Is Wrist Temperature Measurement Accurate for Infants and Seniors?

Is there a significant discrepancy between the temperature measured near the wrist and the core body temperature?

There is a type of temperature measuring device available on the market that can be worn on infants or on the arm.
If this temperature measurement tool is placed on the wrist, will the data it provides have a significant discrepancy from the actual body temperature? If this device is worn on the wrist of elderly individuals, can it be considered a reliable reference?

Xiao Chen, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2004/09/21

Dr. Yu Xianneng reply Internal Medicine

One is surface body temperature and the other is core body temperature, which can differ by approximately 0.5 to 1.0 degrees Celsius.
If the body temperature exceeds 38 degrees Celsius, it may be necessary to visit a hospital to determine whether it is due to a bacterial or viral infection or another condition such as a gout attack.

Reply Date: 2004/09/21

More Info

When it comes to measuring body temperature, especially in infants and seniors, accuracy is crucial for assessing health conditions. The wrist temperature measurement devices you mentioned are designed for convenience, but they may not provide the most reliable readings compared to traditional methods.

Firstly, it's important to understand that body temperature can be measured in several ways: orally, rectally, axillary (underarm), and tympanic (ear). Each method has its own range of accuracy. For infants, rectal temperature is considered the gold standard, as it provides the most accurate reflection of core body temperature. Axillary measurements are less accurate and can be influenced by external factors, such as ambient temperature and the child's activity level.

Wrist temperature measurement devices typically measure surface temperature rather than core body temperature. This means that the readings can be significantly lower than the actual body temperature, especially in infants and seniors, whose skin may have different thermal properties. Studies suggest that surface temperature readings can differ from core temperature by as much as 0.5 to 1.0 degrees Celsius. Therefore, while a wrist device can provide a general idea of temperature trends, it should not be relied upon for precise medical assessments.

For infants, especially those under three months old, any sign of fever (defined as a rectal temperature of 38 degrees Celsius or higher) warrants immediate medical attention. This is because infants have immature immune systems and are at a higher risk for serious infections. If a wrist temperature measurement indicates a fever, it is advisable to confirm with a more accurate method, such as rectal measurement.

In seniors, the situation is somewhat similar. Age-related changes in skin and subcutaneous tissue can affect temperature readings. Seniors may have a lower baseline body temperature, and their ability to regulate temperature can be compromised due to various health conditions or medications. Therefore, while a wrist temperature measurement can serve as a preliminary check, it should not replace more accurate methods, especially if there are symptoms of illness.

In conclusion, while wrist temperature measurement devices can be convenient and may provide a rough estimate of body temperature, they should not be solely relied upon for accurate health assessments in infants and seniors. For any significant health concerns or symptoms, it is always best to consult a healthcare professional and use more reliable methods of temperature measurement. Regular monitoring of temperature, especially in vulnerable populations like infants and the elderly, is essential for early detection of potential health issues.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Infant Fever: Importance of Temperature Monitoring in Newborns

Hello doctor, may I ask if not measuring the temperature of a baby who is one or two months old could lead to us not knowing if they have a fever, and what impact that might have? Sometimes their forehead feels a bit warm to the touch. Thank you.

Dr. Xiao Kaiwen reply Pediatrics
The skin on an adult's hand is relatively thicker than that of an infant, so measuring an infant's temperature with an adult's hand is often inaccurate. If the hand feels warm, it is advisable to use a calibrated thermometer to measure the infant's temperature...

Understanding Normal Body Temperature: Myths and Facts for Parents

The normal body temperature for humans is generally considered to be between 36.5°C and 37.5°C (97.7°F to 99.5°F). This range is applicable to both adults and children, including newborns. If you occasionally measure a temperature below 36°C (96.8°F), it could be due to various f...

Dr. Chen Bozhang reply Family Medicine
The thermometer may still have discrepancies due to changes in skin temperature and room temperature, even when functioning normally, and it should only be used as a reference. If a child has any issues, it is important to continuously monitor their body temperature and other phy...

Understanding Hypothermia in Children: When to Seek Medical Attention

On December 16, the child bumped their head while getting off the bed. On December 19, a follow-up visit indicated that everything was fine, but the child was still observed to have shaking during sleep. On December 31, the child had a fever, and on January 1, they visited a pedi...

Dr. Xiao Kaiwen reply Pediatrics
During sleep at night, peripheral blood vessels constrict, which can sometimes lead to a decrease in peripheral temperature. While ear thermometers or axillary temperature measurements are convenient, they can often have significant inaccuracies. I believe that measuring the true...

Understanding Your Baby's Temperature: When to Worry and How to Care

My baby's body temperature ranges from 36.3 to 36.7 degrees Celsius, usually around 36.4. The nurse at the hospital where I gave birth mentioned that my baby's temperature is lower than that of most infants. Sometimes, when he cries very hard, his hands and feet turn pu...

Dr. Xiao Kaiwen reply Pediatrics
Such a body temperature is not significantly low. As long as the appetite and activity levels are normal, I believe it is acceptable. Typically, infants a few months old have not fully matured in their autonomic nervous system and peripheral blood circulation, making their body t...