Concerns Over Youth Soccer Injuries: Are Health Authorities Speaking Up?

Is there any response from the Department of Health? (Forwarded by the Department of Health)

I am currently 52 years old.
When I was 35, I experienced knee pain after running for just 15 minutes.
Around the age of 46, I also felt pain when climbing steep stairs.
For a period, I thought it was due to being vegetarian and having high uric acid levels; however, I later realized that this might not be the cause.
I then considered whether it was related to a past motorcycle injury, but I remained uncertain.
Recently, a third rehabilitation physician suggested that the root cause might stem from playing soccer in middle school, which could have led to sports-related injuries.
The rehabilitation physician stated, "Sudden impacts to the knee while playing soccer can easily cause injuries; if it were me, I wouldn't play soccer." I never expected that the good intentions of my middle school teacher would lead to my current issues.
Not only do I suffer from knee pain, but due to playing soccer, the development of my feet (including the soles) is uneven, and I am never quite satisfied with the way I walk.
1.
What I don't understand is that soccer may not be suitable for students below middle school age.
I wonder if educational authorities discourage students from playing soccer, and whether health authorities have expressed any concerns about this.
It is worrying that the number of students playing soccer today may lead to an increase in knee pain (injuries) in the years to come.
2.
Additionally, another rehabilitation physician mentioned, "Running is not a good exercise; I have examined the knees of former Mayor Ma Ying-jeou, and they are not in good condition." I wonder if health authorities have also remained silent on this matter.

Li, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2004/04/26

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics

Exercise is beneficial for maintaining health, but sports injuries can potentially lead to joint damage.
However, this should not overshadow the advantages of physical activity.
Physicians worldwide encourage people to engage in regular exercise, while also advising them to choose appropriate activities.
Older individuals should avoid high-intensity workouts, whereas sports like soccer and running are more suitable for younger people.

Reply Date: 2004/04/26

More Info

The concerns you've raised regarding youth soccer injuries and the broader implications of physical activities like running are significant and merit attention from both educational and health authorities. As a 52-year-old who has experienced knee pain linked to past athletic activities, your insights reflect a growing awareness of the potential long-term consequences of youth sports participation.

Youth Soccer and Injury Risks
Soccer, while an excellent way for young people to engage in physical activity, can indeed pose risks, particularly for those under the age of 13. The nature of soccer involves sudden stops, starts, and collisions, which can lead to acute injuries such as sprains, strains, and fractures. Additionally, repetitive stress injuries can develop over time, particularly in the knees, hips, and ankles.
Health authorities and educational institutions should ideally provide guidelines that emphasize the importance of proper training, conditioning, and injury prevention strategies. This includes educating coaches and parents about the risks associated with youth soccer and promoting safe play practices. Unfortunately, there may not be a strong enough voice from health authorities specifically discouraging soccer for younger students, which could lead to an increase in injuries as you have suggested.

Running and Joint Health
Regarding running, it is often touted as a beneficial form of exercise, but it can also lead to injuries, particularly in individuals who may not have the proper technique or conditioning. The statement from the rehabilitation physician regarding the potential downsides of running is valid, especially for those with pre-existing joint issues. Running can exacerbate conditions like patellofemoral pain syndrome, osteoarthritis, and other knee-related problems, particularly in individuals who may have a history of injuries or joint instability.

Recommendations for Health Authorities
1. Education and Awareness: Health authorities should actively promote awareness about the risks associated with youth sports, including soccer and running. This could involve workshops for coaches, parents, and young athletes about injury prevention and proper techniques.

2. Guidelines for Participation: Establishing clear guidelines on age-appropriate sports participation can help mitigate risks. For instance, emphasizing non-contact sports or modified versions of soccer for younger children could reduce injury rates.

3. Monitoring and Research: Continuous research into the long-term effects of youth sports participation is crucial. Health authorities should monitor injury rates and outcomes to better inform policies and recommendations.

4. Encouraging Alternative Activities: Promoting a variety of physical activities that are less likely to result in injury, such as swimming, cycling, or non-competitive games, can provide children with the benefits of exercise without the associated risks of contact sports.

Conclusion
In conclusion, while soccer and running can be beneficial for physical health, the potential for injury, particularly in youth, cannot be overlooked. It is essential for health authorities and educational institutions to take a proactive stance in addressing these concerns. By providing education, establishing guidelines, and promoting safer alternatives, we can help ensure that young athletes can enjoy the benefits of physical activity while minimizing the risk of long-term injuries. Your experiences highlight the importance of these discussions and the need for a collective effort to safeguard the health of future generations.

Similar Q&A

Child's Mysterious Fever After Soccer Incident: Is It Related to Concussion?

A seven-year-old child accidentally got hit by a soccer ball during a class on the morning of August 13th and fell to the ground. According to the child, he closed his eyes and felt like he fainted, but quickly opened his eyes and got back up. He went swimming in the afternoon an...

Dr. Zhang Junwei reply Neurosurgery
Hello, first you should know that there is still doubt regarding the concussion. If it were truly a brain-related illness causing the high fever, the child would likely have already been in a coma, so that possibility is extremely low. Furthermore, the fact that it occurred two w...

Head Injury in Young Children: What Parents Need to Know

Today, my child (1 year and 4 months old) fell from a height of about 60 cm and hit the upper right side of her head against the handle of a wardrobe (made of aluminum alloy), resulting in bleeding about 5 cm above her right ear. (The doctor estimated the wound to be about 0.5 cm...

Dr. Huang Junxiong reply Surgery
Hello~ 1. A child over one year old who has received vaccinations according to the schedule does not need to receive a tetanus vaccine again. 2. For young children who are not yet able to express themselves, their mental status can be assessed through the following observations: ...

Could My Brother's Soccer Injury Lead to Brain Damage?

Your ten-year-old brother frequently participates in soccer matches. A few days ago, during a community-organized friendly match, he was struck on the forehead by a ball kicked from close range. He experienced a headache and was taken to the hospital. An MRI was performed, which ...

Dr. Ding Xianwei reply Neurosurgery
Basically, if there is no loss of consciousness, an MRI is not necessary. As for the subsequent sequelae, continuous observation is required to understand them.

Understanding Growing Pains in Children: Symptoms, Duration, and Impact on Sports

Dr. Hsu: What are the symptoms and duration of growing pains in children? Will engaging in sports training have any adverse effects?

Dr. Xu Xijing reply Orthopedics
Growing pains in children typically occur near the knee and elbow joints. The pain usually lasts from one to two weeks, and during this period, it is important to rest and avoid vigorous activities. Engaging in sports training may exacerbate the pain and prolong the recovery peri...