Ligament displacement
Hello: Two years ago, I suffered a fracture in my left wrist due to a car accident.
It healed after two months, but later, a doctor diagnosed a ligament displacement that required surgery to insert screws for stabilization.
Currently, I often experience soreness due to work, sometimes feeling like something is stuck, and my fingers occasionally feel numb while doing tasks.
I have seen many doctors, and they all suggested that I should have the screws removed for improvement.
However, my attending physician said that removal is unnecessary and that soreness is normal, advising me to avoid heavy lifting.
I am really confused about whether I should have the screws removed or not.
Would removal be beneficial? Is there any impact on my future if I do not have them removed? Thank you.
Yin, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2005/03/30
Dr. Ye Qingnian reply Orthopedics
X-ray examination of screws implanted during surgery is necessary to determine if they are protruding and affecting joint movement; if not, they do not need to be removed.
Reply Date: 2005/03/30
More Info
After undergoing ligament displacement surgery and having screws inserted for stabilization, it's understandable to have concerns about whether or not to remove those screws, especially given your ongoing symptoms of discomfort and the sensation of something being caught in your wrist.
Firstly, it's important to recognize that the presence of screws or other hardware in the body can sometimes lead to discomfort, especially if they are located near nerves or other sensitive structures. The symptoms you describe—persistent aching, a feeling of something being stuck, and occasional numbness in your fingers—could potentially be related to the hardware itself, but they could also stem from the original injury or the healing process.
In many cases, screws and plates used in orthopedic surgeries are left in place unless they cause significant problems. The rationale behind this is that, in most instances, the body can adapt to the presence of these foreign objects without major complications. However, if the screws are causing pain or functional limitations, it may be worth considering their removal.
Here are some factors to consider regarding the removal of screws:
1. Symptom Relief: If multiple doctors have suggested that removing the screws could alleviate your symptoms, it may be worth pursuing this option. Persistent pain and discomfort that affects your daily activities can significantly impact your quality of life.
2. Risk of Removal: While removing screws is generally a straightforward procedure, it does carry some risks, such as infection, bleeding, or damage to surrounding tissues. However, if the screws are indeed contributing to your symptoms, the benefits of removal may outweigh these risks.
3. Timing of Removal: If your symptoms are severe and persistent, discussing the timing of the removal with your orthopedic surgeon is crucial. Some surgeons prefer to wait until the bone has fully healed before removing hardware, while others may be more proactive if they believe the hardware is causing issues.
4. Long-term Effects: Leaving the screws in place typically does not lead to long-term complications unless they cause significant pain or functional impairment. However, if you continue to experience discomfort, it may lead to chronic pain or other issues over time.
5. Consultation with Specialists: If you feel uncertain about your current surgeon's recommendations, seeking a second opinion from another orthopedic specialist can provide additional insights. They may have different perspectives on whether the screws should be removed based on your specific symptoms and medical history.
In conclusion, while many patients can live comfortably with screws in place, your ongoing symptoms warrant a thorough evaluation. If the screws are indeed the source of your discomfort, removal could potentially lead to significant improvement in your symptoms and overall function. It's essential to have an open dialogue with your healthcare provider about your concerns and to explore all available options for your situation.
Similar Q&A
Concerns About Retained Screws After ACL Repair Surgery: Pain and Complications
Hello, about 4 to 5 years ago, I underwent surgery for posterior cruciate ligament repair and fixation. A year later, after the screws were removed, the doctor mentioned that there were still three screws left inside because they were close to nerves and blood vessels, so they we...
Dr. Wang Shouji reply Orthopedics
In general, this type of steel pin does not necessarily need to be removed. If removal is required, there may be some minor risks involved, but as long as precautions are taken, the risks should be minimal. It is important to consider whether removal is absolutely necessary. Wish...[Read More] Concerns About Retained Screws After ACL Repair Surgery: Pain and Complications
Post-Surgery Concerns: Will Screws Shift After Ankle Ligament Repair?
Hello, doctor! I would like to ask you about my condition. I have a sports injury that caused a separation of the bone above the joint on the outer side of my left foot, along with a ligament tear. After observing for six weeks, the doctor decided to perform a screw fixation surg...
Dr. Chen Bochen reply Orthopedics
Hello, ordinary screws are not that fragile. If the screws are loose, it usually accompanies an increase in pain, and there would be noticeable pain at the moment of injury. If you are still concerned, you can return for a follow-up appointment and ask your original surgeon to pe...[Read More] Post-Surgery Concerns: Will Screws Shift After Ankle Ligament Repair?
Is It Too Early to Remove Screws Four Months Post-Surgery?
Hello, I was in a car accident in mid-November last year, resulting in a fibula fracture and a tear at the distal end of the deltoid ligament. Although the fibula only had a small transverse fracture, the doctor still placed three internal fixation screws, and the torn deltoid li...
Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
If the fracture has healed and does not affect stability, and there are protruding bone screws, consideration can be given to removing the screws; otherwise, it may lead to skin perforation, which would be problematic.[Read More] Is It Too Early to Remove Screws Four Months Post-Surgery?
Understanding Shoulder Labrum Repair: Concerns About Titanium Screws
Hello, Doctor. I have been diagnosed with a tear in the supraspinatus muscle and a labral tear. I have been experiencing pain for a long time, and after more than a year of ineffective rehabilitation, my doctor has recommended arthroscopic surgery. However, I have several concern...
Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
1. Usually, the screws used to fix ligaments do not need to be removed, and if removal is necessary, it can be quite difficult. You can still engage in physical activity later, and the chance of loosening is minimal. You may want to consult your attending physician about this. ...[Read More] Understanding Shoulder Labrum Repair: Concerns About Titanium Screws
Related FAQ
(Orthopedics)
Ligament Tear(Orthopedics)
Ligament(Orthopedics)
Postoperative(Orthopedics)
Dislocation(Orthopedics)
Post-Clavicle Fracture Surgery(Orthopedics)
Ankle Ligament Rupture(Orthopedics)
Distal Radioulnar Joint Dislocation(Orthopedics)
Arthroscopic Surgery(Orthopedics)
Posterior Cruciate Ligament(Orthopedics)