Can Patients with Chocolate Cysts Safely Use Evening Primrose Oil?

Chocolate cyst

Hello Doctor: Two years ago, I was diagnosed with a chocolate cyst (endometriosis), which was already 7-8 cm in size at the time of discovery.
The doctor recommended surgical treatment, and after the surgery, I continued to take oral contraceptives and returned to the hospital for follow-up examinations every six months, all of which were normal.
About six months ago, I started taking traditional Chinese medicine for treatment and regulation.
Three months ago, my doctor suggested that I start taking evening primrose oil.
However, I recently learned that people with tumors should not take evening primrose oil.
Yet, my traditional Chinese medicine doctor told me that many patients with chocolate cysts use evening primrose oil for treatment (taking it for four months, then pausing for observation).
These two statements are in direct opposition, and I am confused.
Can patients with chocolate cysts take evening primrose oil? Is the rapid recurrence of my condition related to this? Thank you, doctor, for your clarification.

cc, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2005/08/29

Dr. Lin Qingzhong reply Traditional Chinese Medicine

Hello, online friends!
1.
Evening primrose, also known as Oenothera biennis, is a biennial herb.
The flowers of the evening primrose bloom slowly in the evening and wither by dawn, making it a plant that only blooms for the moon.
Native Americans used evening primrose to treat wounds, dermatitis, and other ailments.
In the 19th century, evening primrose was brought to Europe, and in the 20th century, scientists discovered that its seeds contain a special fatty acid—gamma-linolenic acid (GLA).
2.
Evening primrose is commonly used as a folk remedy for gynecological or other conditions in Western cultures, but it is rarely utilized in traditional Chinese medicine in Taiwan or mainland China.
Whether evening primrose can be used to treat gynecological conditions such as endometriosis is still not well established, and the efficacy claimed by health food products on the market is subjective.
3.
If you have conditions similar to endometriosis, it is advisable to consult qualified practitioners of both Western and traditional Chinese medicine for appropriate diagnosis and treatment.
This approach is more likely to effectively address the issue and avoid misdiagnosis.

Finally, I wish you all the best.

Dr.
Lin Ching-Chung, Director of the Traditional Chinese Medicine Department, Fengyuan Hospital.

Reply Date: 2005/08/29

More Info

When it comes to the use of Evening Primrose Oil (EPO) for patients with chocolate cysts (endometriomas), there are several factors to consider. Chocolate cysts are a manifestation of endometriosis, where endometrial tissue grows outside the uterus, often leading to cyst formation on the ovaries. The management of endometriosis can be complex and varies from patient to patient.

Evening Primrose Oil is known for its high content of gamma-linolenic acid (GLA), an omega-6 fatty acid that is believed to have anti-inflammatory properties. Some proponents suggest that EPO may help alleviate symptoms associated with hormonal imbalances and menstrual discomfort, which could be beneficial for women suffering from endometriosis. However, the evidence supporting its efficacy in treating endometriosis or preventing the recurrence of chocolate cysts is limited and somewhat anecdotal.

Your situation is particularly nuanced because you have a history of significant chocolate cysts and have undergone surgical intervention. The recurrence of your cyst, despite the use of EPO, raises important questions. While some practitioners, including your traditional Chinese medicine (TCM) doctor, may advocate for the use of EPO in managing endometriosis symptoms, others may caution against it, especially in the context of existing tumors or cysts. This divergence in opinion can be confusing, but it reflects the complexity of treating conditions like endometriosis.

From a medical standpoint, it is essential to consider the following:
1. Hormonal Influence: Endometriosis is influenced by hormonal changes, particularly estrogen. EPO may have an effect on hormone levels, and while it is often used to help with PMS and other hormonal issues, its impact on endometriosis is not well understood. Some studies suggest that omega-6 fatty acids can promote inflammation, which may not be ideal for someone with endometriosis.

2. Monitoring and Follow-Up: Given your history of chocolate cysts and the recent recurrence, it is crucial to maintain regular follow-ups with your healthcare provider. Monitoring the size of the cyst and any associated symptoms is vital in managing your condition effectively.

3. Individual Response: Each patient's response to supplements like EPO can vary. While some may find relief from symptoms, others may not experience any benefits or could potentially see adverse effects. It is essential to listen to your body and discuss any changes with your healthcare provider.

4. Consultation with Specialists: If you are considering continuing EPO or any other supplement, it may be beneficial to consult both your gynecologist and a qualified nutritionist or herbalist who understands your medical history and can provide tailored advice.

5. Alternative Treatments: There are various treatment options for managing endometriosis, including hormonal therapies, pain management strategies, and lifestyle modifications. Exploring these options with your healthcare provider may provide a more comprehensive approach to managing your condition.

In conclusion, while some patients with chocolate cysts may use Evening Primrose Oil, it is essential to approach this decision with caution and under the guidance of your healthcare team. The relationship between EPO and the recurrence of chocolate cysts is not definitively established, and individual responses can vary significantly. Regular monitoring and open communication with your healthcare providers will be key in managing your health effectively.

Similar Q&A

Can You Take Evening Primrose Oil with Endometriosis?

I have endometriosis (chocolate cyst) which is benign, and I am currently taking oral contraceptives for treatment. Previously, I heard my doctor mention evening primrose oil, but he only briefly mentioned it, and I didn't think much of it at the time. Recently, a friend gav...

Dr. Li Guanghan reply Obstetrics and Gynecology
Dear Sir/Madam: Be very cautious with dietary supplements that have uncertain ingredients and effects. If your primary physician does not actively recommend them, there is no absolute necessity to take them. Dr. Li Guanghan, Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Hsinchu Hospit...

The Impact of Evening Primrose Oil on Benign Breast Conditions

Hello, Director. I am an internet user who is particularly concerned about healthcare information. Recently, I discovered something resembling a fibrocystic mass in my breast. After an ultrasound and fine needle aspiration, my doctor confirmed that it is not a malignant tumor and...

Dr. Lin Shuilong reply Surgery
In response: From a medical perspective, breast tumors and fibrocystic changes do not disappear due to medication or dietary supplements. The use of evening primrose oil leading to the disappearance of benign breast tumors is purely anecdotal and lacks medical validation. The red...

Can Women with Fibroadenomas Take Evening Primrose Oil Safely?

Can I take evening primrose oil if I have breast fibromas and fibrocystic breast disease? I previously had an examination at Chang Gung Memorial Hospital, and the doctor advised me to return for follow-ups once a year. I also have dysmenorrhea, and I would like to take evening pr...

Dr. Li Guanghan reply Obstetrics and Gynecology
Hello: 1. For breast tumor issues, please consult a breast surgeon. 2. If you have long-term menstrual pain, please come in for an examination to determine whether it is primary dysmenorrhea or secondary dysmenorrhea caused by conditions such as endometriosis. After that, we can ...

Can Traditional Chinese Medicine Cure Chocolate Cysts and Aid Fertility?

I have a chocolate cyst that is about 6 centimeters in size. Can I treat it with traditional Chinese medicine? This is my second occurrence of a chocolate cyst; the first one was removed surgically, but it recurred shortly after. I do not want to undergo surgery again. Additional...

Dr. Yan Sumei reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
When consuming Si Wu Tang or Zhong Jiang Tang, adjustments should be made according to individual constitution for effective treatment. Standard formulations of Si Wu Tang and Zhong Jiang Tang, which are designed for convenience, may not be suitable for long-term use by everyone....