Optimal Care for Burns: Silver Ointment, Artificial Skin, or Bandages? - Surgery

Share to:

Which method is better for the care of burn wounds?


Hello, I recently suffered a burn from a soldering iron, and the epidermis has already peeled off at the time of the injury.
I initially rinsed the area with cool water and applied "Silzine" ointment along with a non-adherent gauze dressing.
Currently, there is no pain when I do not touch, pull, or expose it to water.
I would like to ask whether I should continue with this dressing method, or if I should directly apply artificial skin, or use a combination of artificial skin and ointment.
Which option would be more suitable at this stage?

Ting, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2023/04/12

Dr. Peng Xianwen reply Surgery


Hello Mr.
Ting: Different stages require different methods of medication application, and the severity of the wound will also have an impact.
Director Peng Hsien-Wen, General Surgery, Nantou Hospital.

Reply Date: 2023/04/12

More Info


When it comes to optimal care for burns, especially second-degree burns, it is crucial to follow a structured approach to ensure proper healing and minimize the risk of infection. Based on the information provided and general medical knowledge, I will address your question regarding the use of silver ointment, artificial skin, and bandages for your burn care.

First and foremost, it is essential to understand the nature of your burn. Second-degree burns involve damage to both the epidermis (the outer layer of skin) and part of the dermis (the second layer of skin). These burns can be characterized by redness, swelling, pain, and blisters. The initial treatment you described—cooling the burn with running water and applying a silver sulfadiazine ointment (Silzine) along with a non-adherent dressing—is a standard and effective approach for managing second-degree burns.

Silver sulfadiazine is a topical antibiotic that helps prevent infection and promotes healing. It is particularly beneficial for burns because it has both antimicrobial properties and a soothing effect on the damaged skin. The use of a non-adherent dressing is also appropriate, as it protects the wound from external contaminants while allowing for some moisture retention, which is vital for healing.

Regarding your question about whether to continue with your current dressing, switch to artificial skin, or use a combination of artificial skin and ointment, here are some considerations:
1. Continue Current Dressing: If your burn is not showing signs of infection (such as increased redness, swelling, pus, or worsening pain), and you are comfortable with the current treatment, it is advisable to continue using the silver sulfadiazine ointment with the non-adherent dressing. This method allows for regular monitoring of the wound and provides a protective barrier.

2. Artificial Skin: Artificial skin, or bioengineered skin substitutes, can be beneficial for certain types of burns, particularly when there is a significant loss of skin or when the wound is not healing adequately. However, the decision to use artificial skin should be made by a healthcare professional based on the specific characteristics of your burn. If your burn is still in the early stages of healing (as indicated by your description of the wound), it may not yet be appropriate to switch to artificial skin. Typically, artificial skin is considered when the wound has progressed to a certain level of healing or if there is a concern about the wound's ability to heal on its own.

3. Combination Approach: Using artificial skin in conjunction with topical ointments can sometimes be effective, but again, this should be guided by a healthcare provider. The combination can provide a moist environment conducive to healing while also offering protection from infection.

In summary, your current approach of using silver sulfadiazine and a non-adherent dressing is appropriate for managing your second-degree burn. It is crucial to monitor the wound closely for any signs of infection and to follow up with a healthcare provider for further evaluation and guidance on whether transitioning to artificial skin is necessary. Healing from second-degree burns typically takes 2-3 weeks, and if the wound does not show signs of improvement after this period, further medical intervention, such as skin grafting, may be required.

Always remember that individual cases can vary significantly, so it is essential to consult with a healthcare professional for personalized advice and treatment options tailored to your specific situation.

Similar Q&A

Effective Wound Care for Second-Degree Burns: Best Practices and Tips

Hello Doctor: I accidentally burned my foot on the exhaust pipe on July 26, resulting in a large wound. Concerned about infection, I sought treatment at a nearby clinic, where the doctor diagnosed it as a second-degree burn. For the past few days, I have been caring for the wound...


Dr. Huang Junxiong reply Surgery
1. This is a second to third degree burn. 2. For wound dressing changes, Silver Sulfadiazine ointment can be used, once a day. 3. Currently, the use of "artificial skin" dressings is not appropriate. 4. Dressing changes are needed approximately every 2-3 weeks for the w...

[Read More] Effective Wound Care for Second-Degree Burns: Best Practices and Tips


Understanding Scar Treatment Options After Burns: Gels vs. Ointments

Hello Doctor: I had a burn with blisters a month ago, and I have been using artificial skin since then. The wound is healing, and the skin is red. I wear long pants and skirts for sun protection. I would like to ask about scar removal products, specifically the differences betwee...


Dr. Wu Yuxin reply Dermatology
It mainly depends on the area affected. If it is a joint, it is recommended to use ointments or gels rather than adhesive patches, as they may not adhere well.

[Read More] Understanding Scar Treatment Options After Burns: Gels vs. Ointments


How to Care for Second-Degree Burns at Home: Essential Tips and Advice

I would like to ask about my mother's inner thigh burns. Both of her legs have extensive burns, approximately second-degree, with the left leg being more severe, having several blisters larger than a finger. She went to the hospital for emergency care at the time, and in the...


Dr. Lu Daokuan reply Plastic Surgery
Burns require daily dressing changes at the hospital, as the risk of infection is high with self-treatment. Blisters should only be punctured after complete disinfection; oily ointments should not be used. It is not always necessary to receive anti-inflammatory injections; it is ...

[Read More] How to Care for Second-Degree Burns at Home: Essential Tips and Advice


Understanding Burn Wound Care: Insights from Plastic Surgery

Hello, Doctor. I had a motorcycle accident and was treated at the hospital, where the physician assessed my wounds as second and third-degree burns. A week ago, I was prescribed Silvadene (silver sulfadiazine) cream to apply at home. After applying the medication, the wound gradu...


Dr. Shi Wenbin reply Plastic Surgery
In deeper wounds, eschar forms, with dry black eschar being hard and, after being softened by moisture, turning into white soft eschar, which is easier to remove. Once removed, the wound can heal more readily. The white burn ointment provided to you can promote the softening of t...

[Read More] Understanding Burn Wound Care: Insights from Plastic Surgery


Related FAQ

Burn

(Surgery)

Wound Healing

(Surgery)

Burns

(Dermatology)

Skin Graft

(Plastic Surgery)

Wounds From Car Accident

(Surgery)

Wound

(Internal Medicine)

Paronychia

(Surgery)

Hemorrhoid Ointment

(Surgery)

Bruising

(Surgery)

Cellulitis

(Surgery)