Hemorrhoid Surgery: An Overview of Options and Anesthesia - Surgery

Share to:

Regarding hemorrhoid surgery?


I believe my hemorrhoids are at grade 3 – they protrude during bowel movements and cannot be pushed back in, requiring sitz baths for cleaning before applying medication to push them back.
I have consulted with hospitals such as Taipei Medical University Hospital, Chang Gung Memorial Hospital, and Mackay Memorial Hospital, all of which have recommended surgery.
I am very concerned about the potential complications and anesthesia associated with surgery.

Now that there are options like hemorrhoidectomy and ultrasound-assisted surgery, I would like to ask the physician: In the case that surgery is necessary, can I request general anesthesia instead of local anesthesia? Additionally, the doctor mentioned that my condition is still suitable for a hemorrhoidectomy.
Is it true that a hemorrhoidectomy has a lower risk of complications? After the surgery, under normal circumstances, is there no risk of recurrence? Thank you.

allen, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2004/12/13

Dr. Wang Qichao reply Surgery


Hello: There are various anesthesia methods for hemorrhoid surgery (local anesthesia, spinal anesthesia, general anesthesia, etc.), depending on the practices of different hospitals and physicians.
With current anesthesia techniques, it is quite safe and rarely results in complications.
Traditional hemorrhoid surgery has its drawbacks, but it also has advantages.
The most significant disadvantage is postoperative pain, with some individuals describing it as if a piece of glass is being cut at the anal opening.
Additionally, slow wound healing is another drawback, but its greatest advantage is the minimal chance of recurrence, usually less than five percent.
As for surgical complications, bleeding occurs in about three percent of cases, with infections and anal stenosis being other potential issues, but these rates are approximately one percent.
The circumferential excision surgery has only been adopted in the country for a few years, and there are no extensive long-term results available yet.
However, initial reports are mostly positive.
Nonetheless, circumferential excision surgery has inherent limitations: (1) it is not covered by health insurance and costs approximately 15,000 to 20,000 TWD; (2) it is not suitable for individuals who have previously undergone anal treatments (such as ligation, sclerotherapy, etc.), or those with severe prolapse, anal fissures, or anal infections.
This is my understanding and I hope it serves as a reference for you.
Sincerely, Dr.
Wang Qichao, Surgeon.

Reply Date: 2004/12/13

More Info


When considering hemorrhoid surgery, particularly for a third-degree hemorrhoid where the tissue protrudes during bowel movements and cannot be manually pushed back, it is essential to understand the surgical options, anesthesia types, and potential outcomes.

Surgical Options
There are primarily two surgical techniques for treating hemorrhoids: hemorrhoidectomy (which can be performed using traditional excision or newer methods like stapled hemorrhoidopexy) and minimally invasive techniques such as rubber band ligation or infrared coagulation. Given your situation, where the hemorrhoids are significant enough to cause discomfort and require surgical intervention, a hemorrhoidectomy is often recommended.
1. Hemorrhoidectomy: This is the most common and effective surgical procedure for severe hemorrhoids. It involves the surgical removal of the hemorrhoidal tissue. While this method can be associated with postoperative pain, it generally has a high success rate in preventing recurrence.

2. Stapled Hemorrhoidopexy: This technique involves using a stapling device to reposition the hemorrhoids and cut off their blood supply. It is less painful than traditional hemorrhoidectomy and has a quicker recovery time, but it may not be suitable for all patients.

3. Minimally Invasive Techniques: These include rubber band ligation, where a rubber band is placed around the base of the hemorrhoid to cut off blood supply, and infrared coagulation, which uses heat to shrink hemorrhoids. These methods are less invasive and can be performed in an outpatient setting but may not be effective for larger hemorrhoids.


Anesthesia Options
Regarding anesthesia, you can discuss your preference for general anesthesia (full sedation) versus local anesthesia (numbing the area).
- General Anesthesia: This option allows you to be completely unconscious during the procedure, which can be beneficial if you are anxious about the surgery or if the procedure is expected to be lengthy or complex. It is essential to inform your anesthesiologist about any past experiences with anesthesia, such as nausea or headaches, as these can influence the choice of anesthetic agents and techniques.

- Local Anesthesia: This is often used for less invasive procedures and allows for quicker recovery times. However, some patients may feel discomfort or anxiety during the procedure, which can be a concern for those with a fear of surgery.


Postoperative Considerations
After surgery, it is common to experience some pain and discomfort, which can be managed with pain medications. The risk of complications, such as infection or excessive bleeding, exists but is generally low when the procedure is performed by an experienced surgeon.
1. Recovery: Most patients can return to normal activities within a week or two, but full recovery may take longer, especially if a traditional hemorrhoidectomy is performed.

2. Recurrence: While hemorrhoid surgery is effective, there is still a possibility of recurrence, particularly if lifestyle factors such as diet and bowel habits are not addressed postoperatively. Maintaining a high-fiber diet, staying hydrated, and avoiding straining during bowel movements are crucial for preventing future issues.

3. Follow-Up Care: Regular follow-up appointments with your surgeon are essential to monitor your recovery and address any concerns that may arise.

In conclusion, if surgery is deemed necessary, you should feel empowered to discuss your anesthesia preferences with your healthcare provider. Understanding the surgical options and potential outcomes will help alleviate some of your concerns. It is also crucial to follow postoperative care instructions to minimize the risk of complications and recurrence.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Anesthesia Options for Hemorrhoid Surgery: Safety and Alternatives

Regarding hemorrhoid surgery, is it true that laser excision has become the standard method? Additionally, what are the anesthesia options—spinal anesthesia or general anesthesia? As I understand it, spinal anesthesia is performed via the spinal nerves, and one of the risks assoc...


Dr. Hou Yongji reply Surgery
Hello: 1. Hemorrhoids are a benign condition closely related to diet and lifestyle habits. The vascular tissue of hemorrhoids is actually a normal part of the human anatomy, so it is impossible to completely eliminate hemorrhoidal tissue unless the anus is removed. Therefore, y...

[Read More] Understanding Anesthesia Options for Hemorrhoid Surgery: Safety and Alternatives


Understanding Hemorrhoid Excision: Anesthesia Options and Recovery Tips

Hello, I have two external hemorrhoids. One has been present for a long time, located slightly above the anal opening, and it doesn't affect my daily activities. However, last Monday, I discovered a new one that is positioned right at the anal opening. This new one feels qui...


Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
Your condition is more like acute thrombotic hemorrhoids. Since it has gradually decreased in size over the past few days, the doctor did not recommend surgery. If surgery is necessary, it will depend on whether a partial or complete hemorrhoidectomy is performed. A partial hemor...

[Read More] Understanding Hemorrhoid Excision: Anesthesia Options and Recovery Tips


Understanding Hemorrhoid Surgery: Specialist Availability and Anesthesia Options

I would like to inquire if the Keelung Hospital under the Department of Health does not have a colorectal surgery department, only a general surgery department. If I choose to undergo hemorrhoid surgery at your hospital, will a colorectal specialist be arranged to handle the proc...


Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
Hello: In response to your question, our hospital's colorectal surgery department is here to assist you. Please visit us according to the outpatient schedule. The surgery I perform uses a combination of local and sedation anesthesia. This method combines the advantages of bo...

[Read More] Understanding Hemorrhoid Surgery: Specialist Availability and Anesthesia Options


Understanding Anal Fistula Surgery: Risks and Anesthesia Options Explained

Dr. Gao has diagnosed an anal fistula and recommends surgery. I would like to ask: 1. What are the risks associated with this surgery? 2. The doctor advocates for general anesthesia, but my research indicates that spinal or local anesthesia is commonly used. Is there a significan...


Dr. Hou Yongji reply Surgery
1. Anorectal surgeries (such as hemorrhoidectomy or fistulotomy) are generally considered minor procedures; however, due to the involvement of structures that control bowel function, careful attention to anatomical details is essential. Therefore, it is advisable to seek treatmen...

[Read More] Understanding Anal Fistula Surgery: Risks and Anesthesia Options Explained


Related FAQ