Eyeglass prescription issues?
Hello, Doctor Gao.
I am a 15-year-old teenager with myopia.
Due to the need to see the blackboard in class, I went for an eye examination to get glasses.
Two weeks ago, I visited a local hospital for an eye exam without dilation.
The results from the automated refraction indicated that my left eye has -2.00 diopters of myopia and my right eye has -1.75 diopters.
After a trial frame vision check, the doctor prescribed glasses with the minimum prescription that allows for 20/20 vision: left eye -1.75 diopters with -1.00 diopter of astigmatism, and right eye -1.50 diopters with -0.75 diopter of astigmatism.
I did not experience any significant discomfort during the trial.
That afternoon, I went to an optical store to get my glasses.
I did not take the prescription from the doctor but asked the optician at the store to perform a new refraction without dilation.
The optician also prescribed glasses based on achieving 20/20 vision, resulting in: left eye -2.25 diopters with -1.00 diopter of astigmatism, and right eye -2.00 diopters with -0.50 diopter of astigmatism.
I felt some discomfort and strain while trying on the glasses, and the optical store said it was normal for first-time wearers to need time to adjust.
I accepted this explanation, but after a week of wearing the glasses, I still experienced discomfort and a feeling of tightness and fatigue in my eyes.
The optical store suggested reducing the prescription to alleviate discomfort.
I have a few questions for you, Doctor Gao:
Q1: The prescription from the hospital and the one from the optical store differ by 0.50 diopters for each eye.
What could be the reasons for this fluctuation in my eye prescription?
Q2: For high school students, is it advisable to have a prescription that allows for 20/20 vision (primarily for seeing the classroom blackboard)? If the prescription is reduced for comfort, could this have any negative effects on the eyes?
Q3: Is it possible that my eye fatigue and ciliary muscle tension during the refraction led to a higher than actual prescription?
Q4: What is the significance of the difference between the non-dilated and dilated refraction results in the field of optometry?
Q5: Following up on Q4, which prescription should we consider as more appropriate for my glasses?
Q6: Given my current myopia (approximately -1.75 to -2.00 diopters), would you recommend wearing glasses for daily activities, or should I only wear them for distance viewing?
Thank you for your patience in reading my questions, Doctor Gao.
Duo Duo, 10~19 year old female. Ask Date: 2024/07/08
Dr. Gao Pilin reply Ophthalmology
Hello:
Q1: What are the possible reasons for a difference of 50 diopters between the prescription obtained at the hospital and that obtained at the optical store? The difference in prescription may arise from several factors: 1.
Testing environment: The refraction environment at the hospital and the optical store (such as lighting conditions, the type and condition of the refracting instruments) may differ.
2.
Individual condition: Factors such as fatigue level, visual habits, and sleep quality on the day of the examination can affect the results.
Q2: Is it ideal for high school students to wear glasses that allow them to see a vision of 1.0? If the prescription is reduced for comfort, could it have any impact on the eyes? Generally, it is ideal for adolescents to wear glasses that provide a vision of 1.0, as this ensures clear vision for learning and daily activities.
If the prescription is reduced for comfort, it may affect clarity when looking at distant objects, potentially leading to eye strain or blurred vision over time.
Additionally, not properly correcting vision may impact learning and daily life.
Q3: Is it possible that eye fatigue at the time of the examination, with the ciliary muscle tense, could result in a higher prescription than the actual one? Yes, this is indeed possible.
When the eyes are fatigued or the ciliary muscle is tense, it can lead to pseudomyopia, resulting in an overestimation of the prescription.
Therefore, it is important to maintain a good state of rest before the examination.
Q4: What is the significance of the un-dilated prescription versus the prescription obtained after dilation in the field of refraction? The un-dilated prescription usually contains a component of pseudomyopia, as the ciliary muscle may still be in a tense state.
The prescription obtained after dilation is more accurate because the dilating agent fully relaxes the ciliary muscle, allowing for the measurement of the true refractive error.
Q5: Which prescription should be chosen for glasses? The prescription obtained after dilation should be selected.
If dilation is not performed, the prescription recommended by the ophthalmologist should be used.
Q6: With the current myopia prescription (approximately 175 to 200 degrees), is it advisable to wear glasses for daily activities, or only for distance viewing? With a myopia prescription between 175 and 200 degrees, it is recommended to wear glasses during daily activities to ensure clear vision.
However, if it is inconvenient, glasses can be worn only for distance viewing or activities that require precise vision, such as seeing the blackboard in class.
I hope these answers help resolve your questions.
Wishing you good eye health!
Reply Date: 2024/07/08
More Info
When it comes to selecting the right prescription glasses for a teenager, especially one with myopia (nearsightedness), there are several important factors to consider. Your situation highlights a common concern among young individuals who are beginning to wear glasses, and it’s essential to address your questions thoroughly.
Q1: Differences in Prescription Between the Hospital and the Eyewear Store
The discrepancy in prescription between the hospital and the eyewear store can arise from several factors. Firstly, the testing environment can differ significantly. Hospitals often use more sophisticated equipment and may have a more controlled environment, while eyewear stores might rely on quicker methods that can be influenced by factors like lighting and the patient's comfort. Additionally, the experience and technique of the optometrist or optician conducting the exam can lead to variations in the results. It's also possible that your eyes were fatigued during the second test, which could have affected the outcome.
Q2: Importance of Achieving 1.0 Vision and Comfort
For students, especially in high school, having a prescription that allows for clear vision (1.0) is crucial for activities like reading the blackboard. However, comfort is equally important. If a lower prescription provides adequate vision for classroom activities without causing discomfort, it may be a better choice. Prolonged discomfort can lead to eye strain, headaches, and a negative association with wearing glasses, which could discourage consistent use.
Q3: Eye Fatigue and Its Impact on Prescription
Yes, it is indeed possible that eye fatigue and tension in the ciliary muscles (which help focus the lens) can lead to an overestimation of the prescription needed. When the eyes are tired, they may not relax adequately during the exam, resulting in a higher prescription than necessary. This is why it’s often recommended to have a thorough eye exam when the eyes are well-rested.
Q4: Significance of Non-Dilated vs. Dilated Measurements
In the field of optometry, non-dilated measurements (without the use of cycloplegic drops) typically reflect the eye's natural state, which can include some muscle tension. Dilated measurements, on the other hand, provide a more accurate assessment of the refractive error because the ciliary muscles are relaxed, allowing for a true representation of the eye's focusing ability. This is particularly important for young patients, as their eyes can change rapidly.
Q5: Choosing the Right Prescription
When deciding on the appropriate prescription, it’s generally advisable to consider the dilated measurements as they provide a more accurate reflection of your refractive error. However, if comfort is a significant issue with the higher prescription, it may be worth discussing with your eye care provider the possibility of using a slightly lower prescription that still allows for adequate vision.
Q6: Daily Use of Glasses
Given your current prescription of approximately 175-200 degrees of myopia, it is advisable to wear glasses for daily activities, especially if you find yourself straining to see clearly. Wearing glasses consistently can help reduce eye fatigue and improve overall visual comfort. If you only wear them occasionally, you may find that your eyes become more fatigued when you do need to see clearly.
In conclusion, it’s essential to communicate openly with your eye care provider about your experiences with your glasses. If discomfort persists, consider returning to the provider for a reevaluation. They may suggest adjustments to your prescription or provide recommendations for lens types that could enhance comfort. Regular eye exams are crucial, especially during your teenage years when your vision may still be changing.
Similar Q&A
Understanding Contact Lens Impact on Uneven Vision in Teens
I am a first-year high school student and have just started wearing contact lenses. I originally had an issue with unequal prescription between my left and right eyes, but I have been wearing -2.50 in both eyes. I used to think the prescriptions were very close, but today I notic...
Dr. Wang Zhangji reply Ophthalmology
Your issue requires diagnostic testing to confirm.[Read More] Understanding Contact Lens Impact on Uneven Vision in Teens
Understanding Fluctuating Vision: Causes and Solutions for Eye Health
Hello Doctor, I am nearly 34 years old this year. Since childhood, my family strictly limited my reading, writing, and television viewing distances. During fifth and sixth grade, when I loved reading the most, I did not have myopia. However, during middle school, the educationa...
Dr. Cai Wenyuan reply Ophthalmology
Hello, I believe your issue is not serious. I recommend visiting a medical center for a check-up. Wishing you peace and good health. Sincerely, Dr. Tsai Wen-Yuan, Director of the Ophthalmology Department, Taoyuan Hospital, Ministry of Health and Welfare.[Read More] Understanding Fluctuating Vision: Causes and Solutions for Eye Health
Understanding Sudden Myopia Changes: Eyeglasses vs. Contact Lenses
About 6 to 7 months ago, I had an eye exam. My left eye was over -600, and my right eye was -575. I was prescribed daily disposable contact lenses for my myopia control and glasses with a slightly lower prescription. I usually wear contact lenses during the day and regular glasse...
Dr. Gao Pilin reply Ophthalmology
Hello: Based on your description, you have recently noticed an increase in your myopia, and you experience different visual perceptions when wearing glasses and contact lenses. This situation may have several possible causes: 1. Refractive changes: The increase in myopia may be...[Read More] Understanding Sudden Myopia Changes: Eyeglasses vs. Contact Lenses
Correcting Visual Disparity: Effective Solutions for Myopia and Astigmatism
Hello Dr. Liang, My daughter is currently 17 years old and in her second year of high school. Her vision was normal during childhood, but she started developing myopia in the fifth grade, and the disparity between her two eyes has been increasing. Currently, her left eye has a p...
Dr. Liang Ce reply Ophthalmology
It is recommended that you discuss the child's condition further with the ophthalmologist and seek the most appropriate consultation. Wishing you good health.[Read More] Correcting Visual Disparity: Effective Solutions for Myopia and Astigmatism
Related FAQ
(Ophthalmology)
Sunglasses(Ophthalmology)
Eye Medication(Ophthalmology)
Parallax(Ophthalmology)
Vision Discrepancy(Ophthalmology)
Glasses Fitting(Ophthalmology)
Prescription Strength(Ophthalmology)
Digital Devices(Ophthalmology)
Eyes(Family Medicine)
Farsightedness(Ophthalmology)