Persistent Shoulder Pain After Clavicle Surgery: Is the Plate Misplaced? - Orthopedics

Share to:

The metal plate is not displaced, but there is pain?


Hello, Doctor.
On June 4th, I had a motorcycle accident and fractured my right distal clavicle.
I visited the clinic the next day and underwent surgery, using a self-funded hook plate.
After the surgery, the pain significantly decreased, and while I felt some foreign body sensation, it was not prominent.

On July 10th, I rode a friend's motorcycle home.
Although the speed was not fast, the road was uneven with many manhole covers.
After getting off the bike, I noticed that my right shoulder was more painful than it had been in the previous month, and the foreign body sensation felt different from what I experienced a month post-surgery.
I am concerned that the movement on the motorcycle may have caused the plate to shift and press against the surrounding soft tissue.
I had a follow-up appointment on July 15th, where I had an X-ray taken.
I explained to the substitute doctor (as my original physician was abroad for training) that my affected area had started to hurt.
The doctor reviewed the X-ray and said there were no issues and no displacement.
However, as of today (July 18th), I still experience pain and soreness near my right shoulder.
My entire arm feels slightly numb when hanging naturally, and the soreness near the clavicle extends to the back of my neck and right upper back, which is quite uncomfortable.
The foreign body sensation is becoming more pronounced, and I only feel comfortable when lying down; discomfort returns after I get up.
I usually do not lift heavy objects with my right hand, nor do I raise it or make large movements; I only perform the rehabilitation exercises prescribed by the doctor.
This sudden discomfort has persisted for a week, and I am really worried that the plate may have shifted.
Thank you for reading, Doctor.
I wish you all the best, good health, and prosperity.

TT, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2024/07/18

Dr. Wang Jiacheng reply Orthopedics


If the first X-ray indicates no displacement and you don't believe it, it's best to wait another two weeks and then get another X-ray to check.

Reply Date: 2024/07/18

More Info


After clavicle surgery, persistent shoulder pain can be concerning, especially if it appears to be worsening over time. It's understandable to worry about the possibility of the surgical plate being misplaced or causing additional issues. Based on your description, it seems that you are experiencing a combination of pain, discomfort, and a sensation of foreignness in the area surrounding your shoulder and clavicle.
Firstly, it’s important to recognize that post-operative pain can be influenced by several factors, including the surgical procedure itself, the healing process, and the physical activities you engage in after surgery. The fact that you experienced a significant reduction in pain immediately after the surgery is a positive sign, indicating that the procedure was initially successful in addressing the fracture. However, the increase in pain after riding on a motorcycle could suggest that the movement and vibrations may have aggravated the area, even if the plate itself has not moved.

Regarding your concerns about the plate potentially being misplaced, it’s reassuring that your follow-up X-ray did not show any signs of displacement. X-rays are a useful tool for assessing the position of surgical hardware, but they may not always capture soft tissue issues or other complications. If the plate were indeed misplaced, it could potentially irritate surrounding soft tissues, leading to pain and discomfort. However, since the X-ray indicated that everything appeared normal, it’s likely that the pain you are experiencing is related to the healing process or soft tissue irritation rather than a misplacement of the plate.

The symptoms you describe, including pain radiating to the neck and back, as well as a sensation of numbness in the arm, may suggest that there is some irritation or compression of the nerves in the area. This could be due to swelling, muscle tension, or even postural changes as you adjust to the discomfort. It’s also possible that the muscles and soft tissues around the shoulder are still recovering from the trauma of the injury and the surgery, which can lead to referred pain and discomfort.

To manage your symptoms, consider the following recommendations:
1. Rest and Ice: Ensure you are giving your shoulder adequate rest. Applying ice to the area can help reduce inflammation and alleviate pain.

2. Physical Therapy: If you haven’t already, engaging in a structured physical therapy program can be beneficial. A physical therapist can provide targeted exercises to strengthen the shoulder and improve range of motion while also addressing any muscle imbalances or tension.

3. Pain Management: Over-the-counter pain medications, such as ibuprofen or acetaminophen, can help manage pain and reduce inflammation. Always consult with your physician before starting any medication.

4. Follow-Up: If your symptoms persist or worsen, it’s crucial to follow up with your orthopedic surgeon or a specialist. They may recommend additional imaging studies, such as an MRI, to assess the soft tissues around the shoulder and clavicle.

5. Avoid Strain: Be cautious with activities that may strain your shoulder, especially lifting or reaching overhead. Gradually reintroduce activities as tolerated.

In conclusion, while it’s understandable to be concerned about the surgical plate and your ongoing symptoms, the absence of displacement on the X-ray is a reassuring sign. Focus on recovery through rest, physical therapy, and proper pain management. If your symptoms do not improve, do not hesitate to seek further evaluation from your healthcare provider. Your health and comfort are paramount, and addressing these concerns early can lead to better outcomes in your recovery process.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Shoulder Pain After Clavicle Fracture Surgery: When to Seek Help

Hello doctor, I have a clavicle fracture and had surgery to insert a steel plate, which has since been removed. It has been about nine months since the plate was removed, and a year and a half since the surgery. However, sometimes I experience pain when moving my shoulder forward...


Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
After a fracture has healed, it should not cause pain; therefore, it is best to consult a physician for evaluation.

[Read More] Understanding Shoulder Pain After Clavicle Fracture Surgery: When to Seek Help


Persistent Shoulder Pain After Clavicle Fracture Surgery: What to Expect?

Dear Dr. Shi, Hello! I underwent surgery on my left clavicle on September 1, where it was stabilized with a plate and screws. I started rehabilitation at the hospital one month post-surgery, and it has now been two and a half months. Why is there still significant pain near my s...


Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
After a clavicle fracture surgery, it is important to monitor the degree of bone healing. If the bone has completely healed, there should be no pain, which typically occurs within three to six months. Regarding shoulder mobility, if the bone screws are not impinging on the muscle...

[Read More] Persistent Shoulder Pain After Clavicle Fracture Surgery: What to Expect?


Post-Surgery Issues with Right Clavicle: Pain and Concerns After Trauma

I suffered a right clavicle fracture in a car accident on October 21 of this year. After surgery, a hook-shaped plate was used for fixation. Follow-up X-rays on November 15 and December 15 showed good results. However, on December 20, during a company team-building activity, the ...


Dr. You Dianqi reply Orthopedics
Hello, there could be many reasons for this. Generally, the hook plate is considered a removable internal fixation device. While it is present in your body, it may cause some degree of impingement syndrome on your shoulder's rotator cuff. Regarding your concerns about displa...

[Read More] Post-Surgery Issues with Right Clavicle: Pain and Concerns After Trauma


Post-Surgery Shoulder Pain: Is Your Acromioclavicular Joint Unstable?

Doctor, after my acromioclavicular joint surgery, I experience a pinching or grinding sensation and significant pain when I shrug my shoulder or move it back and forth. The orthopedic surgeon said the surgery was very successful, and I've also undergone regenerative treatmen...


Dr. Chen Bochen reply Orthopedics
It is important to first understand the type of surgery being performed, whether it involves a hook plate, a coracoclavicular screw, or ligament reconstruction. If a hook plate is used, there may be a higher likelihood of experiencing friction sounds and pain. Generally, the plat...

[Read More] Post-Surgery Shoulder Pain: Is Your Acromioclavicular Joint Unstable?


Related FAQ

Post-Clavicle Surgery

(Orthopedics)

Clavicle Fracture

(Orthopedics)

Acromioclavicular Joint Dislocation

(Orthopedics)

Shoulder Joint

(Orthopedics)

Scapular Fracture

(Orthopedics)

Clavicle

(Rehabilitation)

Left Shoulder Bone Pain

(Neurology)

Shoulder Pain

(Neurosurgery)

Shoulder Pain

(Rehabilitation)

Distal Humeral Fracture

(Orthopedics)