Can I Change Dentists for a Tooth Filling Within Two Years? - Dentistry

Share to:

Changing doctors?


I had a tooth that was filled about three years ago.
Last year, the filling done by my dentist fell out, so I went to another dentist for a replacement.
Recently, the filling fell out again, and I wanted to switch to a different dentist.
However, when I asked the receptionist, she told me that I cannot change dentists for the same tooth within two years.
Is it really not possible for me to switch dentists if I want to? I have switched dentists before.
Is there such a regulation?

Miss Lin, 50~59 year old female. Ask Date: 2024/03/26

Dr. Lin Jiayong reply Dentistry


Hello: If the tooth is no longer suitable for restoration and the dentist has informed you before the filling, but you still wish to restore the tooth's shape and function after the filling has fallen out, it is recommended to follow the original dentist's advice for treatment.
This may involve root canal therapy followed by the placement of a dental post and a ceramic crown for restoration, or if the tooth cannot be preserved and there is a risk of acute or chronic infection, it should be decisively extracted.
If more than two clinics are unable to address your condition, it is advisable to seek help from the dental department of a medical center in the area.
Regarding health insurance regulations, if you want to know the details, it is recommended to consult the local dental association (peer regulations) and the local health insurance bureau.

Reply Date: 2024/03/26

More Info


Changing dentists for a tooth filling or any dental treatment is generally a personal choice and should not be restricted by any formal regulations. In the United States, patients have the right to choose their healthcare providers, including dentists, at any time. If you are unhappy with the treatment you received or the quality of care from your current dentist, you are entitled to seek a second opinion or switch to a different dentist without any legal or ethical repercussions.

In your case, it seems that you have had a filling done on a tooth that has not held up well, leading to multiple visits and repairs. It's understandable that you would want to find a dentist who you feel is more competent or better suited to your needs. The comment from the receptionist about not being able to change dentists for the same tooth within two years is likely a misunderstanding or a miscommunication. There are no universal rules that prevent patients from switching dentists for the same tooth or treatment.

When considering a new dentist, it’s important to do your research. Look for reviews, ask for recommendations from friends or family, and consider the dentist's qualifications and experience. You might also want to inquire about their approach to dental care, especially regarding fillings and restorative work.
If you decide to switch dentists, here are some steps you can take:
1. Request Your Dental Records: You have the right to request your dental records from your current dentist. This includes any X-rays, treatment notes, and details about the fillings that have been done. Having this information will help your new dentist understand your dental history and the specific issues with your tooth.

2. Communicate Your Concerns: When you visit the new dentist, be open about your previous experiences and what you are looking for in terms of treatment. This will help them tailor their approach to your needs.

3. Discuss Treatment Options: Depending on the condition of the tooth, the new dentist may suggest different treatment options. If the filling has repeatedly failed, they might recommend a more durable solution, such as a crown or an inlay/onlay, which can provide better protection and longevity.

4. Follow-Up Care: After receiving treatment from the new dentist, ensure you follow up as recommended. Regular check-ups can help catch any issues early and maintain your dental health.

5. Insurance Considerations: If you have dental insurance, check with your provider to ensure that the new dentist is in-network, which can help reduce your out-of-pocket costs.

In summary, you absolutely can change dentists for a tooth filling or any other dental treatment. There are no restrictions preventing you from doing so, and it’s important to find a dentist who you trust and feel comfortable with. Your dental health is paramount, and you deserve to receive the best care possible. If you have further concerns about the treatment options for your tooth or the quality of care you’ve received, don’t hesitate to seek out a new dentist who can provide the care you need.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Dental Insurance: Switching Dentists and Costs Explained

Health insurance does not stipulate that you must stay with a specific provider for a certain number of years before switching to another one. If I do not want to continue with this provider (due to poor attitude), I would need to pay out of pocket, right? Approximately how much ...


Dr. Zeng Guanghui reply Dentistry
Hello, sir: Thank you for your inquiry. I would like to respond to your question and provide the following advice: According to health insurance regulations, the same dental filling location (tooth position) cannot be refilled within a year and a half. If you have ongoing symptom...

[Read More] Understanding Dental Insurance: Switching Dentists and Costs Explained


Understanding Dental Insurance Coverage and Re-treatment Policies in Taiwan

Hello, Doctor! I have a few questions to ask. 1. Some online users mentioned that a dental filling for the same tooth can only be claimed after two years, and if another dentist takes over, it becomes out-of-pocket expenses. 2. A medical student stated that dentists cannot ch...


Dr. Lin Jiayong reply Dentistry
Hello: Returning to the root of the issue, the majority of cases arise from the initial inappropriateness of the restoration (more than two-thirds of the anterior crown is missing, or the occlusal cusps or marginal ridges of posterior teeth are weak or consist of only residual ro...

[Read More] Understanding Dental Insurance Coverage and Re-treatment Policies in Taiwan


Switching Dentists: How to Address Poor Dental Work and Costs

Hello~ Recently, I went to a dentist for a filling, but each time I leave, I end up with new issues. The doctor always says, "Let's prioritize getting it filled before addressing aesthetic concerns," which results in the fillings looking worse than if I hadn't...


Dr. Lin Jiayong reply Dentistry
Hello: It is recommended to find a physician you trust. After stating your purpose, it is best if the physician is willing to assist you. If the issue exceeds the physician's scope of practice, asking the physician to issue a referral to a medical center for further manageme...

[Read More] Switching Dentists: How to Address Poor Dental Work and Costs


Can I Switch Dentists During My Orthodontic Treatment?

Hello: Due to missing teeth, I underwent orthodontic treatment for a year and seven months. During my appointments, the doctor has accidentally touched my chest multiple times. I used to bring my boyfriend with me, which prevented it from happening, but recently it has started oc...


Dr. Huang Zhicheng reply Dentistry
Dear A-Mao-Mao, Hello, orthodontic treatment is very specialized. You can first schedule an appointment to consult with other specialists and discuss the future costs based on the current progress. If you find it reasonable, you can switch doctors. Wishing you peace and health...

[Read More] Can I Switch Dentists During My Orthodontic Treatment?


Related FAQ

Dental Filling

(Dentistry)

Silver Filling

(Dentistry)

Dental Implant

(Dentistry)

Crown Lengthening

(Dentistry)

Temporary Crown

(Dentistry)

Lost Filling

(Dentistry)

Retainer

(Dentistry)

Permanent Teeth

(Dentistry)

Toothache

(Dentistry)

Denture Fitting

(Dentistry)