Challenges in Changing Tracheostomy Tubes: A Case Study - Pulmonology

Share to:

Issues with Changing Tracheostomy Tubes


Hello Dr.
Zhou,
Background of the issue: My 65-year-old mother has a tracheostomy tube that needs to be replaced in about a month.
After a consultation with the ENT department at Hospital C, an endoscopy revealed that there is dry secretions in the trachea, making it difficult to replace the tube.
Initially, Hospital C suggested that the patient return to Hospital A for the procedure.
If performed at Hospital C, it would require going to the operating room and anesthesia.
The doctor mentioned that the surgery carries life-threatening risks, including the risk of a second stroke and significant bleeding.
Question (1): In April and May, the tracheostomy tube was replaced at Hospitals A and B, which was a simple and direct replacement without any surgical intervention.
Is the issue of dry secretions in the trachea severe enough to necessitate a high-risk surgery, or are there alternative management options?
Question (2): The doctors at Hospital C speculate that the dry secretions are due to the caregivers not properly cleaning the tracheostomy tube.
Is maintaining the cleanliness of the tracheostomy tube the responsibility of the caregivers? (We have also consulted with a pulmonologist at Hospital A, who indicated that the hospital where the patient is located would generally handle such matters unless the hospital lacks the necessary equipment.)
Hospitalization background: On March 8, 2023, my mother was hospitalized at Hospital A due to a hemorrhagic stroke.
After the first extubation, she experienced respiratory failure and required re-intubation.
In late March, the attending physician recommended a tracheostomy, which was performed by a pulmonologist on March 27.
On April 12, the tracheostomy tube was replaced at Hospital A with a model that allows for speech practice.
Due to health insurance regulations, she was transferred to Hospital B at the end of April, where the tube was replaced again on May 10.
According to the doctor, the tracheostomy tube needs to be replaced every month.
She was transferred to Hospital C on May 22, with the next replacement scheduled for June 8 based on Hospital B's recommendation.
At the end of May, the rehabilitation physician at Hospital C consulted with an ENT specialist, who indicated that the inner tube was difficult to insert and that the brand of the tracheostomy tube was different from what is typically used at Hospital C, leading to uncertainty about a successful procedure.
An endoscopic examination revealed dry secretions in the trachea, and the doctor advised against direct replacement due to the risk of significant bleeding, explaining to the family that surgery would be necessary, which carries substantial risks.
The anesthesiologist also warned that the situation could become severe enough to require ECMO support.
Management from March to June at various hospitals:
- Hospital A: The tracheostomy tube was cleaned daily by nurses, and mucolytic medication was administered via the tracheostomy tube.
- Hospital B: The tracheostomy tube was cleaned three times daily by nurses, and mucolytic medication was administered via the tracheostomy tube.
Oxygen was gradually removed to practice spontaneous breathing.
- Hospital C: The tracheostomy tube is cleaned daily by nurses, and mucolytic medication is administered via a nebulizer.
They have now discovered dry secretions and have started administering pure oxygen in hopes of softening the dry secretions.
Patient status: She has suffered a brain injury and stroke, is partially paralyzed, has a nasogastric tube, a tracheostomy tube, and just had her urinary catheter removed.
She can breathe independently (without supplemental oxygen).
In April, during suctioning, it was noted that the secretions were more viscous, so mucolytic treatment has been continuously administered.

Jiaoji de jiashu, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2023/06/06

Dr. Zhou Ziguang reply Pulmonology


Hello: The question involves the patient's actual condition and the existing equipment at the hospital, which requires clinical evaluation.
Please discuss the follow-up treatment plan with the original physician.

Reply Date: 2023/06/06

More Info


Changing a tracheostomy tube can present various challenges, particularly in patients with complex medical histories, such as your mother. In this case study, we will address the concerns raised regarding the difficulties encountered during the tube change, the implications of dry secretions in the trachea, and the responsibilities of caregivers in maintaining tracheostomy care.

1. Challenges in Changing the Tracheostomy Tube:
The situation described indicates that your mother has been experiencing difficulties with her tracheostomy tube change due to the presence of dry secretions in the trachea. This can complicate the procedure significantly. In general, when a tracheostomy tube needs to be changed, it is typically a straightforward process; however, if there are complications such as thick, dry secretions, the risk of bleeding or injury to the trachea increases.
The recommendation from C hospital to perform the procedure in an operating room under anesthesia is likely a precautionary measure. The presence of dry secretions can lead to a situation where the tube cannot be easily replaced, and if force is applied, it could result in trauma to the trachea, potentially leading to significant complications, including excessive bleeding or the need for more invasive interventions, such as re-intubation or even the use of ECMO (extracorporeal membrane oxygenation) in severe cases.

In your previous experiences at A and B hospitals, the successful changes of the tracheostomy tube without complications suggest that the situation may have changed due to factors such as the type of tube used, the technique employed, or the patient's current condition. It is essential to assess whether the tube is compatible with the patient's anatomy and whether the care protocols for managing secretions have been adequately followed.

2. Maintaining Tracheostomy Tube Hygiene:
Regarding the cleaning and maintenance of the tracheostomy tube, it is indeed a shared responsibility between healthcare providers and caregivers. While nurses typically perform daily cleaning and suctioning, caregivers should also be educated on how to assist in maintaining the tube's hygiene. This includes regular cleaning of the outer cannula, ensuring that the inner cannula (if present) is cleaned or replaced as needed, and monitoring for signs of infection or blockage.

The suggestion that the dry secretions may be due to inadequate cleaning by caregivers highlights the importance of proper education and training for those involved in the patient's care. Caregivers should be instructed on the importance of hydration, the use of humidification, and the administration of mucolytics or other medications to help manage secretions effectively.

Conclusion:
In summary, the challenges faced during your mother's tracheostomy tube change are multifaceted and may require a collaborative approach involving healthcare professionals and caregivers. It is crucial to address the underlying issues contributing to the dry secretions, such as ensuring proper hydration and humidification, and to educate caregivers on their role in maintaining tracheostomy care. If the situation remains unresolved, seeking a second opinion or further evaluation from a specialist may be beneficial to ensure the best possible outcome for your mother.

Similar Q&A

Navigating Tough Decisions: A Family's Dilemma on Life Support Options

Dear Doctors of the e-Hospital in Taiwan, Hello! I previously wrote to inquire about my father, who has been intubated for over a month. The doctors have stated that he is 100% dependent on the ventilator for survival and will never be able to be weaned off it. They have been ur...


Dr. Liao Yaopan reply Family Medicine
Hello, would you like to understand the situation regarding "tracheostomy"? Based on the aforementioned circumstances, the chances of successfully extubating in the short term are low. I personally recommend that a tracheostomy is a better option for an assisted airway....

[Read More] Navigating Tough Decisions: A Family's Dilemma on Life Support Options


Can Patients with Severe Intellectual Disability Train for Tracheostomy Removal?

Two years ago, my brother was hospitalized for choking and required emergency treatment. After intubation and subsequent observation, his blood oxygen levels dropped and his breathing became weak, necessitating re-intubation. Due to the inability to remove the tube in the short t...


Dr. Cai Zongwei reply Pulmonology
Hello: The removal of the tracheostomy tube requires the evaluation of multiple indicators and cannot be based solely on cognitive assessment. Additionally, according to regulations, this medical consultation cannot provide a diagnosis. Please consult the original treating physic...

[Read More] Can Patients with Severe Intellectual Disability Train for Tracheostomy Removal?


Post-Tracheostomy Care: Managing Coughing and Voice Changes

It has been about four months since my elderly family member had their tracheostomy tube removed, and they still experience frequent coughing. Are there any care methods available, or should we just learn to adapt to the frequent coughing? Their voice has been hoarse since the tu...


Dr. Yang Wenda reply Pulmonology
Hello: 1. After extubation, if there is hoarseness, please consult an otolaryngologist to check for any issues with the vocal cords. 2. The cough issue is not significantly related to the removal of the tracheostomy tube, unless there is excessive sputum. The airway at the origin...

[Read More] Post-Tracheostomy Care: Managing Coughing and Voice Changes


Post-Tracheostomy Care: Addressing Wound Healing and Future Risks

Hello, thank you for your previous response. My mother has had her tracheostomy tube removed for over three months now, and she is recovering well. However, the healing wound on her neck has turned into a small deep hole, and the skin inside is healing. My mother is worried that ...


Dr. Zhuang Ziyi reply Pulmonology
Hello: 1. The tracheostomy wound will gradually heal on its own over time, and it is generally covered with a scarf for both aesthetic and practical purposes. 2. It may not necessarily be a complication of the tracheostomy. Older patients often have reduced elasticity in the ...

[Read More] Post-Tracheostomy Care: Addressing Wound Healing and Future Risks


Related FAQ

Tracheostomy

(Pulmonology)

Trachea

(Pulmonology)

Difficulty Breathing

(Pulmonology)

Copd

(Pulmonology)

Ct Report

(Pulmonology)

Choking

(Pulmonology)

Tuberculosis

(Pulmonology)

Sputum

(Otolaryngology)

Bronchiectasis

(Pulmonology)

Postoperative Lung Adenocarcinoma

(Pulmonology)