Amniocentesis and Neural Tube Defect Risks in Pregnancy

Questions regarding amniocentesis during prenatal care?

Hello Dr.
Huang, I previously underwent a blood test for Down syndrome in the obstetrics and gynecology department, and the results indicated a risk of 1 in 1250 for Down syndrome, but a risk of 1 in 37 for neural tube defects.
Initially, the doctor suggested monitoring with ultrasound or referred me to a larger hospital for a detailed ultrasound examination, and did not recommend amniocentesis.
Later, I went to another hospital where the doctor performed a 4D ultrasound and found the brain and spinal cord to be normal.
However, when I returned to the original hospital, the same doctor changed their recommendation and said that amniocentesis was necessary for accurate results.
I feel very confused and conflicted, especially since I am already 21 weeks pregnant.
I would appreciate it if you could help answer the following questions (the more detailed, the better), as I am really worried:
1.
If the ultrasound shows that the brain and spinal cord appear normal, is there still a high risk that the child will have cognitive impairment or other issues in the future? What is the likelihood?

2.
Are both amniocentesis and the previous blood test used to check for elevated levels of alpha-fetoprotein (AFP) in relation to fetal neural tube defects? Does amniocentesis provide more accurate data?
3.
Some doctors have mentioned that elevated levels of alpha-fetoprotein do not necessarily indicate that the fetus has a neural tube defect (and that it is not solely determined by amniotic fluid testing).
In this case, can the results of the amniocentesis be used as a basis for deciding to terminate the pregnancy? Or do you have any other better suggestions? Thank you, a concerned mother.

aaa, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2005/09/11

Dr. Huang Jianxun reply Obstetrics and Gynecology

This is a very important topic.
In principle, high-level ultrasound examinations and amniocentesis complement each other and are necessary.
However, since amniocentesis is an invasive procedure, it carries its own risks.
Regarding the probability of Down syndrome being 1 in 250 and neural tube defects being 1 in 37, whether amniocentesis is absolutely necessary is debatable.
Personally, I believe it is better to seek direct consultation at National Taiwan University Hospital.

Reply Date: 2005/09/11

More Info

Understanding the complexities of prenatal testing, particularly regarding amniocentesis and neural tube defects (NTDs), is crucial for expectant parents. Your concerns are valid, especially given the conflicting information you've received from different healthcare providers. Let's break down your questions to provide clarity.

1. Neural Tube Defects and Cognitive Implications
Neural tube defects, such as spina bifida and anencephaly, occur when the neural tube, which eventually forms the brain and spinal cord, fails to close properly during early fetal development. The risk of cognitive impairment or other developmental issues in a child born with an NTD can vary significantly based on the severity and type of defect.
If a 4D ultrasound shows normal brain and spinal cord development, the likelihood of significant cognitive impairment is generally lower. However, it is important to note that some children with mild forms of NTDs may still experience challenges, but many can lead healthy lives with appropriate interventions. The probability of cognitive issues is not solely determined by the presence of an NTD but also by the specific nature of the defect, the timing of diagnosis, and the interventions available.

2. Amniocentesis and Alpha-Fetoprotein (AFP) Testing
Amniocentesis is a diagnostic procedure that involves extracting amniotic fluid to analyze fetal cells and substances, including alpha-fetoprotein (AFP). Elevated levels of AFP in the maternal blood can indicate a higher risk of NTDs, but it is not definitive.
While blood tests can suggest the possibility of NTDs, amniocentesis provides a more accurate assessment. It allows for direct measurement of AFP levels in the amniotic fluid and can also provide genetic information about the fetus. Therefore, if your healthcare provider recommends amniocentesis, it is likely to obtain a clearer picture of the fetal condition, especially given the elevated risk indicated by the initial screening.

3. Interpreting Amniocentesis Results
It is crucial to understand that elevated AFP levels do not automatically mean that a fetus has an NTD. Many factors can contribute to elevated AFP, including multiple gestations, incorrect dating of the pregnancy, or other non-defect-related issues.
Regarding the decision to terminate a pregnancy based on amniocentesis results, this is a deeply personal choice and should be made with careful consideration and counseling. The results of the amniocentesis can provide valuable information about the health of the fetus, but they should be discussed thoroughly with your healthcare provider, who can help interpret the results in the context of your specific situation.

Recommendations
1. Seek a Second Opinion: If you feel uncertain about the recommendations from your current healthcare provider, it may be beneficial to seek a second opinion from a maternal-fetal medicine specialist. They can provide more specialized insight into your situation.

2. Discuss Concerns Openly: Bring up your concerns about the conflicting advice regarding amniocentesis and the implications of the tests. A good healthcare provider will take the time to address your worries and explain the rationale behind their recommendations.

3. Consider Genetic Counseling: If you are facing difficult decisions regarding your pregnancy, genetic counseling can provide support and information tailored to your specific circumstances. Counselors can help you understand the risks, benefits, and implications of various testing options.

4. Stay Informed: Educate yourself about neural tube defects and the implications of various prenatal tests. Understanding the medical terminology and the potential outcomes can empower you to make informed decisions.

In conclusion, while the prospect of neural tube defects and the associated testing can be daunting, being proactive in your healthcare decisions and seeking clarity from your providers can help alleviate some of the anxiety. Remember, you are not alone in this journey, and there are resources available to support you through this process.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Amniotic Fluid Testing: Common Concerns for Expecting Mothers

Dr. Wang: Hello! I have received your reply, and I really appreciate your answers. I will visit your clinic when I reach 15 weeks, but before that, I have two questions that I hope you can take the time to answer for me. 1. I previously had blood tests for thalassemia and syphi...

Dr. Wang Jionglang reply Obstetrics and Gynecology
Hello, In response to your question, neural tube defects (NTDs) are a type of abnormal development of the fetal central nervous system. The neural tube is the precursor to the central nervous system, which differentiates into the brain and spinal cord during pregnancy. For vari...

Understanding Neural Tube Defects: Risks, Testing, and Child Health

Hello, doctor. My wife had a blood test for Down syndrome screening during her first pregnancy, and the screening included a risk value for "neural tube defects," which was found to be 1 in 27, clearly abnormal. A high-level ultrasound was performed, and the doctor did ...

Dr. Dong Yuhong reply Obstetrics and Gynecology
Hello: If you have related concerns, you can seek relevant examinations. However, there is currently no direct causal relationship between having an extra vertebra, bone cancer, and the values from screening tests. Thank you!

Understanding Neural Tube Defects: Causes and Essential Tests for Expecting Mothers

At 16 weeks of pregnancy, a blood test was conducted to check for gestational diabetes. During a follow-up visit at 18 weeks, the doctor informed that the incidence of gestational diabetes is low, but there is a potential risk of the fetus having neural tube defects. A detailed e...

Dr. Li Guanghan reply Obstetrics and Gynecology
Down syndrome screening has a higher rate of neural tube defects, which can generally be assessed via ultrasound around 20 weeks of gestation, with a relatively high detection rate. The causes of neural tube defects are unknown and are more prevalent in certain populations. Addit...

Understanding the Risks of Amniocentesis During Pregnancy

I am currently about 17 weeks pregnant. The maternal blood test showed a risk of Down syndrome at 1 in 3000. Although this is considered a low-risk group, I still want to self-fund an amniocentesis. However, I have some concerns. Will the needle used for the amniocentesis harm th...

Dr. Xu Junzheng reply Obstetrics and Gynecology
Amniocentesis is typically performed under ultrasound monitoring and should not cause any harm. Thank you!