How to Determine the Best Treatment for Warts: Freezing vs. Surgery

Q: How to Determine the Best Treatment for Warts: Freezing vs. Surgery

Hello： Generally, dermatologists often recommend cryotherapy as it does not create open wounds, making it easier to care for and less disruptive to daily life. <br>However, in cases of more stubborn lesions, other adjunctive treatment methods may be employed. <br>If you have skin

How is the treatment method for warts determined?

I have a question.
Both my brother and I have had experiences with warts.
When my brother went to see a doctor, he was treated with cryotherapy.
According to him, there were no wounds during the treatment, and he didn't need to change any dressings.
After two sessions of cryotherapy, he was cured.
On the other hand, when I went to a different hospital for treatment, the doctor told me that I needed to undergo a minor surgical procedure.
Thinking it was best to treat it early, I agreed.
However, after the surgery, I had a large wound, which wasn't painful, but I had to change dressings frequently, and it was inconvenient to walk.
Why are there such different treatment methods? Shouldn't there be multiple treatment options suggested for similar conditions, with the doctor recommending what they believe is the best approach? Is surgery really the best method? Based on my brother's and my experiences, cryotherapy seems to be the better option, right? Is there a way to determine how to proceed with treatment? Thank you for your response!

BWTDJ, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2005/08/12

Dr. Zheng Lizhen reply Dermatology

Hello: Generally, dermatologists often recommend cryotherapy as it does not create open wounds, making it easier to care for and less disruptive to daily life.
However, in cases of more stubborn lesions, other adjunctive treatment methods may be employed.
If you have skin issues, please consult a dermatologist for an accurate diagnosis and treatment.
Sincerely, Dr.
Cheng Li-Chen, Dermatology.

Reply Date: 2005/08/12

More Info

When it comes to treating warts, two common methods are cryotherapy (freezing) and surgical excision. Each method has its own advantages and disadvantages, and the choice between them often depends on various factors, including the type of wart, its location, the patient's medical history, and personal preferences.

Cryotherapy involves applying liquid nitrogen to the wart, which freezes the tissue and causes the wart to fall off after a few days. This method is generally quick, often performed in a doctor's office, and typically requires no anesthesia. Patients may experience some discomfort during the procedure, but it is usually minimal. One of the main advantages of cryotherapy is that it leaves little to no scarring, and there is no need for extensive aftercare, such as changing dressings or managing a large wound. Many patients find this method appealing due to its convenience and effectiveness, especially for common warts.

On the other hand, surgical excision involves cutting out the wart and some surrounding tissue. This method may be recommended for larger warts, warts that are resistant to other treatments, or warts located in sensitive areas where precision is crucial. While surgical excision can be effective, it typically results in a larger wound that requires more care, including regular dressing changes and monitoring for signs of infection. Patients may also experience more discomfort during recovery compared to cryotherapy.

The choice between these two methods can depend on several factors:
1. Type and Size of Wart: Some warts, such as plantar warts or those that are particularly large or deep, may respond better to surgical excision. In contrast, smaller, superficial warts are often effectively treated with cryotherapy.

2. Location: Warts in sensitive areas, such as the face or genitals, may be treated with cryotherapy to minimize scarring. Conversely, warts on the hands or feet may be excised if they are causing pain or discomfort.

3. Patient Preference: Some patients may prefer a quick, less invasive option like cryotherapy, while others may opt for surgical excision if they believe it will provide a more definitive solution.

4. Medical History: Patients with certain medical conditions or those who are immunocompromised may require a more cautious approach, which could influence the choice of treatment.

5. Response to Previous Treatments: If a wart has not responded to cryotherapy in the past, a doctor may recommend surgical excision as a more aggressive approach.

In conclusion, both cryotherapy and surgical excision are effective methods for treating warts, but they cater to different situations and patient needs. It is essential for patients to discuss their options with a healthcare provider who can assess their specific case and recommend the most appropriate treatment. Ultimately, the best treatment is one that balances effectiveness with the patient's comfort and lifestyle considerations. If you or your brother have had different experiences, it could be due to the specific characteristics of your warts or the treatment protocols of the healthcare providers you visited. Always consult with a qualified healthcare professional to determine the best course of action for your individual situation.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Treatment Options for Genital Warts: Freezing vs. Electrocautery

Dear Director Chang, I recently found out that I have genital warts and have also asked my girlfriend to get checked. I would like to know if cryotherapy can be used internally in the vagina, or if electrosurgery is the only option. Since we both have active lifestyles, I am cur...

Dr. Zhang Kunmin reply Obstetrics and Gynecology
Hello, the current treatment options for genital warts include various methods such as cryotherapy, electrocautery, topical medications, and laser therapy. Generally, patients' daily lives are not significantly affected. It is advisable to discuss with the examining physicia...

Fastest Treatments for Plantar Warts: Freezing vs. Topical Medications

What is the fastest method to treat plantar warts? Is cryotherapy more effective than topical medications, or can both methods be used together?

Dr. Wu Yuxin reply Dermatology
Cryotherapy combined with wart treatment solution.

Effective Treatments for Viral Warts: Surgery, Costs, and Recovery Insights

I have been troubled by a problem for a long time! I have developed several viral warts on my hands and soles, commonly known as plantar warts. I have been seeing a dermatologist for nearly a year, during which I have undergone treatments including cryotherapy, electrosurgery, an...

Dr. Huang Ruiyun reply Dermatology
Currently, there is no 100% effective treatment for warts. Some individuals may resolve completely after a single cryotherapy session, while others may have lesions that are just as stubborn as yours. Surgical removal is a rather poor treatment option, with no higher success rate...

What to Do If Freezing Treatment for Warts Fails in Children?

Hello, an eight-year-old boy has a raised hard lump in the nail fold diagnosed by a dermatologist as a "wart." After cryotherapy, the lump is still present. I would like to ask: 1. Should he immediately undergo cryotherapy again? 2. If we wait until four months later du...

Dr. Huang Ruiyun reply Dermatology
Hello! 1. You can do it whenever you have time. 2. If treatment is not performed, the warts may disappear on their own after four months, remain the same, or even multiply. 3. Duofilm (wart treatment solution, manufactured by Steifel) should be used with caution and requires pati...