Are Impulse Control Disorders Considered Neurotic Disorders? - Psychiatry

Share to:

Is adjustment disorder or impulse control disorder classified as a neurosis?


Hello Dr.
Hsueh, I am a recent graduate this year, and I would like to apply for a voluntary military service.
However, during my middle school years, I visited the pediatric psychiatry department at National Cheng Kung University, and as a result, I was found to have a psychiatric medical record during the military medical bureau's review.
After reviewing the medical documents I sent him, the military doctor stated that I have "Adjustment Disorder" and "Impulse Control Disorder," but he deemed me unfit due to the "Impulse Control Disorder." I noticed in the military recruitment guidelines that it mentions individuals with a history of psychoneurosis would be disqualified.
I would like to ask the doctor if "Impulse Control Disorder" is indeed considered a type of psychoneurosis.
Previously, I asked the doctor at National Cheng Kung University if "Adjustment Disorder" qualifies as psychoneurosis, and he mentioned that it would be somewhat of a stretch to classify it as such.
I really want to know if "Impulse Control Disorder" is classified as psychoneurosis.
If it is not, I would like to discuss with the military medical bureau about undergoing a psychological evaluation, as I genuinely want to serve in the military.
I don't want to be deemed unfit just because I previously sought psychiatric help, especially since I wasn't on medication and my visits were just conversations with the doctor.
Emotions are normal for everyone, so why should having emotions lead to a diagnosis of "Impulse Control Disorder"? My emotions did not require medication for control.
I truly want to understand whether "Impulse Control Disorder" is considered a type of psychoneurosis, as I have not found much information on this topic.
I would appreciate your help in clarifying my doubts.

Nìmíng, 10~19 year old female. Ask Date: 2023/05/02

Dr. Xue Gengming reply Psychiatry


Recommendation: Please consult a psychiatrist at the mental health clinic.
Thank you.
Wishing you good health!

Reply Date: 2023/05/02

More Info


Impulse Control Disorders (ICDs) are classified as a group of mental health disorders characterized by the inability to resist a temptation, urge, or impulse that may harm oneself or others. These disorders include conditions such as Intermittent Explosive Disorder, Kleptomania, Pyromania, and others. The classification of these disorders can sometimes lead to confusion regarding their categorization within the broader spectrum of mental health disorders, particularly in relation to neurotic disorders.

Neurotic disorders, often referred to as anxiety disorders or psychoneuroses, are characterized by excessive anxiety or irrational fears that can lead to significant distress and impairment in functioning. They include conditions such as Generalized Anxiety Disorder, Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder (OCD), and Phobias. The key distinction between neurotic disorders and impulse control disorders lies in the nature of the symptoms and the underlying mechanisms.

Impulse Control Disorders are not typically classified as neurotic disorders. Instead, they are often categorized under the broader umbrella of disruptive, impulse-control, and conduct disorders in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5). This classification reflects the focus on the inability to control impulses rather than the anxiety or fear-driven symptoms characteristic of neurotic disorders.

In your case, the diagnosis of "Impulse Control Disorder" may have been made based on specific behaviors or patterns observed during your assessment. It is essential to understand that having a diagnosis does not inherently mean that you are unfit for military service. The military's medical standards can vary, and they often take into account the severity of the disorder, the presence of symptoms, and how these may impact your ability to perform duties.

Regarding your concerns about being deemed unfit for service due to a diagnosis of Impulse Control Disorder, it is crucial to communicate openly with the military medical board. You may want to request a psychological evaluation to provide a clearer picture of your mental health status. This evaluation can help determine whether your symptoms are currently manageable and whether they significantly impair your functioning.

It's also worth noting that many individuals experience emotional fluctuations and challenges without necessarily meeting the criteria for a mental health disorder. The fact that you did not require medication or intensive treatment suggests that your symptoms may not be severe. Engaging in regular conversations with a healthcare provider, as you mentioned, can be a healthy way to process emotions and experiences.

In summary, while Impulse Control Disorders are not classified as neurotic disorders, they are recognized as distinct mental health conditions. If you believe that your diagnosis does not accurately reflect your current mental health status, pursuing a psychological evaluation could be beneficial. This step may provide you with the opportunity to clarify your situation and potentially challenge the military's decision regarding your fitness for service. Remember, mental health is a complex and nuanced field, and seeking clarity and support is always a positive step forward.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Neurotic Disorders: What Mental Illnesses Are Included?

In the context of insurance exclusions for mental disorders, "neurosis" typically includes conditions such as depression, bipolar disorder, anxiety disorders, and certain stress-related disorders. However, it generally does not include neurodegenerative diseases like de...


Dr. Guo Jialun reply Psychiatry
Psychoneurosis is not a specific diagnostic term, and it is currently not included in the American Psychiatric Association's Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM). This term generally refers to mild mental disorders, such as anxiety disorders, phobias, ...

[Read More] Understanding Neurotic Disorders: What Mental Illnesses Are Included?


Understanding Childhood-Onset Psychotic Disorders: A Guide for Students

What are "psychotic disorders originating in childhood"? Are childhood-onset neurotic disorders considered "psychotic disorders originating in childhood"? I am currently a university student and have been diagnosed with anxiety disorder and obsessive-compulsiv...


Dr. Huang Xiaoxian reply Psychiatry
Dear Chen, thank you for your question. You mentioned psychotic disorders originating in childhood, which generally refer to autism and pervasive developmental disorders, and your current symptoms fall into a different category, so there is no need to worry too much. Anxiety diso...

[Read More] Understanding Childhood-Onset Psychotic Disorders: A Guide for Students


Understanding Intrusive Thoughts and Impulses: A Mental Health Perspective

Hello, doctor. Actually, I don't quite understand my issue; I just know that I seem to have some symptoms of attention deficit, so I came to consult you. I apologize if I'm mistaken. As a child, I was someone who found it difficult to concentrate, and sometimes I would ...


Dr. Song Chengxian reply Psychiatry
Hello Kai-Hsuan, based on your description, it seems that you have been experiencing persistent obsessive thoughts, poor concentration, and involuntary movements. I recommend that you seek evaluation from a psychiatrist or a mental health specialist to assess whether you may have...

[Read More] Understanding Intrusive Thoughts and Impulses: A Mental Health Perspective


Understanding Repetitive Checking Behavior: Is It Perfectionism or Something More?

Could I ask Dr. Wang again if my behavior of repeatedly checking things is due to my overly anxious or perfectionist personality? (This happens only for things I care about.) Moreover, it seems to occur only in certain specific situations and not in all aspects of daily life, so ...


Dr. Wang Chongren reply Psychiatry
Dear Dr. Wang Chong-Jen of the Tainan Hospital, Department of Psychiatry, Executive Yuan Health Department: I apologize if my previous response was misleading. The differential diagnosis of obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) includes many conditions (including obsessive-compuls...

[Read More] Understanding Repetitive Checking Behavior: Is It Perfectionism or Something More?


Related FAQ

Neurotic Disorder

(Psychiatry)

Compulsive Behavior

(Psychiatry)

Fetishism

(Psychiatry)

Psychoneurosis

(Neurology)

Psychosomatic Disorders

(Psychiatry)

Emotional Instability

(Psychiatry)

Adhd-Related

(Psychiatry)

Adjustment Disorder

(Psychiatry)

Binge Eating

(Psychiatry)

Involuntary Psychiatric Treatment

(Psychiatry)