Recovery After ACL and Meniscus Injuries: A Patient's Guide

Tear of the right knee posterior cruciate ligament, rupture of the collateral ligaments, and meniscus tear?

Hello Doctor,
A month ago, I was injured in a car accident, resulting in a complete tear of my right knee posterior cruciate ligament (PCL), a rupture of the collateral ligaments, and a tear of the meniscus.
I underwent surgery a week ago.
Prior to the surgery, I discussed with my doctor that if repair was not possible, an artificial ligament would be used to replace the PCL.
During the arthroscopy, it was found that there were four small roots of the PCL that could be reattached, so the doctor only removed the damaged portion of the meniscus and did not perform any ligament repair.
I am 37 years old, and I would like to know: under normal circumstances, what percentage of the ligament can regenerate on its own? How long does this process typically take? What level of rehabilitation is necessary to avoid re-injury? If rehabilitation is inadequate, will I risk limping in the future due to muscle atrophy? Additionally, will I be more prone to future tears because the overall stability of my knee is very compromised?
Honestly, I consulted 5 or 6 doctors before deciding to proceed with the last one for surgery.
I understand that the help a doctor can provide is limited, but I feel very helpless.
However, I hope to find a clear method to work towards recovery (even if it means undergoing another surgery) to prevent the possibility of limping in the future.
I apologize for my emotional state, and I hope you can provide me with some professional advice.
Thank you!

Walice Zilo, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2004/03/24

Dr. Su Yiren reply Orthopedics

Hello Walice Zilo! I am pleased to assist you.
Regarding issues with the posterior cruciate ligament (PCL), there are some contradictions and uncertainties surrounding the mechanical principles and pathological issues of both the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) and PCL.

Firstly, in terms of mechanical importance and contribution to the knee joint, the PCL is more significant than the ACL; however, clinically, the severity of symptoms is greater for ACL injuries than for PCL injuries.
Why is this the case? I can only say that this is a conclusion drawn from decades of research by scholars and experts.

The complete rupture of the PCL was only recently addressed with the introduction of reconstruction tools in the past few years.
This indicates that the harm patients endure from such surgeries may be comparable to the benefits gained from PCL reconstruction, resulting in a minimal economic 'margin.'
Additionally, there is the issue of artificial ligaments.
In the past, many patients in Taiwan underwent replacement or repair of the ACL and PCL with synthetic fibers (similar to a scout rope).
However, these methods have fallen out of favor because foreign materials tend to rupture after a period of time within the body, particularly among professional basketball players.
Consequently, these techniques are now rarely used worldwide.

Reply Date: 2004/03/24

More Info

Recovering from an ACL (anterior cruciate ligament) injury, especially after a complex situation involving multiple ligament tears and meniscus damage, can be a daunting process. It’s understandable to feel anxious about your recovery, especially given the severity of your injuries and the surgical interventions you've undergone. Here’s a comprehensive guide to help you understand what to expect during your recovery and rehabilitation.

Healing Process
1. Self-Healing of Ligaments: After an ACL injury, the healing process can vary significantly from person to person. In your case, since the surgeon was able to preserve some of the ligament tissue, there is a possibility that the remaining fibers can heal and regain some functionality. However, it’s important to note that ligaments do not heal back to their original strength. Generally, with appropriate rehabilitation, you might expect to regain about 70-80% of the ligament's original strength over time, but this can take several months to a year.

2. Timeframe for Recovery: The recovery timeline can vary widely based on the extent of the injury, the surgical technique used, and your adherence to rehabilitation protocols. Typically, after ACL reconstruction, patients can expect to return to light activities in about 6 months, but full recovery, including returning to sports, can take 9-12 months or longer.

Rehabilitation Protocol
1. Initial Phase (0-6 weeks post-surgery): Focus on reducing swelling and pain management. This may include rest, ice, compression, and elevation (RICE). Gentle range-of-motion exercises should be initiated as tolerated to prevent stiffness.

2. Strengthening Phase (6 weeks - 3 months): Once you have regained sufficient range of motion, you will begin strengthening exercises. This phase is crucial for rebuilding muscle strength around the knee, particularly the quadriceps and hamstrings. Your physical therapist will guide you through exercises tailored to your specific needs.

3. Functional Training (3-6 months): As your strength improves, you will start functional training, which includes exercises that mimic daily activities and sports movements. This phase is essential for preparing your knee for the demands of your lifestyle or sports.

4. Return to Activity (6-12 months): Gradual return to sports and high-impact activities will be introduced, depending on your progress. Your physical therapist will assess your readiness based on strength, stability, and functional performance.

Risks of Inadequate Rehabilitation
1. Risk of Re-injury: If rehabilitation is not followed diligently, there is a significant risk of re-injury. The knee may not regain the necessary stability, leading to further damage to the ligaments or meniscus.

2. Long-term Consequences: Inadequate rehabilitation can lead to muscle atrophy, joint instability, and potentially result in chronic pain or osteoarthritis in the knee. This could contribute to a limp or altered gait over time.

3. Psychological Impact: The fear of re-injury can also affect your confidence in your knee, which may lead to compensatory movements that can cause additional strain on other joints.

Conclusion
It’s crucial to maintain open communication with your healthcare team throughout your recovery. Regular follow-ups with your orthopedic surgeon and physical therapist will help monitor your progress and adjust your rehabilitation plan as needed. If you have concerns about your recovery or experience any setbacks, do not hesitate to reach out to your medical team.

Remember, recovery is a gradual process, and while it may feel overwhelming at times, with dedication and the right support, you can work towards regaining full function of your knee. Stay positive and focus on the small milestones along the way.

Similar Q&A

Post-ACL Reconstruction and Meniscus Repair: Understanding Complications and Recovery

Hello Dr. Shih, good evening. I apologize for disturbing you. I am Professor Lai's nephew, and my surname is Lu. Due to my work in the Philippines this year, I am temporarily unable to return to Taiwan for medical consultation. I have some postoperative orthopedic issues I w...

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
The sequelae you mentioned can occur, but it's essential to have a physician evaluate the situation to determine the cause of the knee joint swelling. Applying ice and resting may help improve the condition. If there is no further injury, recovery typically progresses gradua...

Understanding Cartilage Recovery Time and Assessment After Surgery

Hello, Doctor. In August 2017, I suffered a sports injury that resulted in a torn anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) in my left leg, along with a meniscal tear. After surgery, the ACL healed well, but I continued to experience pain in the cartilage area. In July 2018, I was diagnos...

Dr. Li Yongheng reply Orthopedics
1. Recovery typically takes six months. 2. It is not certain; it could be normal, or there may still be issues with the meniscus. 3. Strenuous exercise should be avoided for at least one year. 4. It depends on the specific circumstances at that time.

Understanding Post-ACL Reconstruction Cysts: Symptoms, Diagnosis, and Recovery

Hello, Doctor. Last November, after school, I had an accident while riding my electric scooter and slipped on construction sand. At that time, my backpack was heavy, and I was carrying other items. I realized I was going to fall, and in the past, I would jump off and land safely,...

Dr. Chen Yongxue reply Orthopedics
Hello, PVNS is actually quite rare. To confirm the diagnosis, it is essential to rely on the pathology report. PVNS should exhibit specific characteristics in MRI imaging and arthroscopic examination, especially during arthroscopy, where very distinctive colors are observed, maki...

Understanding Arthroscopic Surgery: Knee Injuries and Recovery Insights

Hello, doctor. I have many questions to ask. A year ago, I injured my left knee while playing basketball, and after researching various sources, I have the following questions that need answers: 1. What are the methods for repairing the meniscus in the knee? What are the potenti...

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
Meniscus repair involves suturing the meniscus to promote healing. In cases where the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) is not completely torn, conservative treatment is typically the primary approach. If the ACL is completely torn, the decision for surgical intervention depends o...