Is Cast Immobilization Enough for My Heel Fracture?

Fracture fixation

I sought medical attention for a tear-type fracture in my heel.
The doctor only applied a cast for stabilization, but after 7 weeks, there has been almost no improvement.
I experience pulling pain when sitting or lying down, and I feel that the area is not properly stabilized.
In this situation, would it be necessary to use pins for fixation? Thank you!

A Dong, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2004/03/30

Dr. Li Wenlin reply Orthopedics

Hello,
In response to your question, fractures do not always require surgical treatment; the best approach is determined based on the type and classification of the fracture, as well as the individual circumstances of the patient.
Generally speaking, fractures of the bones tend to require a longer recovery time, typically around eight weeks of non-weight bearing.
Additionally, the soft tissues in the foot can easily become sensitive or unable to bear weight due to the trauma from the fracture.
Therefore, rehabilitation after the removal of the cast is crucial.
Techniques such as heat therapy, massage, and both active and passive range of motion exercises for the ankle and foot can gradually help relax the tight soft tissues and restore weight-bearing ability.

Based on your description, I recommend that you first consult an orthopedic physician to ensure that there are no issues with the fracture site, and then seek assistance from a rehabilitation specialist to arrange for rehabilitation.
This approach may help resolve your issues more quickly.
Wishing you a speedy recovery!

Reply Date: 2004/03/30

More Info

When dealing with a heel fracture, particularly a complex one like a tear fracture, the treatment approach can vary significantly based on the specific nature and severity of the fracture. In your case, it seems that after seven weeks of cast immobilization, you are still experiencing significant pain and discomfort, which raises some important considerations.

First, it’s essential to understand that while cast immobilization is a common initial treatment for many types of fractures, it may not always be sufficient for more severe or complicated fractures. A heel fracture, especially if it involves displacement or significant soft tissue injury, may require more than just a cast to ensure proper healing. The fact that you are still experiencing pain and a sensation of instability suggests that the fracture may not be healing adequately in its current state.

In cases where conservative treatment with a cast does not lead to improvement, further evaluation is warranted. This typically involves imaging studies, such as X-rays or possibly a CT scan, to assess the alignment of the fracture and to check for any complications such as non-union (where the bone does not heal properly) or malunion (where the bone heals in an incorrect position). If these imaging studies reveal that the fracture is not healing as expected, surgical intervention may be necessary.

Surgical options for heel fractures can include the use of internal fixation devices, such as screws or plates, to stabilize the fracture and promote healing. The decision to proceed with surgery will depend on several factors, including the specific characteristics of the fracture, your overall health, activity level, and the presence of any other injuries.

In addition to surgical considerations, it’s also important to address your pain management and rehabilitation. Persistent pain after a fracture can be debilitating and may require a multidisciplinary approach, including physical therapy, pain management strategies, and possibly the use of orthotic devices to support the healing process.

As for your specific question about whether you need pins or other forms of internal fixation, this is something that should be discussed with your orthopedic surgeon. They will be able to provide you with a thorough assessment based on your current condition and the results of any imaging studies. If surgery is indicated, they will explain the procedure, the expected recovery time, and the rehabilitation process that will follow.

In summary, while cast immobilization is a standard treatment for heel fractures, it may not be sufficient in all cases, especially if there is no improvement after several weeks. It is crucial to follow up with your healthcare provider to discuss your ongoing symptoms and to determine the best course of action for your specific situation. Early intervention can often lead to better outcomes and a quicker return to normal activities.

Similar Q&A

Can a Fibula Fracture Heal Without Surgery? Understanding Treatment Options

After falling down the stairs, I went to the emergency room immediately, where the doctor diagnosed a bone fracture and applied a cast for immobilization. Two days later, I returned to the orthopedic clinic, and the doctor indicated that the fracture is located on the outer side ...

Dr. Chen Bochen reply Orthopedics
Hello Ms. Liu, your condition is an ankle fracture. The degree of displacement cannot be assessed by the lateral view alone; the anteroposterior view must also be considered for proper evaluation. If the displacement is not severe, it is indeed possible to apply a cast, but regul...

Managing Tibial Fractures: Pain Relief, Cast Issues, and Mobility Tips

Hello Doctor: I am attaching four photos of my fracture. The injury occurred on April 9, and my second follow-up appointment was on April 15. The first two photos were taken during the second visit, while the last two were taken during the first emergency visit. During the first ...

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
Your questions have been repeated. I already answered them on April 15th. Basically, your fracture is unlikely to displace, so it is best for you to follow your doctor's instructions and return for your scheduled appointment to change the cast. Recovery will take approximate...

Alternatives to Heavy Casts for Left Tibia Fractures: What You Need to Know

I have attached a photo of my fracture. My fracture has been casted up to my thigh, and the cast is too heavy for me to get out of bed on my own. I have to rely on my family for assistance. Since my mobility is limited, it has been six days since the fracture, and apart from my v...

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
The photo shows a tibial fracture (shinbone fracture) without displacement. The best treatment option is to use a cast for immobilization. Currently, you are using a posterior splint (long leg splint) that covers only the back of the thigh and calf. It should be changed to a shor...

Are Ankle Braces as Effective as Casts for Ankle Injuries?

A few days ago, I sprained my ankle and an X-ray revealed a small bone fragment in the ankle that is fractured and displaced. The doctor advised against using screws but recommended a cast. However, wearing a cast is quite inconvenient in daily life, so I opted for a rigid ankle ...

Dr. Chen Xingyuan reply Orthopedics
Dear Readers, The treatment for fractures can be most simply and easily addressed with plaster casts. The purpose of immobilization is to reduce displacement, alleviate pain, and promote bone healing. Although having a cast can be quite inconvenient in daily life, it provides th...