Anal Fistulas: Treatment Options and When to Consider Surgery - Surgery

Share to:

Anal fistula


Hello, Doctor.
About a year ago, I noticed a hard lump near my anus.
When it first appeared, I consulted a physician who said it was hemorrhoids, and I left it at that.
Over the past year, the lump has been painless, itch-free, and without any discharge, and its size hasn't changed.
However, the week before last, it developed a small hole and bled a tiny amount of fresh blood, but that stopped quickly.
I didn't see a doctor until last Thursday (a different one from a year ago), and this doctor said it was a fistula but that surgery wasn't necessary since there were no signs of inflammation.
He prescribed an ointment and advised me to apply it to see if the wound would heal, which it has now done.
I would like to ask Dr.
Ke if I should just leave it alone now? Is applying the ointment effective, or would it be better to schedule surgery? I've read online that doctors often say that a fistula requires surgery to heal.
Thank you, Doctor.

kk, 10~19 year old female. Ask Date: 2024/07/22

Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery


The only definitive treatment for an anal fistula is surgery.
If there is no infection, swelling, or discomfort, continuous observation is also an option.
However, if there are recurrent infections, it is advisable to proceed with surgical treatment to prevent the development of a complex fistula.

Reply Date: 2024/07/22

More Info


Understanding anal fistulas can be quite complex, and it's important to approach the topic with a clear understanding of the condition, its treatment options, and when surgical intervention may be necessary.

An anal fistula is an abnormal connection between the anal canal and the skin surrounding the anus. It often develops as a result of an infection in the anal glands, leading to the formation of an abscess. Once the abscess drains, it can leave a tract or tunnel, which is what we refer to as a fistula. Symptoms can vary; some patients experience pain, swelling, or discharge, while others may have a fistula that remains asymptomatic, as you described in your case.

In your situation, you mentioned that the hard lump near your anus was initially diagnosed as hemorrhoids and later identified as a fistula by a different physician. The fact that it was asymptomatic for a year and only recently bled slightly when it developed a small opening is significant. The absence of pain, discharge, or inflammation suggests that the fistula may not be causing any immediate problems.

Your doctor’s recommendation to apply a topical ointment and monitor the healing of the wound is a common approach, especially in cases where the fistula is not causing significant symptoms. Topical treatments can help soothe the area and promote healing, but they are not a definitive cure for the fistula itself. The healing of the external opening does not necessarily mean that the internal tract has closed, and this is where the concern lies.

The general consensus among healthcare professionals is that while some anal fistulas can heal on their own, many require surgical intervention to ensure complete resolution. Surgery is often recommended for fistulas that are symptomatic or have a higher risk of complications. The surgical options can vary, including fistulotomy (opening the fistula tract), seton placement (a drain to allow the fistula to heal), or more complex procedures for complicated fistulas.

In your case, since the wound has healed and you are not experiencing any discomfort or other symptoms, it may be reasonable to continue monitoring the situation. However, it is crucial to remain vigilant for any changes, such as the return of pain, swelling, or discharge, which could indicate that the fistula is still present or has become problematic.

If you find that the fistula reopens, becomes painful, or if you have any concerns about its status, it would be wise to consult with a colorectal surgeon. They can provide a more thorough evaluation and discuss the potential need for surgery if the fistula is determined to be persistent or symptomatic.

In summary, while topical treatment may be effective in managing the symptoms of an asymptomatic anal fistula, it is essential to keep an eye on the situation. If any new symptoms arise or if you have concerns about the fistula's status, seeking further medical advice is advisable. Surgery is often the definitive treatment for anal fistulas, particularly if they are symptomatic or recurrent, so maintaining open communication with your healthcare provider is key to managing your condition effectively.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Anal Fistulas: Symptoms, Risks, and Treatment Options

Hello, doctor. At the end of January and the beginning of February, I had an anal abscess that was not drained because it seemed to be located deeper. I was treated with antibiotics and pain relievers. However, after experiencing continuous diarrhea on the night of March 27, I ha...


Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
Anal abscesses should primarily be treated with surgery. Sometimes, if the symptoms are mild or the location is unclear, oral antibiotics may be administered initially. However, if symptoms worsen, incision and drainage surgery is necessary; otherwise, severe cases can lead to se...

[Read More] Understanding Anal Fistulas: Symptoms, Risks, and Treatment Options


Post-Surgery Anal Fistula: Pain, Healing, and Treatment Options

Hello Doctor: After undergoing surgery for a fistula and mixed hemorrhoids on December 28, 2018, I often experience swelling and pain when pressing on the area where the fistula was located. Upon examination, it was found that there is still a small wound inside the anus that has...


Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
1. Anal fistulas can be evaluated using fistulography to determine their course; however, this type of examination is typically available only at larger hospitals. Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) can also be used, but health insurance may not cover it, and the diagnostic accurac...

[Read More] Post-Surgery Anal Fistula: Pain, Healing, and Treatment Options


Exploring Non-Surgical Options for Anal Fistula Treatment

Hello Dr. Ke, I would like to ask you whether surgery is the only option for treating anal fistulas. I have seen online that there are non-surgical methods such as electroacupuncture and the Fistula Plug technique. Due to my work commitments, I hope to choose a non-surgical, outp...


Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
Hello: In response to your question, the only definitive treatment for anal fistulas is surgery. The traditional surgical approach involves either incision or excision of the fistula to remove it completely. Newer techniques, such as the use of electrocoagulation or fistula plugs...

[Read More] Exploring Non-Surgical Options for Anal Fistula Treatment


Minimally Invasive Surgery for Chronic Anal Fistulas: What You Need to Know

I would like to inquire about the current treatment options for a diagnosed anal fistula, which is considered chronic and mild. I understand that traditionally, surgery involved incision, resulting in large wounds and longer healing times, with a possibility of recurrence during ...


Dr. Xu Kaixi reply Surgery
The treatment for anal fistulas involves fistulotomy or excision, with most cases being managed through traditional surgical methods. The recovery time is approximately one week. The recurrence rate is related to the severity and complexity of the original fistula.

[Read More] Minimally Invasive Surgery for Chronic Anal Fistulas: What You Need to Know


Related FAQ