Confusion Over Ovarian Cysts: To Operate or Not? A Patient's Dilemma

Cyst

Hello Doctor: My mother, born in 1981, is entering menopause.
Recently, she underwent examinations at three different hospitals.
At the first hospital, the doctor mentioned a 0.6 cm cyst on one ovary and insisted on surgery, followed by blood tests.
A few days later, she visited the second hospital, where the chief physician stated there was a 1.5 cm cyst and also recommended surgery, along with blood tests.
After a few more days, she went to a third hospital, where the chief physician claimed there was nothing there and that surgery was unnecessary, suggesting a follow-up in six months without the need for blood tests.

On the way back, she checked the blood test results at the first hospital, which showed elevated levels, leading them to insist on surgery again.
Initially, they mentioned both sides, but later said it might only require one side.
Then, at the second hospital, a different doctor also insisted on surgery.
This conflicting information from three reputable hospitals has left us quite confused.

The uterine cyst is less than 5 cm, which typically does not require surgery; what about the ovarian cyst? We are very concerned about the possibility of it being a corpus luteum cyst or the potential risk of it turning into a malignant tumor, as suggested by the first two doctors.
Additionally, my mother is currently menstruating; can she still undergo an ultrasound examination? We would appreciate your prompt clarification.
Thank you.

CL, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2004/03/05

Dr. Wu Zongcheng reply Obstetrics and Gynecology

Dr.
Wu Zongcheng from the Tainan Hospital of the Department of Health, Executive Yuan, responds: (1) The uterus does not develop cysts; it can only have uterine fibroids and adenomyosis.
(2) Generally, when referring to cysts, it pertains to ovarian cysts.
According to textbooks, cysts smaller than 5 centimeters can be monitored (with follow-up every three months).
(3) Cysts larger than 5 centimeters or those that may be malignant require surgical intervention.
(4) Please consult a physician at a public hospital or medical school to determine if surgery is necessary.
Tainan Hospital wishes you good health and all the best.

Reply Date: 2004/03/05

More Info

The situation you described regarding your mother's ovarian cysts is indeed complex and reflects the variability in medical opinions that can arise in such cases. Ovarian cysts are fluid-filled sacs that can form on the ovaries and are quite common, especially in women of reproductive age. However, as women approach menopause, the nature and management of these cysts can become more nuanced.

Understanding Ovarian Cysts
Ovarian cysts can be classified into several types, including functional cysts (such as follicular and corpus luteum cysts), dermoid cysts, and endometriomas (chocolate cysts). Most functional cysts are benign and often resolve on their own without treatment. However, the concern arises when cysts are larger, persist over time, or exhibit characteristics that raise suspicion for malignancy.

Surgical Indications
The decision to operate on an ovarian cyst typically depends on several factors:
1. Size of the Cyst: Cysts larger than 5 cm, especially if they are complex (having solid components or irregularities), may warrant surgical intervention.

2. Symptoms: If the cyst is causing significant pain, pressure symptoms, or other complications, surgery may be indicated.

3. Imaging Findings: Ultrasound characteristics can help differentiate between benign and potentially malignant cysts. For example, a simple cyst that is less than 5 cm and has smooth borders is usually benign.

4. CA-125 Levels: This blood test can be helpful, especially in postmenopausal women, as elevated levels may indicate a higher risk of ovarian cancer.

Conflicting Opinions
The conflicting opinions from different healthcare providers can be confusing. It's essential to consider that:
- Different doctors may have varying thresholds for recommending surgery based on their clinical experience and interpretation of the imaging and lab results.

- The presence of symptoms, the patient's age, and the characteristics of the cyst can lead to different recommendations.

Recommendations
1. Seek a Second Opinion: If there is significant disagreement among specialists, it may be beneficial to seek a second opinion from a gynecologic oncologist or a specialist in reproductive endocrinology. They can provide a more comprehensive evaluation and may suggest additional imaging or monitoring.

2. Monitoring: If the cyst is small (like the 0.6 cm or 1.5 cm cysts mentioned) and not causing symptoms, a watchful waiting approach may be appropriate, with follow-up ultrasounds to monitor for changes.

3. Timing of Ultrasound: Regarding your question about performing an ultrasound during menstruation, it is generally acceptable to do so. However, some clinicians prefer to schedule ultrasounds during the follicular phase of the menstrual cycle (days 1-14) for clearer imaging of the ovaries.

4. Discuss Risks and Benefits: If surgery is recommended, it’s crucial to discuss the potential risks and benefits, including the possibility of complications, recovery time, and the impact on future fertility.

Conclusion
In summary, the management of ovarian cysts, especially in the context of approaching menopause, requires careful consideration of multiple factors. While surgery may be necessary in some cases, many cysts can be monitored without immediate intervention. Open communication with healthcare providers and seeking additional opinions can help clarify the best course of action for your mother's health.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Ovarian Cysts: Treatment Options and Fertility Concerns

Hello, doctor. I have a few questions regarding my situation as a 36-year-old who has never been pregnant. 1. I have a left ovarian cyst measuring 8.6 x 7 cm. Is surgery the only option available? Medications or injections have not been effective in reducing its size. However, ...

Dr. Huang Yuande reply Obstetrics and Gynecology
1. Generally, if the size is greater than 7 centimeters, surgery can be considered. If clinical examination shows no signs of malignancy, observation may be an option. However, if there is severe pain or persistent bleeding, a physician's evaluation is necessary. 2. Yes. ...

Understanding Ovarian Cysts: Treatment Options and Surgical Considerations

Hello doctor, I would like to ask about my mother (60 years old and postmenopausal). She recently had a check-up and was found to have an 8 cm ovarian cyst. Does she definitely need surgery to remove it, or can it be monitored or treated with medication? If surgery is necessary, ...

Dr. Cao Guotao reply Obstetrics and Gynecology
Hello, it is generally recommended to proceed with surgery. If the tumor is benign, there is no need to remove the uterus as well. Wishing you good health.

Understanding Ovarian Cysts: Surgical Options and Expert Advice

Hello, Dr. Cao. I apologize for the interruption! I have something to consult with you. Recently, I have been experiencing frequent urination at night and an uncontrollable urge to get out of bed. Therefore, I visited a gynecologist for an ultrasound, and the result showed a 10 c...

Dr. Cao Guotao reply Obstetrics and Gynecology
Hello, you may consider traditional or laparoscopic surgery. Wishing you good health.

Understanding Ovarian Tumors: Risks and Surgical Considerations

My fiancée experienced severe pain and bloating during her menstrual period in February. After undergoing an ultrasound at Mackay Memorial Hospital, a cyst approximately 6 cm was found on her ovary. The doctor advised her to return for a follow-up examination this month. After th...

Dr. Zhong Wenzhen reply Obstetrics and Gynecology
Hello, Zhiren: First, menstrual cramps, bloating, and ovarian cysts are not related. They are two independent events. Second, as you mentioned, it should not be a simple ovarian cyst, but rather a tumor. The chance of it being malignant is very low, but it should still be excis...