Is it possible for long-standing abnormalities on chest X-rays (such as apical pleural thickening and mild fibrosis) to reverse and heal without medication?
Hello, I am a 50-year-old male, non-smoker and non-drinker.
In 2018, I had my first chest X-ray at Hospital A, which revealed "apical pleural thickening and mild fibrosis." A CT scan also showed a 0.3 cm pulmonary nodule, and the physician informed me that the likelihood of it being benign was high, recommending annual follow-ups.
Since then, routine health checks at different hospitals have consistently noted "abnormal chest X-ray" or "apical pleural thickening," while the term "fibrosis" does not always appear.
Currently, I have a question regarding my health.
In 2023, during a health check at Hospital B, I was again noted to have "abnormal chest X-ray, apical pleural thickening." However, in March 2024, due to discomfort in my chest (central pain that worsens with coughing or inhalation), I visited Hospital B again.
The outpatient physician stated, "The X-ray looks very clear, with no signs of apical pleural thickening or fibrosis."
Given that the physician had previously educated me that "apical pleural thickening or fibrosis are both irreversible," how could the latest X-ray show such improvement? Furthermore, the health check report from the same hospital a year prior also noted "abnormal chest X-ray, apical pleural thickening." Is this possible, or could there have been a mix-up with another patient's X-ray? Or could the outpatient physician have misinterpreted the results?
What should my next steps be? The outpatient physician at Hospital B firmly stated that "the X-ray shows no abnormalities" and believes my chest pain is unrelated to any thoracic disease, suggesting it might be caused by gastroesophageal reflux.
However, I do not have symptoms of gastroesophageal reflux, and my chest pain is persistent throughout the day, not just "after meals." Should I seek another hospital's thoracic department for a repeat X-ray? Or which specialty should I consult to determine the cause of my symptoms? Thank you for your response!
wen, 50~59 year old female. Ask Date: 2024/03/29
Dr. Wu Yingxun reply Pulmonology
Hello: Mild pleural thickening and fibrosis at the lung apex are likely irreversible reactions, but they do not cause chest pain and are considered old lesions.
Some physicians may overlook these inactive lesions.
Reply Date: 2024/03/29
More Info
Lung apex pleural thickening and fibrosis are conditions that can raise significant concerns for patients, especially when they are noted on imaging studies such as X-rays or CT scans. Your situation, where you have experienced variations in the interpretation of your lung imaging over the years, is not uncommon and can be quite perplexing.
Firstly, it is important to understand that pleural thickening and fibrosis are generally considered to be irreversible changes in the lung tissue. These changes can occur due to a variety of reasons, including previous infections, exposure to environmental toxins, or even idiopathic causes. When a physician states that these changes are "irreversible," it typically means that the structural alterations in the lung tissue cannot be reversed to their original state. However, the degree of thickening or fibrosis can sometimes appear to stabilize or even improve in subsequent imaging studies, which can lead to confusion.
In your case, the discrepancy between the findings of your previous X-rays and the recent one could be attributed to several factors:
1. Variability in Imaging Techniques: Different hospitals may use different imaging equipment or techniques, which can affect the clarity and interpretation of the images. This variability can lead to differences in the reported findings.
2. Interpretation Differences: Radiologists may have different levels of experience or focus on different aspects of the imaging. It is possible that the radiologist interpreting your recent X-ray did not see the same signs of pleural thickening or fibrosis that were noted in previous studies.
3. Natural Variation: In some cases, the appearance of lung structures can change over time due to various factors, including the resolution of inflammation or changes in the lung's response to environmental factors.
Given that you are experiencing persistent chest pain, it is crucial to pursue further evaluation. Here are some steps you might consider:
1. Seek a Second Opinion: If you have concerns about the accuracy of the recent interpretation, it may be beneficial to seek a second opinion from another radiologist or a pulmonologist. They can review your imaging studies and provide additional insights.
2. Further Imaging: If your symptoms persist, requesting further imaging, such as a CT scan, may provide more detailed information about the state of your lungs and any potential underlying issues.
3. Consult a Specialist: Given your symptoms of chest pain, it may be worthwhile to consult a pulmonologist who specializes in lung diseases. They can perform a thorough evaluation, including pulmonary function tests, and determine if your symptoms are related to lung pathology or if they could be due to other causes, such as gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) or musculoskeletal issues.
4. Consider Gastroenterology Consultation: Since the physician suggested that your chest pain might be related to GERD, it could be beneficial to consult a gastroenterologist. They can evaluate your symptoms and determine if there is a gastrointestinal cause for your discomfort.
5. Monitor Symptoms: Keep a detailed record of your symptoms, including when they occur, their severity, and any potential triggers. This information can be invaluable for your healthcare providers in determining the underlying cause of your chest pain.
In conclusion, while lung apex pleural thickening and fibrosis are generally considered irreversible, variations in imaging results can occur. It is essential to address your ongoing symptoms with appropriate medical professionals to ensure a comprehensive evaluation and management plan. Don't hesitate to advocate for your health and seek further evaluations as needed.
Similar Q&A
Understanding Mild Fibrotic Changes and Pleural Thickening in Lung Health
Hello Dr. Yang, I have received my chest X-ray results from my health check-up, which indicate no definite active pulmonary infiltration or consolidation in this study. However, there are mild fibrotic changes at both upper lungs and minimal bilateral apical pleural thickening....
Dr. Yang Wenda reply Pulmonology
Hello: Based on the description, it seems more like a scar left from a previous inflammatory lesion. It should be monitored once a year.[Read More] Understanding Mild Fibrotic Changes and Pleural Thickening in Lung Health
Understanding Pleural Thickening and Fibrosis: Causes and Treatment Options
Hello doctor, I recently had a health check-up, and today's report indicated that there is thickening and fibrosis of the right pleura, highlighted in red. I have never smoked, but I had a prolonged cough recently and did not see a doctor at that time. After I eventually con...
Dr. Yang Zhiyun reply Pulmonology
Hello, based on your described X-ray findings, they may be due to old pulmonary tuberculosis or an unknown cause. If there are no changes in the X-ray comparison, it is likely a benign lesion. However, if there are changes, further investigation is necessary. These changes may no...[Read More] Understanding Pleural Thickening and Fibrosis: Causes and Treatment Options
Understanding Emphysema and Pleural Thickening After Pneumothorax
Hello doctor, about three years ago I had a spontaneous pneumothorax. Later, the doctor performed a CT scan and mentioned that there was a bleb in the left lower lung, but I wasn't advised to return for a follow-up. Recently, the results from my school health check indicated...
Dr. Cai Zongwei reply Pulmonology
Hello: Pneumothorax has various causes, some of which are directly or indirectly related to blebs or emphysema (which may increase the risk, and it is advisable to avoid participating in certain high-risk activities). Pleural thickening is mostly a sequela of past lung diseases a...[Read More] Understanding Emphysema and Pleural Thickening After Pneumothorax
Understanding the Risks of Pneumonia with Pleural Thickening
Hello, Doctor: During my health check-up two years ago, I was found to have pleural thickening at the lung apex and a 40-degree spinal scoliosis. Occasionally, I experience some shortness of breath, but the situation is not severe. I would like to ask if I would be at a greater r...
Dr. Hong Yuanbin reply Internal Medicine
Hello, the phenomenon of pleural thickening at the lung apex and the 40-degree scoliosis should not have a direct correlation with pneumonia. It is recommended to engage in regular exercise and maintain a consistent routine to reduce the risk of pneumonia. Thank you for your inqu...[Read More] Understanding the Risks of Pneumonia with Pleural Thickening
Related FAQ
(Pulmonology)
Fibrous Calcification(Pulmonology)
Pleural Effusion(Pulmonology)
Chest(Pulmonology)
Bronchiectasis(Pulmonology)
Lung Nodule(Pulmonology)
Ground-Glass Nodule(Pulmonology)
Ct Report(Pulmonology)
Postoperative Lung Adenocarcinoma(Pulmonology)
Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease(Pulmonology)