Pneumothorax twice?
Hello Dr.
Chang,
I have experienced two episodes of pneumothorax in my right chest, but neither required chest tube insertion; both times I recovered at home.
However, after browsing some medical websites, I found that doctors recommend surgery after a second pneumothorax episode.
Given my situation, do I need surgery? Since neither episode required chest tube insertion or presented severe symptoms, I feel my family may not understand why surgery is necessary.
Will thoracoscopic surgery have any adverse effects on my body? I am starting school in mid-September; will this affect my academic progress? Thank you.
A Jun, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2004/08/19
Dr. Zhang Zhengda reply Pulmonology
Mr.
A-Jun: Pneumothorax in young individuals typically occurs only once, but some may experience recurrent episodes.
Generally speaking, among patients who have had more than one occurrence, at least one-third will have another episode.
Therefore, for those with recurrent pneumothorax, surgery is recommended to excise the small blebs on the pleura.
This is because no one can predict whether the next occurrence will be mild or result in a large pneumothorax.
Thoracoscopic surgery should be safe for thoracic surgeons.
Additionally, young individuals who have experienced two episodes may qualify for military service exemptions.
Dr.
Chang Cheng-Ta.
Reply Date: 2004/08/19
More Info
Recurrent pneumothorax, or the repeated occurrence of air in the pleural space, can be a concerning condition that may require surgical intervention, especially after multiple episodes. In your case, having experienced two pneumothorax events without the need for chest tube insertion suggests that your episodes were relatively mild. However, the recommendation for surgery after a second occurrence is based on the potential for future complications and the overall management of the condition.
Understanding Pneumothorax
Pneumothorax occurs when air leaks into the pleural space, the area between the lungs and the chest wall. This can happen spontaneously, often in tall, young males, or as a result of trauma or underlying lung disease. Symptoms typically include sudden chest pain and shortness of breath. While some cases resolve on their own, recurrent pneumothorax can lead to more severe complications, including respiratory distress and the need for more invasive treatments.
Why Surgery Might Be Recommended
1. Preventing Recurrence: The primary reason for recommending surgery after multiple pneumothorax episodes is to prevent further occurrences. Surgical options, such as video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS), can help to identify and treat the underlying causes, such as blebs or bullae (small air-filled sacs on the lung surface) that may be prone to rupture.
2. Improving Quality of Life: Recurrent pneumothorax can significantly impact daily activities and quality of life. Surgery can provide peace of mind and reduce the anxiety associated with the possibility of another episode.
3. Avoiding Complications: If pneumothorax recurs frequently, it can lead to complications such as tension pneumothorax, which is a life-threatening condition. Surgical intervention can mitigate this risk.
Surgical Options
The most common surgical procedure for recurrent pneumothorax is VATS, which is minimally invasive. During this procedure, the surgeon makes small incisions in the chest and uses a camera to guide the operation. The benefits of VATS include:
- Less Pain: Compared to open surgery, VATS typically results in less postoperative pain.
- Shorter Recovery Time: Patients often experience a quicker recovery and can return to normal activities sooner.
- Lower Risk of Complications: Minimally invasive techniques generally have fewer complications than traditional open surgery.
Concerns About Surgery
1. Impact on Daily Life: While surgery does involve some recovery time, many patients are able to return to their normal activities within a few weeks. If you have classes starting in mid-September, it would be advisable to discuss your timeline with your surgeon. They can provide a more personalized estimate based on your specific situation.
2. Potential Risks: As with any surgical procedure, there are risks involved, including infection, bleeding, and complications related to anesthesia. However, these risks are generally low, especially with minimally invasive techniques.
3. Family Understanding: It can be challenging to convey the need for surgery to family members who may not understand the medical rationale. It might help to explain that the goal of surgery is to prevent future episodes and complications, thereby ensuring a better quality of life.
Conclusion
In summary, while your previous pneumothorax episodes did not require invasive treatment, the recommendation for surgery after recurrent occurrences is a proactive approach to prevent future complications. Discussing your concerns with your healthcare provider can help clarify the benefits and risks associated with surgery. They can also provide guidance on recovery timelines to help you manage your academic responsibilities effectively. Ultimately, the decision should be made based on a thorough discussion of your specific medical history and lifestyle considerations.
Similar Q&A
Managing Recurring Pneumothorax: Treatment Options After Surgery
Hello, Doctor: I experienced a left-sided pneumothorax in August this year, which was a spontaneous pneumothorax. I underwent conservative treatment with a drainage tube, but unfortunately, it recurred in October. This indicates that my chances of a third recurrence are very high...
Dr. Ke Zhengchang reply Pulmonology
Hello: After experiencing a recurrence of pneumothorax and undergoing thoracoscopic surgery, it is recommended that you return to the original hospital for another chest CT scan to determine how many blebs may potentially rupture and cause pneumothorax again. This information wil...[Read More] Managing Recurring Pneumothorax: Treatment Options After Surgery
Understanding Spontaneous Pneumothorax: Pain Management and Treatment Options
I would like to ask about my pneumothorax, which has recurred for the second time. This time it is not severe, just a mild issue at the apex, so the doctor said surgery is not necessary and it can be allowed to reabsorb. However, I still feel a lot of pain and discomfort. Is this...
Dr. Jian Shuntian reply Pulmonology
Hello: Persistent pain may indicate that the wound has not yet healed. If this occurs a second time, surgical repair is recommended. Best regards.[Read More] Understanding Spontaneous Pneumothorax: Pain Management and Treatment Options
Managing Recurrent Spontaneous Pneumothorax After Bilateral Pleurodesis
Fifteen years ago, I underwent bilateral pleurodesis due to spontaneous pneumothorax, and recently, it has recurred with an estimated air leak of about 30% on both sides, primarily concentrated in the upper and lower pleura. However, the thoracic surgeon stated that due to the ad...
Dr. Shen Bochan reply Pulmonology
Hello: Regarding the expertise of a thoracic surgeon, I do not have experience in the surgical aspects, and it is best to consult your original surgeon for specific situations. As for the issue of flying with a pneumothorax, it is not advisable to fly if a pneumothorax is present...[Read More] Managing Recurrent Spontaneous Pneumothorax After Bilateral Pleurodesis
Understanding Recurring Pneumothorax: Symptoms, Risks, and Recovery
Hello Doctor, I have a history of pneumothorax twice in 2015, once on the left side and once on the right side, both requiring thoracoscopic surgery and pleural adhesion treatment. Last September, I experienced a slight recurrence of air in my right chest, but it was minor and re...
Dr. Yang Wenda reply Pulmonology
Hello: Having undergone pleurodesis can reduce the risk of recurrent pneumothorax, but it does not guarantee that it will not occur again. If you experience severe chest pain or have difficulty breathing, it is advisable to have a follow-up chest X-ray to rule out the possibility...[Read More] Understanding Recurring Pneumothorax: Symptoms, Risks, and Recovery
Related FAQ
(Pulmonology)
Pleural Effusion(Pulmonology)
Difficulty Breathing(Pulmonology)
Chest Tightness(Pulmonology)
Aspiration Pneumonia(Pulmonology)
Respiratory Distress Syndrome(Pulmonology)
Lung Nodule(Pulmonology)
Choking(Pulmonology)
Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease(Pulmonology)
Cough(Pulmonology)