Persistent Swelling in the Right Eyelid: Allergy or Structural Issue?

Swelling occurring only at the right eyelid raises concerns about a potential structural issue in the right eyelid?

Hello, Doctor: My son is 20 years old and has had a tendency for eye allergies since childhood.
Currently, he still experiences symptoms of eye allergies, though not as severely as when he was younger.
His current symptoms include tearing 1-2 times a day in both eyes, itching in both eyes 2-3 times, and swelling in a roughly 1 cm area of the eyelid near the inner corner of the right eye (which is not very red and has some peeling).
Although applying a topical steroid like Betamethasone for 2-3 days reduces the swelling, it often recurs.
Notably, only the eyelid near the right inner corner experiences this swelling; the left eyelid has never been swollen (when itching occurs, both eyes itch simultaneously, but for some reason, the left inner corner has never swollen).
Since childhood, my son has frequently had discharge from the right inner corner of the eye, and he has undergone invasive nasolacrimal duct examinations, which showed no issues with duct narrowing.
Doctors have attributed the tearing and itching to allergies, and I understand it is difficult to eliminate allergens.
It does not significantly disrupt daily life, so I would like to focus on the swelling of the eyelid above the right inner corner (as it affects appearance).
I would like to ask the doctor: 1) If it is still an allergy, and both inner corners experience the same itching and rubbing, why does only the right inner corner swell? Could there be a structural issue with the right inner corner? 2) If there is no structural issue with the right inner corner, is the information provided sufficient for the doctor to make a preliminary assessment of what might be causing the swelling of the eyelid above the inner corner? (Could it be eyelid dermatitis?) Thank you, Doctor.

Zheng, 50~59 year old female. Ask Date: 2023/05/31

Dr. He Jianxian reply Ophthalmology

It is unclear why your son is experiencing this condition only at the outer corner of the right eye while the left eye is unaffected.
However, it is quite common for clinical lesions to present asymmetrically.
The likelihood of structural abnormalities is theoretically low, but if allergies are indeed severe, in addition to topical medications such as eye drops or ointments, oral medications may also be necessary.
This is provided for your reference.
Director He Jianxian, Department of Ophthalmology, Nantou Hospital.

Reply Date: 2023/05/31

More Info

Understanding persistent swelling in the eyelid, particularly in a case like your son's, requires a careful consideration of various factors, including allergies, structural issues, and other dermatological conditions. Given the symptoms you've described, let's delve into the possible causes and provide some guidance.

1. Allergic Reactions
Your son's history of eye allergies suggests that the swelling in the right eyelid could indeed be related to an allergic reaction. Allergies can manifest in various ways, including localized swelling, redness, itching, and tearing. The fact that the swelling occurs primarily in the right eyelid, despite both eyes experiencing itchiness and tearing, raises the question of whether there might be a localized sensitivity or an irritant that is affecting only that side.

2. Structural Issues
While allergies are a common cause of eyelid swelling, structural issues could also be a factor. The eyelids are made up of various tissues, including skin, muscle, and fat. If there is an anatomical difference or a structural issue in the right eyelid, it could predispose it to swelling. For instance, conditions such as chalazia (blocked oil glands), cysts, or even previous trauma could lead to localized swelling. However, since you mentioned that your son has undergone a nasal duct examination with no issues found, it seems less likely that a structural problem is the primary cause.

3. Dermatitis or Eczema
Another possibility is that the swelling could be related to a form of dermatitis, such as contact dermatitis or eyelid eczema. This condition can cause localized swelling, redness, and flaking skin. Given that the swelling is accompanied by some peeling, this could indicate a dermatological issue rather than an allergic one. If the skin around the eyelid is dry or irritated, it may lead to a cycle of itching and swelling.

4. Diagnosis and Treatment
To address your concerns effectively, it would be beneficial for your son to see an ophthalmologist or a dermatologist specializing in ocular conditions. They can perform a thorough examination, which may include:
- Visual Inspection: To assess the nature of the swelling and any associated symptoms.

- Allergy Testing: If allergies are suspected, skin tests or blood tests can help identify specific allergens.

- Skin Scraping or Biopsy: If dermatitis is suspected, a sample of the affected skin may be taken for further analysis.

5. Management Strategies
In the meantime, here are some management strategies that may help alleviate your son's symptoms:
- Cold Compresses: Applying a cold compress to the swollen eyelid can help reduce swelling and provide relief from itching.

- Antihistamines: Over-the-counter antihistamines may help control allergic symptoms.

- Moisturizers: If dryness is an issue, using a gentle, hypoallergenic moisturizer around the eyelid may help.

- Avoiding Irritants: Identifying and avoiding potential irritants, such as certain soaps, cosmetics, or environmental allergens, can be beneficial.

Conclusion
In summary, while the persistent swelling in your son's right eyelid could be due to allergies, it is essential to consider other factors such as structural issues or dermatological conditions. A thorough examination by a healthcare professional will provide a clearer understanding and guide appropriate treatment. If the swelling continues or worsens, seeking medical advice promptly is crucial to prevent any potential complications.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Lower Eyelid Swelling: Causes and Concerns

Hello, my brother-in-law has developed swelling in the lower eyelid of his right eye, along with a discomfort that feels like something is inside the eye. However, after seeing an ophthalmologist, he was told that there is nothing wrong. The swelling has persisted for over a mont...

Dr. Wang Zhishun reply Ophthalmology
Hello, if the ophthalmologist has checked and found no issues, the more common causes of swelling in the lower eyelid are related to the nose or skin lymphatic edema. If the discomfort persists, you might want to explore these areas first. Thank you!

Persistent Eye Puffiness: Causes, Treatments, and Expert Insights

I have been experiencing chronic swelling in my eyes, specifically only on the right side, which has caused my double eyelid to turn into a single eyelid. I have seen over ten doctors; some suggested that it might be dry eye syndrome and prescribed artificial tears, but it hasn&#...

Dr. Hu Yusheng reply Ophthalmology
Dear Miss Ami, You have been experiencing long-term swelling in your right eye, which has not improved despite being treated as an allergic issue, and thyroid hyperactivity has been ruled out. It is recommended that you consult a physician to prescribe oral antihistamines to see...

Sudden Eyelid Swelling: Causes, Allergies, and Treatment Options

When I woke up in the morning and cleared my eye discharge, everything seemed fine. However, after putting in my contact lenses and preparing to do my makeup, I noticed that my right upper eyelid suddenly became very swollen. The double eyelid crease was swollen all the way up to...

Dr. Cai Wenyuan reply Ophthalmology
Hello, the common causes of sudden eyelid swelling are indeed as you mentioned. If it is due to an allergy, it should not last too long after medication, but the specifics may depend on the actual situation. Wishing you safety and health. Sincerely, Dr. Tsai Wen-Yuan, Director of...

Should You See a Rheumatologist for Persistent Allergy Symptoms?

Two weeks ago, on Monday night, I stayed up late and woke up the next morning to find that my lower eyelid was swollen, extending to my cheekbone. I confirmed there was no external trauma and thought it might be due to allergies and fatigue, expecting the swelling to subside. By ...

Dr. Zeng Guosen reply Internal Medicine
Hello, based on your situation, it may be angioedema, which can have many causes, with allergies being just one of them. I recommend that you visit a dermatologist or an immunology/rheumatology specialist for further evaluation and treatment. Thank you for your question.