Effectiveness of Periodontal Flap Surgery Without Bone Graft - Dentistry

Share to:

Periodontal flap surgery


Dear Doctor: After undergoing basic treatment for periodontal disease at the hospital, my doctor mentioned that I need to have periodontal flap surgery, which may require bone grafting.
However, the hospital only offers bone grafts from human and bovine sources, which I am somewhat opposed to, and I would prefer to use synthetic bone grafts.
Therefore, I would like to know if it is effective to perform periodontal flap surgery without bone grafting.
Will the surgery potentially worsen my dental condition? I hope to at least maintain the current stability of my teeth.

Miss Wang, 50~59 year old female. Ask Date: 2023/03/09

Dr. Zeng Guanghui reply Dentistry


If periodontal surgery is performed without the use of bone graft material, and only the periodontal defects are removed, the height of the alveolar bone will decrease, the gums will recede, and the spaces between the teeth will widen.
It is advisable to have further discussions with a periodontist.
Dr.
Tseng Guang-Hui, Department of Dentistry, Nantou Hospital.

Reply Date: 2023/03/09

More Info


Periodontal flap surgery is a common procedure used to treat advanced periodontal disease, particularly when there is significant attachment loss and bone loss around the teeth. The primary goal of this surgery is to gain access to the roots of the teeth and the underlying bone to remove plaque, tartar, and infected tissue. This can help to reduce inflammation, promote healing, and ultimately improve the stability of the teeth.

When considering the effectiveness of periodontal flap surgery without the addition of a bone graft, it is essential to understand the role of bone grafting in this context. Bone grafts are often used to help regenerate lost bone and provide a stable foundation for the teeth. In cases where there is significant bone loss, a graft can enhance the healing process and improve the long-term outcomes of the surgery. However, it is possible to perform flap surgery without a graft, and many practitioners do so based on the specific clinical situation.

If you choose to undergo flap surgery without a bone graft, the effectiveness of the procedure will largely depend on the extent of periodontal disease and the condition of the surrounding tissues. In some cases, flap surgery alone can lead to improved periodontal health and stabilization of the teeth, especially if the disease is not too advanced. The removal of infected tissue and thorough cleaning of the root surfaces can significantly reduce bacterial load and inflammation, which may help to maintain the existing attachment levels.

However, there are some risks associated with not using a bone graft. Without the graft, there may be a higher likelihood of further bone loss over time, particularly if the underlying periodontal disease is not adequately controlled. Additionally, if there is significant bone loss prior to surgery, the absence of a graft may result in less favorable outcomes, such as increased mobility of the teeth or a return of periodontal disease.

It is also important to consider your concerns regarding the materials used for bone grafting. If you have reservations about using human or bovine-derived bone grafts, you should discuss this with your dentist or periodontist. There are synthetic bone graft materials available that can be used as alternatives, and your dental professional can help you weigh the pros and cons of each option based on your individual case.

In terms of recovery, flap surgery typically involves a healing period of about two weeks, during which you may experience some swelling and discomfort. Following the procedure, it is crucial to maintain good oral hygiene and follow your dentist's post-operative care instructions to promote healing and prevent complications.

Ultimately, the decision to proceed with flap surgery without a bone graft should be made in consultation with your dental professional. They can assess your specific situation, including the extent of periodontal disease and the condition of your teeth and bone, to determine the best course of action. If you are concerned about the potential for your teeth to worsen after surgery, it is essential to communicate these concerns with your dentist, who can provide guidance and reassurance based on their clinical experience and knowledge.

In summary, while flap surgery can be performed without a bone graft, the long-term effectiveness may vary based on individual circumstances. It is crucial to have an open discussion with your dental care provider about your options, including the use of synthetic graft materials, to ensure that you receive the most appropriate treatment for your periodontal health.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Periodontal Inflammation: Is Bone Grafting Effective?

Hello Dr. Yang, In the past year, I have been experiencing frequent inflammation in my upper right back tooth. When it flares up, I am unable to chew food, and there is pain when I bite down. A dental clinic in Miaoli mentioned that my periodontal condition is severe and that I ...


Dr. Yang Zhiren reply Dentistry
Hello: First, look at the periodontal pocket and periapical X-ray of this tooth. If there is vertical periodontal bone loss, bone grafting can be effective; however, if there is horizontal periodontal bone loss, the effect is limited. If the tooth has significant mobility, it ind...

[Read More] Understanding Periodontal Inflammation: Is Bone Grafting Effective?


Comparing Periodontal Treatments: Gel vs. Flap Surgery for Gum Disease

Hello, Doctor. I have already seen a dentist at a clinic near my home, and the dentist diagnosed me with periodontal disease, recommending periodontal flap surgery and regenerative surgery. However, another dentist suggested using a periodontal gel instead (without surgery). I wo...


Dr. Wu Jinjun reply Dentistry
Hello: 1. Periodontal gel is a medicated gel that is applied into the periodontal pocket. While this gel can inhibit the growth of anaerobic bacteria within the periodontal pocket, its effectiveness still needs to be observed. For teeth with moderate to severe periodontal damage,...

[Read More] Comparing Periodontal Treatments: Gel vs. Flap Surgery for Gum Disease


Can Gum Surgery Replace Scaling for Periodontal Disease?

Can a patient with periodontal disease skip scaling and directly undergo gingival flap surgery? What are the potential complications of gingival flap surgery? I am a patient with moderate to severe periodontal disease.


Dr. Huang Tingfang reply Dentistry
Dear Mr. Joe, Hello! It is necessary to perform scaling for dental calculus. Otherwise, there is a high risk of infection even after periodontal flap surgery. Please communicate more with your dentist. Thank you! Wishing you safety and health! Sincerely, Dr. Huang Ting-Fang, ...

[Read More] Can Gum Surgery Replace Scaling for Periodontal Disease?


Concerns After Bone Grafting: What to Expect Post-Dental Surgery

Hello Dr. Huang: Recently, I had a dental bridge with three crowns placed on my upper front teeth. The left front tooth has been missing for a long time, which caused gum recession. After your examination and assessment, I underwent a bone grafting procedure with a resorbable mem...


Dr. Huang Tingfang reply Dentistry
Dear Miss Belle, Hello! As mentioned, this situation is normal! However, please note that the bone graft needs at least 4 months to heal, so it should not be subjected to occlusal pressure to avoid deformation or damage. Please communicate frequently with your physician! Thank y...

[Read More] Concerns After Bone Grafting: What to Expect Post-Dental Surgery


Related FAQ

Periodontal

(Dentistry)

Cheekbone

(Plastic Surgery)

Post-Wisdom Tooth Surgery

(Dentistry)

Apicoectomy

(Dentistry)

Alveolar Bone

(Dentistry)

Dental Implant

(Dentistry)

Gum Recession

(Dentistry)

Missing Teeth

(Dentistry)

Root Fracture

(Dentistry)

Oral Ulcer

(Dentistry)