Keloid
I developed a keloid at the site where I received the BCG vaccine, but I later got multiple ear piercings without any issues.
What does this indicate? Is there a difference in the severity of keloid predisposition? Since I had no problems with ear piercings, can I get more? I've heard that as long as the wound doesn't affect the dermis, it shouldn't matter—does this have any basis? Also, if a tattoo doesn't affect the dermis, is it okay? Thank you!
pp, 10~19 year old female. Ask Date: 2005/05/16
Dr. Huang Ruiyun reply Dermatology
Individuals with keloid-prone skin may or may not develop keloids on their ears.
It is also possible for one area to be unaffected while another area develops keloids.
Tattoos will inevitably damage the dermis.
It is advisable to refrain from getting ear piercings or tattoos, as you do not have the risk tolerance for such endeavors.
Reply Date: 2005/05/16
More Info
Keloids, also known as hypertrophic scars, are raised areas of scar tissue that develop at the site of an injury or incision. They are formed due to an overproduction of collagen during the healing process, which can lead to excessive tissue formation. Understanding keloids is particularly important for individuals considering body modifications such as piercings and tattoos, as these procedures can potentially trigger keloid formation in susceptible individuals.
In your case, the development of a keloid at the site of your BCG vaccination indicates that you may have a predisposition to keloid formation. However, the fact that you have had multiple ear piercings without any issues suggests that your body may not react the same way to all types of injuries. Keloid formation can vary significantly from person to person, and some individuals may experience keloids in response to certain types of trauma while remaining unaffected by others.
Keloids can indeed vary in severity. Some individuals may develop small, flat keloids that are not particularly bothersome, while others may experience larger, more prominent keloids that can cause discomfort or cosmetic concerns. The severity of keloid formation can depend on several factors, including genetics, skin type, the location of the injury, and the depth of the wound.
Regarding your question about whether you can continue to get piercings, it is essential to consider your individual risk factors. If you have a history of keloid formation, it is advisable to proceed with caution. While some people with keloid-prone skin can get piercings without issues, others may find that even minor injuries can trigger keloid development. Consulting with a dermatologist or a healthcare professional experienced in keloids can provide personalized advice based on your medical history and skin type.
The notion that as long as a wound does not penetrate the dermis (the deeper layer of skin), it will not lead to keloid formation is somewhat misleading. While superficial injuries that do not reach the dermis may have a lower risk of keloid formation, it is not a guarantee. Keloids can form from various types of skin trauma, including superficial injuries, surgical incisions, and even acne lesions. Therefore, it is crucial to be aware of your skin's response to different types of trauma.
As for tattoos, the risk of keloid formation can also vary. Tattoos involve the insertion of ink into the dermis, which means they can potentially trigger keloid formation in susceptible individuals. If you have previously experienced keloids, it is advisable to discuss your plans for a tattoo with a dermatologist. They may recommend patch testing or other precautions to minimize the risk of keloid formation.
In summary, while your experience with ear piercings suggests that you may not be highly susceptible to keloids, it is essential to remain cautious, especially given your history of keloid formation at the BCG vaccination site. Consulting with a healthcare professional can help you make informed decisions about future piercings and tattoos, ensuring that you take the necessary precautions to minimize the risk of keloid development.
Similar Q&A
Is Ear Piercing Keloid Formation Considered Hypertrophic Scarring?
Hello, is the hypertrophy that occurs after getting an ear piercing considered keloid? If so, is it safe to undergo aesthetic hair removal? Thank you.
Dr. Wu Yuxin reply Dermatology
It is advisable to first assess the extent of hyperplasia.[Read More] Is Ear Piercing Keloid Formation Considered Hypertrophic Scarring?
Understanding Keloids: Impact on Skin Treatments and Surgery
Hello Dr. Lin, I would like to inquire about the recent occurrence of keloids. Since I have acne scars on my face, I am considering whether I can undergo a dermabrasion procedure. Additionally, I would like to ask if having a keloid-prone constitution affects the healing process ...
Dr. Lin Mingxiu reply Dermatology
Hello~ 1. Individuals with a keloid tendency are generally advised against undergoing dermabrasion surgery. Typically, keloids are more likely to develop in areas of high tension, such as the chest, back, upper arms, and shoulders, with the chin being a common site on the face, a...[Read More] Understanding Keloids: Impact on Skin Treatments and Surgery
How to Address Keloids After Tattoo Removal: A Dermatologist's Guide
I would like to ask, three years ago I had a car accident that caused a keloid on my nose, but there were no other wounds that developed. Regarding the depth of the injury, I remember when I was in elementary school, I accidentally cut my finger down to the bone, but I did not de...
Dr. Jiang Zheen reply Dermatology
Keloids can be treated with local corticosteroid injections, silicone gel sheets, or laser therapy. Wishing you well.[Read More] How to Address Keloids After Tattoo Removal: A Dermatologist's Guide
Can Tattooing Help Conceal Stretch Marks for Keloid-Prone Skin?
Hello, I would like to ask if I have a keloid-prone condition and I want to use tattooing to conceal stretch marks on my abdomen. Since the wound will scab over, will this cause keloid formation to increase?
Dr. Wu Yuxin reply Dermatology
It mainly depends on the depth; if the puncture is deeper, it will still occur.[Read More] Can Tattooing Help Conceal Stretch Marks for Keloid-Prone Skin?
Related FAQ
(Dermatology)
Tattoo(Dermatology)
Keloid(Plastic Surgery)
Tattoo Removal(Dermatology)
Stretch Marks(Dermatology)
Foreskin(Dermatology)
Moles, Birthmarks(Dermatology)
Nipples(Dermatology)
Herpes Zoster(Dermatology)
Bruising(Dermatology)