dental professionals.
To begin with, it’s essential to understand that tooth extractions, particularly for teeth affected by decay (caries), should be performed with a thorough assessment of the tooth's condition. The dentist performing the extraction is responsible for ensuring that the entire tooth, including the roots, is removed. If a root fragment is left behind, it can lead to complications such as infection, pain, or the need for further surgical intervention, as you have experienced.
In your case, the initial extraction was performed by a different dentist, and the subsequent discovery of a retained root by your orthodontist indicates that the extraction may not have been completed to the standard of care expected in dentistry. The standard of care refers to the level of care that a reasonably competent dentist would provide under similar circumstances. If the extraction was done without ensuring that all parts of the tooth were removed, it could be considered a lapse in the standard of care, potentially qualifying as a dental negligence or malpractice issue.
However, it is also important to consider the context in which the extraction was performed. Factors such as the complexity of the extraction, the condition of the tooth, and the dentist's judgment at the time all play a role. For instance, if the tooth was severely decayed or fractured, it might have been challenging to visualize and remove the entire root. In such cases, the dentist may have acted within the bounds of reasonable care, even if the outcome was not ideal.
If you believe that the initial dentist did not meet the standard of care, you may want to discuss this with them directly. It is possible that they may not have been aware of the retained root and could provide insight into their extraction technique. Additionally, if you feel that the situation warrants it, you could consider seeking a second opinion from another dental professional or consulting with a dental malpractice attorney to explore your options.
In terms of your ongoing dental care, it is crucial to follow through with the recommended extraction of the retained root. Leaving a root fragment in place can lead to further complications, including infection or the development of a cyst. After the extraction, ensure that you maintain regular dental check-ups to monitor your oral health, especially as you proceed with orthodontic treatment.
In summary, while the situation you described may indicate a potential oversight by the initial dentist, it is essential to consider all factors involved. Open communication with your dental care providers and seeking further evaluations will help ensure that you receive the best possible care moving forward. If you have any more questions or concerns, feel free to ask!
Similar Q&A
Is Your Tooth Extraction Complete? Understanding Post-Extraction Concerns
Last night, I had a tooth extraction (for orthodontic purposes) and had my lower left premolar removed. However, today I keep feeling a sharp, hard, protruding area on the gum where the tooth was extracted, and it hurts (unlike the normal healing tissue). It seems like the tooth ...
Dr. Chen Yingfang reply Dentistry
Please return for outpatient treatment.[Read More] Is Your Tooth Extraction Complete? Understanding Post-Extraction Concerns
Common Dental Concerns: Wisdom Teeth, Root Canals, and Myths
Hello, Doctor: 1. Should wisdom teeth generally be extracted? Additionally, after anesthesia, will there be no pain during the extraction? Once the anesthesia wears off, will there be significant pain? 2. I previously underwent root canal treatment, and the original dentist st...
Dr. Zeng Guanghui reply Dentistry
Hello Sir: Thank you for your inquiry. I would like to respond to your question and provide the following advice: If your wisdom teeth are growing in a tilted position and cannot be properly cleaned, leading to recurrent oral infections, it is advisable to have them extracted. Du...[Read More] Common Dental Concerns: Wisdom Teeth, Root Canals, and Myths
Can I Sue My Dentist for Extracting a Tooth Without Anesthesia?
If a dentist extracted your tooth without anesthesia when you were supposed to receive a filling for a cavity, you may have grounds to file a complaint or pursue legal action against the dentist for malpractice. It is important to consult with a legal professional who specializes...
Dr. Yang Zhiren reply Dentistry
Hello: This situation usually occurs when the extracted tooth already had severe periodontal disease and was itself loose (meaning it could have fallen out on its own). I am not aware of the circumstances at that time, and your description is not very clear. If an X-ray of that a...[Read More] Can I Sue My Dentist for Extracting a Tooth Without Anesthesia?
Should You Extract a Loose Tooth After an Injury? Expert Advice
Hello, I had an injury to my upper left incisor near the canine due to a car accident ten years ago, and it has been slightly loose. Recently, I visited a dental clinic, and one dentist said that if the tooth doesn't hurt, I don't need to worry about it. However, anothe...
Dr. Liu Tiancai reply Dentistry
Hello: After dental trauma, there are various possible phenomena, including crown fracture, pulp necrosis, root resorption, root fracture, tooth displacement, and alveolar bone fracture. Your description is insufficient for making a diagnosis; if you could provide X-rays, it woul...[Read More] Should You Extract a Loose Tooth After an Injury? Expert Advice
Related FAQ
(Dentistry)
Tooth Extraction(Dentistry)
Toothache(Dentistry)
Teeth Cleaning(Dentistry)
Tooth Alignment(Dentistry)
Tooth Trauma(Dentistry)
Tooth Root(Dentistry)
Apicoectomy(Dentistry)
Tooth Abscess(Dentistry)
Dentures(Dentistry)