Do You Need Surgery for Stage 3 Hemorrhoids? Exploring Alternatives - Surgery

Share to:

Is surgery necessary for third-degree hemorrhoids?


Hello Doctor: I went to the hospital for an examination yesterday, and the doctor told me that I have hemorrhoids.
He suggested that surgery would be a more permanent solution, but I am a bit afraid of undergoing surgery.
I would like to know if my condition absolutely requires surgery.
I found some information online about hemorrhoids, and I'm not sure if my situation is classified as grade II or grade III:
Grade II: The patient's anal veins are significantly varicose, and the hemorrhoids may occasionally protrude outside the anus but retract on their own.

Grade III: The patient's hemorrhoids are protruding outside the anus most of the time and must be pushed back in manually.
Currently, after I have a bowel movement, my hemorrhoids protrude outside the anus, and I need to push them back in.
Once pushed back, they do not come out again until the next bowel movement.
After wiping, there is blood, and I experience pain during bowel movements.
I also feel some discomfort at other times.
This situation has been ongoing for four days now.
I recall that in the past, there were times when I noticed some blood after bowel movements, but I thought it was due to excessive wiping causing skin tears.
I would like to ask the doctor if it is possible to avoid surgery and if other methods (such as topical medications, oral medications, or using suppositories) could gradually improve my condition.
I am only 20 years old and having hemorrhoids is really shocking to me.
I have started to change my lifestyle habits, but the issue with hemorrhoids is truly distressing!

BABY, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2004/08/05

Dr. Hou Yongji reply Surgery


Hello: Hemorrhoids are benign conditions caused by lifestyle or dietary habits.
Surgical treatment is a symptomatic approach, while long-term solutions lie in improving lifestyle habits.
However, the discomfort caused by hemorrhoids may sometimes not be alleviated without surgical removal.
Therefore, it is advisable to undergo surgery first to relieve the discomfort of hemorrhoids, and then focus on fundamental lifestyle improvements for a lasting solution.

Reply Date: 2004/08/05

More Info


When it comes to managing hemorrhoids, particularly in the context of Stage 3 hemorrhoids, it's essential to understand both the condition and the available treatment options. Hemorrhoids, also known as piles, are swollen veins in the lower rectum and anus that can cause discomfort, bleeding, and pain. They are classified into two main types: internal and external, with internal hemorrhoids being the ones that can prolapse or protrude outside the anal canal.

Based on your description, it seems you are experiencing symptoms consistent with Stage 3 hemorrhoids. This stage is characterized by hemorrhoids that protrude outside the anus during bowel movements and require manual intervention to be pushed back inside. Symptoms such as bleeding during bowel movements, pain, and discomfort are common and can significantly affect your quality of life.


Surgical vs. Non-Surgical Options
Your doctor has suggested surgery as a definitive solution, which is often recommended for Stage 3 hemorrhoids, especially when conservative treatments have failed to provide relief. However, it's understandable to have concerns about surgery, particularly at a young age. Here are some alternatives and considerations:
1. Lifestyle Modifications:
- Diet: Increasing fiber intake can help soften stools and reduce straining during bowel movements. Foods rich in fiber include fruits, vegetables, whole grains, and legumes. You might also consider fiber supplements if dietary changes are insufficient.

- Hydration: Drinking plenty of water can help prevent constipation, which is a significant contributor to hemorrhoid symptoms.

- Exercise: Regular physical activity can improve bowel function and reduce the risk of constipation.

2. Over-the-Counter Treatments:
- Topical Creams and Ointments: Products containing hydrocortisone or witch hazel can help reduce inflammation and relieve itching and discomfort.

- Suppositories: These can provide localized relief and may contain ingredients that soothe the area.

3. Minimally Invasive Procedures:
- If you are hesitant about traditional surgery, there are less invasive options available, such as rubber band ligation, sclerotherapy, or infrared coagulation. These procedures can be effective for Stage 3 hemorrhoids and typically involve less recovery time than traditional surgery.

4. Monitoring Symptoms:
- If your symptoms are manageable and not severely impacting your daily life, you might choose to monitor your condition while implementing lifestyle changes and over-the-counter treatments. However, it is crucial to keep your healthcare provider informed about any changes or worsening of symptoms.


When to Consider Surgery
While many patients find relief through conservative measures, surgery may become necessary if:
- Symptoms persist despite treatment.

- There is significant bleeding or pain.

- Hemorrhoids become thrombosed (clotted), leading to severe pain.


Conclusion
At 20 years old, experiencing hemorrhoids can indeed be distressing, but know that you are not alone, and many people face similar issues. It's commendable that you are already considering lifestyle changes to improve your condition. While surgery is a definitive solution, it is not the only option. Discuss your concerns and preferences with your healthcare provider, who can help you weigh the benefits and risks of each treatment approach. Ultimately, the goal is to find a solution that alleviates your symptoms and improves your quality of life while considering your comfort and preferences.

Similar Q&A

Do You Need Surgery for External Hemorrhoids? Alternatives Explored

Is surgery the only option for external hemorrhoids? Are there no other methods? Mine is between grade three and four.


Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
If external hemorrhoids are not accompanied by bleeding or pain, surgery is not necessarily required. What are the alternative treatment outcomes we hope to achieve? If the goal is for the external hemorrhoids to disappear, then surgery may be the only option. However, if the foc...

[Read More] Do You Need Surgery for External Hemorrhoids? Alternatives Explored


Non-Surgical Options for Hemorrhoids: Is Endoscopic Ligation Right for You?

I am a patient with both internal and external hemorrhoids, and the internal hemorrhoids have reached stage III. The doctor has recommended surgery. However, I am hesitant to undergo surgery due to the fear of hospitalization and the difficulty of wound care. I came across an art...


Dr. Yang Guojun reply Gastroenterology and Hepatology
Currently, hemorrhoids are primarily treated with ligation; however, in some cases, surgical excision may be necessary. If you are fearful or apprehensive about surgery, you may consider consulting another large hospital or a public hospital. If both colorectal surgeons agree tha...

[Read More] Non-Surgical Options for Hemorrhoids: Is Endoscopic Ligation Right for You?


Understanding Hemorrhoids: When to Consider Surgery and What to Expect

Hello, Doctor. Following your advice, I consulted a colorectal surgeon who confirmed that I have grade 3 hemorrhoids and that my rectum is fine at 6 cm. I was advised to undergo a colonoscopy later since other internal examinations were not possible. The doctor suggested that I m...


Dr. Chen Qifeng reply Gastroenterology and Hepatology
Hello: Stage III hemorrhoids are typically recommended for surgical intervention; however, it is important to understand that recurrence is still possible after hemorrhoid surgery. If you prefer not to undergo surgery at this time, using hemorrhoid ointments and taking warm sitz ...

[Read More] Understanding Hemorrhoids: When to Consider Surgery and What to Expect


Non-Surgical Solutions for Severe Hemorrhoids: What You Need to Know

Hello, Doctor: Thank you for your response. I lack the courage to seek medical treatment, even though I know in my heart that my hemorrhoids are likely at stage three or four. I understand that surgery may be necessary, which makes me even more reluctant to go. Moreover, I don&#x...


Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
Hello: The treatment for hemorrhoids is not limited to surgery; there are many other options available between surgical and medical treatments. The key issues are the effectiveness of these treatments and their suitability for you. These local treatment methods include infrared t...

[Read More] Non-Surgical Solutions for Severe Hemorrhoids: What You Need to Know


Related FAQ