Challenges in Managing Hydrocephalus: When Shunt Drainage Fails

The patient has symptoms of hydrocephalus and has had a shunt installed. The drainage is set to maximum, but the results are not satisfactory?

Dear Dr.
Zhang,
My mother is 67 years old.
In 2018, she underwent surgery for a carotid artery aneurysm that was compressing her brainstem and cerebellum, causing difficulty in walking on one side.
Due to the size of the aneurysm, the procedure involved embolization followed by clipping.
Immediately after the surgery, she was somewhat lethargic, but her walking improved significantly compared to before the operation.
We thought everything was fine and that rehabilitation would be sufficient to maintain her health.
However, around 2021, her condition began to deteriorate.
She started walking as if her feet were glued to the floor, experienced urinary incontinence, and her speech and cognitive processing noticeably slowed down.
After researching and consulting with doctors, we suspected hydrocephalus.
In 2022, she underwent a lumbar puncture for examination.
On the same day of the procedure, I observed improvements in her speech and walking.
Subsequently, we had an adjustable drainage catheter placed (from the lumbar region to the abdominal cavity).
On the day after the surgery, my mother spoke very fluently, which was a feeling we hadn't experienced in a long time.
At that moment, we felt it was effective.
However, within a few months, her condition worsened again, returning to the previous state of slow walking and mental fog.
We adjusted the pressure twice, but now it has been set to the maximum outflow capacity, and her condition has not improved.
Tests have indicated that the drainage catheter is not obstructed.

I would like to ask the doctor:
1.
What other options do we have?
2.
What could be the possible reasons for the ineffectiveness of the drainage despite being set to maximum? After the examination or surgery, my mother's condition was always good, so I still believe it is closely related to the drainage of cerebrospinal fluid.
(I apologize if I have offended any professional standards; I have been trying everything possible over the years to help my mother maintain her health.)
Thank you for your assistance in clarifying these concerns!

Ernie, 60~69 year old female. Ask Date: 2023/04/13

Dr. Zhang Junwei reply Neurosurgery

Without detailed examination reports and imaging studies, it is difficult to answer such questions.
If the drainage has been maximized and the condition has not improved, it may not be a problem related to hydrocephalus.
Whether there is an improvement in hydrocephalus can be determined through a CT scan.

Reply Date: 2023/04/13

More Info

Managing hydrocephalus, particularly when shunt drainage fails, presents a significant challenge in neurology and neurosurgery. Hydrocephalus is a condition characterized by an accumulation of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) within the ventricles of the brain, leading to increased intracranial pressure and potential neurological impairment. In your mother's case, it appears that she has a history of significant neurological issues stemming from a carotid artery aneurysm, which complicates her current condition.

1. What other options are available?
When a shunt fails or does not provide adequate drainage, several strategies can be considered:
- Shunt Revision or Replacement: If the current shunt is not functioning properly, a neurosurgeon may recommend revising or replacing the shunt. This could involve replacing the catheter or the valve, or even changing the type of shunt used.

- Endoscopic Third Ventriculostomy (ETV): This is a surgical procedure that creates a new pathway for CSF to flow out of the ventricles, bypassing the obstruction. It is particularly useful in cases where there is a blockage in the normal CSF pathways.

- Medication Management: In some cases, medications that help manage symptoms or reduce CSF production may be considered. However, these are typically adjunctive treatments rather than primary solutions.

- Regular Monitoring: Continuous monitoring of neurological status and regular imaging studies (like MRI or CT scans) can help assess the effectiveness of the current treatment and guide further interventions.

2. Possible reasons for ineffective drainage despite maximum settings:
There are several reasons why a shunt may not be effectively draining CSF even when set to maximum output:
- Obstruction: While imaging has indicated that the shunt is not obstructed, it is still possible for there to be partial blockages or kinks in the catheter that are not easily visible.
- Overdrainage or Underdrainage: If the shunt is draining too much or too little CSF, it can lead to complications such as subdural hematomas or persistent symptoms of hydrocephalus.
- Shunt Malfunction: Mechanical failure of the shunt components can occur, leading to inadequate drainage. This could be due to wear and tear or a manufacturing defect.

- Increased CSF Production: In some cases, the body may produce more CSF than the shunt can handle, leading to persistent symptoms despite adequate drainage.

- Underlying Conditions: Other neurological conditions or complications from previous surgeries may also contribute to the symptoms. For instance, scarring or changes in brain structure from the initial surgery could affect CSF dynamics.

In conclusion, managing hydrocephalus, especially in a post-surgical context, requires a multidisciplinary approach involving neurologists, neurosurgeons, and rehabilitation specialists. It is crucial to maintain open communication with your mother's healthcare team to explore all available options and ensure that her treatment plan is tailored to her specific needs. Regular follow-ups and assessments will be key in navigating this complex condition.

Similar Q&A

Navigating Hydrocephalus Treatment Options: Drainage vs. Shunt Surgery

My mother, who is 50 years old, has been diagnosed with hydrocephalus. One hospital suggested performing a lumbar puncture to drain fluid first, followed by a shunt placement, arguing that the pathway from the brain to the lumbar spine is obstructed, making drainage ineffective. ...

Dr. Zhang Junwei reply Neurosurgery
Patients have different conditions, and the management approaches vary accordingly. It is advisable to visit a medical center or consult multiple hospitals.

Understanding Hydrocephalus: Why Spinal Drainage May Fail

The mother underwent a CT scan and was diagnosed with cerebral edema. The doctor arranged for spinal drainage, but was unable to extract any fluid. Is this due to obstruction or are there other factors involved?

Dr. Zhang Junwei reply Neurosurgery
Cerebral edema cannot be drained, while hydrocephalus can.

Post-Operative Overdrainage in Ventriculoperitoneal Shunt Surgery

Hello Doctor: My father underwent a ventriculoperitoneal shunt surgery at National Taiwan University Hospital over a year ago due to a diagnosis of hydrocephalus. Recently, he exhibited symptoms similar to dementia and went to Renai Hospital for a CT scan, which showed excessive ...

Dr. Qiu Yushu reply Neurosurgery
Hello: There is a possibility of excessive drainage with ventricular-peritoneal shunting (though it is rare). It is advisable to replace it with a drainage device that has a different (higher) pressure setting (there are three types of external drainage device pressures). It is b...

Understanding Drainage Tubes in Neurosurgery: Concerns and Care

Hello: My mother has been in a vegetative state for four months due to a hemorrhagic stroke. At that time, she underwent surgery and had a drainage tube placed internally. Recently, she was hospitalized due to excessive phlegm in her lungs, and it was discovered that there are tw...

Dr. Qiu Yushu reply Neurosurgery
Hello: Examination of the function of the ventriculoperitoneal shunt. 1. Check if it collapses and does not refill. 2. If it cannot be compressed, a consultation with a neurosurgeon is recommended.