Radiation Therapy Options for Brain Tumor Patients - Oncology

Share to:

Radiation therapy


Hello doctor, I am a brain tumor patient.
After undergoing stereotactic radiosurgery, my condition has not improved one year later.
In mid-December 2003, I received 30 sessions of intensity-modulated radiation therapy with a dose of 215.
I have just transferred to Chang Gung Memorial Hospital and had surgery, and I have been discharged.
However, the radiology department at Chang Gung has suggested another 25-30 sessions of radiation therapy with a dose of 200.
I would like to ask, when I initially underwent radiation therapy, my physician mentioned that a dose of 215 was already very high and not suitable for a second round.
A portion of the cells removed during surgery has hardened and necrosed, and some of the cells were sent for research, which indicated that the cells are not proliferating well.
The physician at Chang Gung said this suggests that the previous radiation therapy was very successful.
So, am I unsuitable for further radiation therapy, or are there other treatment options available?

kiol, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2004/06/02

Dr. Lin Zongzhe reply Oncology


Hello: 1.
Performing radiation therapy a second time on the same area can lead to cellular necrosis.
2.
Radiation therapy can be performed again on different areas.
3.
If the same area is treated again due to disease recurrence, and after the physician's explanation, the patient agrees, radiation therapy can also be administered.
4.
It is recommended to ask Dr.
Chang Gung for a more detailed explanation of the condition.
Sincerely, Dr.
Chen Sih-Rong, Department of Oncology, Taoyuan Hospital, Ministry of Health and Welfare.

Reply Date: 2004/06/02

More Info


When considering radiation therapy options for brain tumor patients, particularly in your case, it is essential to understand the nuances of treatment, the potential benefits, and the risks involved. Your situation, having undergone previous radiation therapy and now facing the possibility of additional treatment, raises important questions about the appropriateness and safety of further radiation.

Radiation therapy is a common treatment modality for brain tumors, and it can be delivered in various forms, including external beam radiation therapy (EBRT) and stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS), such as Gamma Knife. The goal of radiation therapy is to target tumor cells while minimizing damage to surrounding healthy tissue. However, the cumulative dose of radiation is a critical factor in determining the safety and efficacy of subsequent treatments.

In your case, you mentioned receiving a high dose of radiation (215 cGy) previously, which was deemed "super strong." This indicates that you have already reached a significant threshold of radiation exposure. The concern with additional radiation therapy is the risk of radiation-induced side effects, particularly in the brain, where sensitive structures are located. These side effects can include cognitive decline, memory issues, and other neurological deficits, which can significantly impact your quality of life.

The recommendation from the radiation oncology team at Chang Gung Hospital for an additional 25-30 sessions of radiation at a similar dosage raises questions about the necessity and safety of this approach. It is crucial to have a thorough discussion with your healthcare providers about the rationale behind this recommendation. They may believe that the benefits of further radiation outweigh the risks, especially if there is evidence of residual tumor activity or if the tumor is aggressive.

However, if the initial radiation treatment was successful, as indicated by the necrosis of some tumor cells, it may be worth exploring alternative treatment options. These could include:
1. Stereotactic Radiosurgery (SRS): This technique delivers a high dose of radiation precisely to the tumor while sparing surrounding healthy tissue. It may be suitable for small, well-defined tumors or residual tumor after surgery.

2. Chemotherapy: Depending on the tumor type and molecular characteristics, systemic treatments may be an option. Chemotherapy can sometimes be used in conjunction with radiation or as an alternative if radiation is deemed too risky.

3. Targeted Therapy: If your tumor has specific genetic mutations, targeted therapies may be available that can effectively treat the tumor with potentially fewer side effects than traditional radiation.

4. Clinical Trials: Investigational therapies or novel approaches may be available through clinical trials. These can offer access to cutting-edge treatments that are not yet widely available.

5. Palliative Care: If the focus shifts towards quality of life rather than aggressive treatment, palliative care can provide support and symptom management without the potential burdens of additional radiation.

Ultimately, the decision regarding further radiation therapy should be made collaboratively with your healthcare team, considering your overall health, the specifics of your tumor, and your personal preferences. It may also be beneficial to seek a second opinion from another radiation oncologist or a multidisciplinary tumor board to explore all available options thoroughly.

In summary, while radiation therapy can be a powerful tool in managing brain tumors, careful consideration must be given to the cumulative effects of radiation and the potential for alternative treatments. Open communication with your medical team is vital to ensure that you make informed decisions that align with your treatment goals and quality of life aspirations.

Similar Q&A

Exploring Advanced Treatments for Brain Tumors: Balancing Aggressive and Conservative Approaches

Hello doctor, I previously underwent some treatments for my brain, including radiation therapy and stereotactic radiosurgery, totaling approximately 12,000 units, which has reached saturation. After surgery to remove the tumor, most of it was necrotic. A portion that appeared via...


Dr. Chen Changmu reply Neurosurgery
Hello, the radiation therapy and surgery have been completed. It is currently recommended to continue regular follow-ups to monitor the changes in the tumor, and then discuss the next steps with your physician.

[Read More] Exploring Advanced Treatments for Brain Tumors: Balancing Aggressive and Conservative Approaches


Best Treatment Options for Benign Astrocytoma: A Patient's Guide

Hello doctor, I was diagnosed with a brain tumor in August, and the biopsy showed it to be a benign astrocytoma. The physician recommended gamma knife treatment, but I found online information stating that gliomas are not suitable for radiation therapy. Could you please advise me...


Dr. Ding Xianwei reply Neurosurgery
Hello, it is recommended to consult your attending physician for a clearer understanding of the patient's condition. Sincerely, Dr. Ding Hsien-Wei, Neurosurgery.

[Read More] Best Treatment Options for Benign Astrocytoma: A Patient's Guide


Understanding Brain Tumor Treatment Options and Survival Rates

Dr. Lai: Thank you for your prompt response. My brother's brain tumor surgery was completed on March 15, and he was transferred to a regular ward on March 18. The doctor mentioned that it is not a metastatic tumor, but it is malignant, and he will need chemotherapy and radia...


Dr. Lai Yicheng reply Oncology
Dear Miss Ling, Thank you for your inquiry. I find it difficult to accurately answer your question regarding "survival rates," as this depends on the pathology report for precise determination. Different cancer cells have varying prognoses, and treatment methods also d...

[Read More] Understanding Brain Tumor Treatment Options and Survival Rates


Understanding Bone Metastasis and Treatment Options for Cancer Patients

1. There is neck pain and pain behind the left ear after the head. This may indicate new bone metastases; please arrange for a whole-body bone scan. If new lesions are found, palliative radiation therapy can be considered. 2. There is left facial paralysis. Is there a possibili...


Dr. Lai Yicheng reply Oncology
Side Effects of Brain Radiation Therapy: (Acute Side Effects) 1. During the treatment process, increased intracranial pressure may occur, leading to symptoms such as headaches, nausea, and vomiting. Additionally, localized edema from the tumor may exacerbate these symptoms. In...

[Read More] Understanding Bone Metastasis and Treatment Options for Cancer Patients


Related FAQ

Radiation Therapy

(Oncology)

Brain Tumor

(Oncology)

Radiation

(Oncology)

Cancer Treatment

(Oncology)

Brain

(Neurosurgery)

Nasopharyngeal Cancer

(Oncology)

Melanoma

(Oncology)

Lymphadenopathy

(Oncology)

Other

(Oncology)

Neck

(Oncology)