the Differences Between AHA and Retinoids for Skin Health

What is the difference between A acid and fruit acid?

If applied topically, it can cause the skin to become thinner and lead to increased sensitivity and allergic reactions.

Hua, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2005/01/04

Dr. Zheng Yizhan reply Pharmacology

Tretinoin, commonly known as Retin-A, is not only highly effective in treating acne but also significantly improves skin texture with long-term use.
It helps to lighten hyperpigmentation, increases collagen in the papillary dermis, and restores skin elasticity and thickness.
This occurs through the binding of tretinoin to its receptors in the cell nucleus, triggering a series of genetic responses that stimulate epidermal cell proliferation, collagen synthesis, and reduce enzymatic degradation.

However, the drawbacks of tretinoin cream include photosensitivity and the potential to cause tretinoin dermatitis, leading to redness, swelling, and peeling, necessitating strict sun protection during the day.
Alpha hydroxy acids (AHAs), derived from fruits, encompass a variety of acids including glycolic acid and lactic acid.
AHAs accelerate the metabolism of the stratum corneum and are effective for aging, rough, sun-damaged skin, as well as acne, superficial scars, dark spots, and actinic keratosis, making them highly regarded.
However, they can also cause stinging and redness, and their use should be directed by a dermatologist.
When using tretinoin or AHAs, the skin may thin temporarily due to the shedding of old skin, making it more susceptible to external factors and potential allergic reactions.
Generally, discontinuing the medication allows for recovery.
The concentration of AHAs is directly proportional to their efficacy, but high concentrations can lead to chemical burns and, in severe cases, scarring.
Therefore, regular visits to a dermatologist are recommended.
Chemical peels commonly utilize AHAs or tretinoin, functioning similarly to a "shedding of old skin" to promote dermal regeneration, resulting in smooth and elastic skin.
Due to the post-peel sensitivity to sunlight, cooler and overcast seasons are considered ideal for such treatments.
Since both tretinoin and high concentrations of AHAs are classified as medications, they should be used under the guidance of a dermatologist to avoid improper use, which can lead to mild peeling and redness or severe issues like uneven pigmentation and significant darkening of the skin.
Individuals with sensitive skin should exercise caution.
If any redness, swelling, heat, or discomfort occurs shortly after use under a dermatologist's guidance, it is advisable to discontinue use until the affected skin returns to normal before resuming treatment.

Reply Date: 2005/01/04

More Info

When it comes to skin health, understanding the differences between Alpha Hydroxy Acids (AHAs) and Retinoids (such as Tretinoin) is crucial for effective skincare. Both of these compounds are widely used in dermatology for their beneficial effects on the skin, but they work in different ways and have distinct properties.

AHAs are water-soluble acids derived from fruits, with glycolic acid and lactic acid being the most common. They primarily function as exfoliants, helping to remove dead skin cells from the surface of the skin. This process can improve skin texture, reduce the appearance of fine lines, and enhance overall radiance. AHAs are particularly effective for treating sun-damaged skin, hyperpigmentation, and rough texture. However, they can also cause irritation, especially in sensitive skin types, leading to redness and peeling. Therefore, it is essential to use them as directed and to follow up with sunscreen, as AHAs can increase photosensitivity.

On the other hand, Retinoids (like Tretinoin) are derivatives of Vitamin A and are known for their ability to promote cell turnover and stimulate collagen production. They penetrate deeper into the skin compared to AHAs and are effective in treating acne, reducing fine lines, and improving skin elasticity. Retinoids work by binding to specific receptors in the skin, triggering a series of genetic responses that lead to increased cell proliferation and collagen synthesis. While they are highly effective, retinoids can also cause irritation, especially when first introduced into a skincare routine. Common side effects include redness, peeling, and dryness, which can be particularly pronounced in sensitive skin.

Regarding the concern about skin becoming thinner and more sensitive with the use of these products, it is important to note that both AHAs and retinoids can lead to a temporary thinning of the outer layer of skin (the stratum corneum) as they promote exfoliation and cell turnover. This thinning can make the skin more susceptible to irritation and sensitivity, especially if used excessively or without proper hydration and sun protection. However, with consistent use and proper skincare practices, the skin can adapt and become more resilient over time.

For individuals with sensitive skin or those who are new to these ingredients, it is advisable to start with lower concentrations and gradually increase usage as the skin builds tolerance. Additionally, incorporating a good moisturizer can help mitigate dryness and irritation. It is also recommended to avoid using AHAs and retinoids simultaneously, as this can increase the risk of irritation. Instead, consider alternating their use—applying AHAs in the morning and retinoids at night, or using them on different days.

In summary, both AHAs and retinoids offer significant benefits for skin health, but they should be used thoughtfully, especially in individuals with sensitive skin. Monitoring your skin's response and adjusting your routine accordingly is key to achieving the desired results without adverse effects. Always consult with a dermatologist if you have concerns about how to incorporate these ingredients into your skincare regimen, especially if you experience persistent irritation or sensitivity.

Similar Q&A

Understanding AHA and Retinoids for Acne Scars and Skin Texture

Hello, Doctor: Last year, I developed a lot of acne on my face. After seeing a doctor and taking antibiotics, I had to stop due to severe headaches that significantly affected my work mood. Later, I successfully improved my acne by eating more fruits, but while the acne cleared u...

Dr. Zheng Lizhen reply Dermatology
Hello: 1. The topical retinoids (A acids) and alpha hydroxy acids (AHAs) available at general pharmacies cannot exceed the concentration limits set by the Department of Health for cosmetic products. To achieve therapeutic effects, a prescription from a physician after an examinat...

AHA vs. Retinoids: Which is More Effective for Acne Scars?

Hello doctor, could you please tell me which is more effective for treating acne scars, Tretinoin or Azelaic Acid? Thank you for your response.

Dr. Wu Yuxin reply Dermatology
For pigment scars, it is recommended to use azelaic acid.

Can You Combine AHA and Retinoids Without Skin Irritation?

If the skin does not feel irritated, can alpha hydroxy acids (AHAs) be applied after using retinoic acid (A acid)?

Dr. Li Yufen reply Dermatology
Hello: It is recommended that you use a single type of acid on your skin at a time. Thank you!

Choosing Between Glycolic Peels and Retinoid Creams for Acne

Hello, Doctor. I would like to ask you about whether to choose glycolic acid peels or tretinoin cream. I have a question regarding my skin condition. Currently, my T-zone is oily, I have a lot of comedones, and my cheeks are red. I am unsure whether to opt for glycolic acid peels...

Dr. Jiang Zheen reply Dermatology
Alpha hydroxy acid (AHA) peels can improve pore congestion and enhance the absorption and efficacy of acne medications. As for tretinoin (commonly referred to as retinoic acid), it is the most effective medication for acne, but it requires at least four months of use. In my perso...