Asthma: Key Questions About Diagnosis and Treatment

Q: Asthma: Key Questions About Diagnosis and Treatment

Hello Day： Here are brief responses to your concerns： (1) Pulmonary function tests should be conducted with standard procedures, which may require multiple attempts. <br>Even if you feel fatigued by the end, there should be data from your tests that can be referenced by your phys

Could you please clarify your question regarding asthma?

1.
Is asthma diagnosed through pulmonary function tests? If I had to blow several times during the test and the nurse only said the last attempt was acceptable, but I was already fatigued by that point, could this affect the accuracy of the pulmonary function results?
2.
Sometimes when I take a deep breath and reach the peak, I experience a sensation of discomfort and do not feel the same relief as I do after a deep breath.
This leads me to take another deep breath until I achieve that comfortable feeling.
However, after a while, when I take a deep breath again or focus on something else, I no longer feel that sensation.
Is this asthma or some other symptom?
3.
Does taking a bronchodilator make asthma symptoms feel better? If taking it does not improve my breathing, could that indicate a misdiagnosis of asthma by the doctor?

jay, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2004/12/22

Dr. Yang Wenda reply Pulmonology

Hello Day: Here are brief responses to your concerns: (1) Pulmonary function tests should be conducted with standard procedures, which may require multiple attempts.
Even if you feel fatigued by the end, there should be data from your tests that can be referenced by your physician.
(2) Difficulty with deep breathing is often related to emotions, stress, or lack of exercise, and is not necessarily indicative of asthma.
(3) Bronchodilators are also commonly used to treat cough and chest tightness; the response to bronchodilators does not have a direct correlation with a diagnosis of asthma.
In summary, whether you have asthma will be determined by your physician based on a comprehensive assessment of your symptoms, pulmonary function test results, family history of allergies, and other factors.
Best wishes!

Reply Date: 2004/12/22

More Info

Asthma is a chronic respiratory condition characterized by inflammation and narrowing of the airways, leading to difficulty in breathing. Understanding its diagnosis and treatment involves several key components, including lung function tests, symptom evaluation, and response to medications.

1. Diagnosis through Lung Function Tests: Lung function tests, particularly spirometry, are essential in diagnosing asthma. These tests measure how much air you can exhale and how quickly you can do so. If you experienced fatigue during the test, it could affect the accuracy of the results. Ideally, the tests should be performed when you are feeling well and not experiencing any acute symptoms. If you were exhausted by the time of the last blow, it might not reflect your true lung capacity. It's crucial to communicate any fatigue or discomfort to the healthcare provider, as they may need to repeat the test under better conditions.

2. Symptoms and Breathing Difficulties: The sensation of discomfort when taking a deep breath can be indicative of several conditions, including asthma. Asthma symptoms often include wheezing, coughing, chest tightness, and shortness of breath, especially during physical activity or at night. The feeling of needing to take another deep breath for relief could be related to bronchoconstriction, where the airways tighten, making it difficult to breathe deeply. However, this sensation can also arise from anxiety or other respiratory conditions. It’s essential to discuss these symptoms with a healthcare provider, who may recommend further evaluation or monitoring.

3. Response to Bronchodilators: Bronchodilators are medications that help open the airways and make breathing easier. If you take a bronchodilator and do not feel relief, it could suggest that asthma is not the underlying issue, or that your asthma may be poorly controlled. In some cases, other conditions such as chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) or vocal cord dysfunction could mimic asthma symptoms. Therefore, if bronchodilators do not provide relief, further investigation is warranted. Your healthcare provider may consider additional tests or alternative diagnoses based on your response to treatment.

In summary, asthma diagnosis relies heavily on lung function tests and symptom assessment. If you have concerns about the accuracy of your lung function tests or the nature of your symptoms, it is essential to follow up with your healthcare provider. They may suggest a comprehensive asthma action plan, which includes monitoring your symptoms, using a peak flow meter to track lung function at home, and adjusting medications as needed.
Additionally, understanding asthma triggers—such as allergens, exercise, cold air, and respiratory infections—can help manage the condition effectively. Treatment typically involves a combination of long-term control medications (like inhaled corticosteroids) and quick-relief medications (like bronchodilators) to manage acute symptoms. Regular follow-ups with your healthcare provider are crucial to ensure optimal asthma management and to make any necessary adjustments to your treatment plan.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Asthma: Steroid Inhalers, Side Effects, and Diagnosis Concerns

I would like to ask if the inhaler prescribed by the doctor contains steroids. Could it cause side effects? I'm afraid that taking it might harm me, so I haven't used it. I want to know if my condition is really asthma. This situation has occurred in the last two months...

Dr. Qu Changke reply Pulmonology
Dear Mr. Hong, As you mentioned in your other letter, you have not yet visited my clinic. You may have mistaken the physician's name. Based on your questions, there are a few key points to address: 1. Asthma can be classified into intrinsic and extrinsic types, and it is ...

Understanding Asthma: Key Questions for Pediatric Patients

Hello, doctor. I would like to ask you a few questions: Since I was young, I have had colds, but the doctor has never detected wheezing during auscultation. However, since I caught a cold in 2009, I have had approximately six colds, and each time the doctor has noted the presence...

Dr. Xiao Kaiwen reply Pediatrics
The diagnosis of asthma is based on a comprehensive assessment of clinical symptoms, physical examination, and laboratory tests. Clinical symptoms include recurrent cough, wheezing, shortness of breath, chest tightness, and sputum production. Physical examination may reveal wheez...

Understanding Asthma: Symptoms, Diagnosis, and Treatment Options

Hello, doctor. I would like to ask if I have asthma. I have had allergic rhinitis for several years. I always sneeze when I wake up in the morning, and sometimes I experience allergies before bed, which leads to poor sleep quality. I often find myself gasping for air, feeling lik...

Dr. Li Huixiong reply Internal Medicine
Whether your allergic rhinitis is a self-diagnosis or a diagnosis made by a physician, individuals with an allergic constitution often experience issues with their nose, skin, and airways, which manifest as allergic rhinitis, atopic dermatitis, and asthma. It is recommended that ...

How Long Should Asthma Treatment Last and When Can You Stop Medication?

Hello, doctor: May I ask 1. How long does asthma treatment usually last? 2. How long should medication be taken before it can be discontinued?

Dr. Yang Wenda reply Pulmonology
Hello Xiaofang: Here are brief answers to your two questions: Asthma is a chronic inflammatory disease of the airways that is related to genetics. Therefore, if your diagnosis is confirmed as asthma, it cannot be completely cured (as the underlying constitution is difficult to ch...