It has been six months, and the scar is still clearly visible?
Hello Dr.
Lee,
Six months ago, I suffered a tibial fracture in the middle part of my left calf due to a car accident.
I did not undergo surgery and instead had it immobilized with a cast for self-healing.
After four months in the cast, it was removed in March of this year.
I am gradually able to walk now, but during my follow-up appointment, the X-ray showed that the fracture line is still clearly visible on the bone.
Is this considered normal? It has been six months since the fracture, but why do I still experience some pain in my ankle and the fracture site after walking for a while? Is it appropriate to start working under these circumstances? Thank you for taking the time to respond!
Ya Yan, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2006/05/07
Dr. Li Wenlin reply Orthopedics
Hello: In response to your question, orthopedic surgeons do not rely solely on X-rays to treat patients with fractures.
Based on your description, you may have a tibial fracture while the fibula remains intact, which is why a cast was applied.
Clinically, since you are able to walk after the cast was removed, it indicates that the fracture has healed to a certain extent.
Follow-up X-rays may still show clear signs of the fracture, but in reality, there is already sufficient new bone formation around the fracture site for support, so there is no need to worry.
As for work, if it is not heavy labor, given your situation, you should be able to return to work.
Wishing you all the best!
Reply Date: 2006/05/07
More Info
Hello! Thank you for reaching out with your concerns regarding your tibial fracture and the healing process. It’s understandable to have questions about your recovery, especially after experiencing a significant injury like a fracture.
Firstly, it’s not uncommon for X-rays to still show visible fracture lines even after several months of healing. Bone healing is a complex process that can vary significantly from person to person. In general, bone fractures go through several stages of healing: the inflammatory phase, the reparative phase, and the remodeling phase. During the reparative phase, a soft callus forms around the fracture site, which eventually hardens into a bony callus. This process can take several weeks to months, and even after the bone has healed sufficiently to allow for weight-bearing activities, the original fracture line may still be visible on X-rays for some time.
The presence of a visible fracture line does not necessarily indicate that the bone has not healed. It is essential to consider other factors, such as the alignment of the bone, the stability of the fracture site, and whether there is any pain or functional limitation. If you are able to walk and perform daily activities without significant pain or instability, it is a positive sign that your bone is healing properly.
Regarding the pain you are experiencing in your ankle and the fracture site, it is not unusual to have some discomfort during the healing process, especially after being immobilized for an extended period. The pain could be due to several factors, including:
1. Residual Inflammation: After a fracture, the surrounding tissues may still be inflamed, which can cause discomfort.
2. Muscle Weakness: Prolonged immobilization can lead to muscle atrophy and weakness, which may contribute to pain when you start to use your leg more.
3. Joint Stiffness: After being in a cast, your joints may be stiff, leading to discomfort when you begin to move them again.
4. Nerve Sensitivity: Sometimes, nerves can become sensitive after an injury, leading to pain that may not necessarily be related to the bone itself.
As for returning to work, it largely depends on the nature of your job and the level of physical activity it requires. If your job involves significant physical exertion or standing for long periods, it may be wise to consult with your healthcare provider before returning. They may recommend a gradual return to activities, possibly incorporating physical therapy to help strengthen the muscles around the ankle and improve flexibility.
In summary, while it is not unusual to see persistent fracture lines on X-rays after six months, the key indicators of healing are your ability to bear weight, the absence of significant pain, and functional mobility. If you continue to experience pain or have concerns about your recovery, I recommend discussing this with your healthcare provider. They may suggest further imaging or a tailored rehabilitation program to ensure a full recovery.
Take care, and I hope you continue to progress well in your healing journey!
Similar Q&A
Understanding Bone Graft Healing: Why Do Bone Lines Remain Visible?
Why can the bone line still be seen after autologous bone grafting? How is the growth capability of the autologous bone graft? After 6 months post-injury, the bone line has healed, but why is there still pain, especially when squatting and applying pressure?
Dr. Chen Yongxue reply Orthopedics
Hello, your letter did not specify which bone was fractured. The healing capacity of certain bones may be slower due to the distribution of blood vessels. Additionally, the assessment of bone healing is not solely determined by the disappearance of the fracture line. The success ...[Read More] Understanding Bone Graft Healing: Why Do Bone Lines Remain Visible?
Understanding Bone Callus Formation After Tibial Fracture Recovery
Dr. Chen: Hello, it has been three and a half months since my tibial fracture. On November 15th, I went to Kaohsiung Medical University for a follow-up examination to see if there is any callus formation. The X-ray showed some areas along the fracture line (since I have a complet...
Dr. Chen Xingyuan reply Orthopedics
Dear Readers, The healing of fractures takes time. Initially, when bone growth begins, a hazy white appearance can be seen at the fracture site on X-rays. As time progresses, this hazy white area will become increasingly opaque, and eventually, the fracture line will disappear, ...[Read More] Understanding Bone Callus Formation After Tibial Fracture Recovery
Accelerating Bone Healing: Tips for Fifth Metatarsal Fracture Recovery
Hello, doctor. I sustained a fracture at the base of my fifth metatarsal while playing basketball at the end of November. During my recent follow-up appointment, an X-ray showed a white, hazy bone callus between the fracture lines, but it has not completely filled the gap, and th...
Dr. Wang Shouji reply Orthopedics
Hello, if there are no symptoms, regular X-ray follow-ups are sufficient, and most bone fracture symptoms will disappear within six months. Changhua Hospital cares about your health. Wang Shou-ji.[Read More] Accelerating Bone Healing: Tips for Fifth Metatarsal Fracture Recovery
Understanding Delayed Healing in Humerus Fractures: Causes and Solutions
It has been six months since my fracture, and I have not undergone surgery. During my last X-ray, it was observed that the center of the bone is still vacant and has not yet formed new bone, although the outer part has healed. The doctor advised me to consume more calcium-rich fo...
Dr. Li Yongheng reply Orthopedics
Hello, you are 22 years old, and it has been six months since your humeral fracture. X-rays show that the outer part has healed. Typically, fracture healing begins from the periphery, and it usually takes about a year for a fracture to fully heal. Therefore, it is normal for the ...[Read More] Understanding Delayed Healing in Humerus Fractures: Causes and Solutions
Related FAQ
(Orthopedics)
Fracture(Orthopedics)
Post-Fracture Rehabilitation(Orthopedics)
Post-Femoral Fracture Surgery(Orthopedics)
Closed Fracture(Orthopedics)
Osteomyelitis(Orthopedics)
Skeleton(Orthopedics)
Tibia And Fibula Fracture(Orthopedics)
Coccygeal Fracture(Orthopedics)
Toe Fractures(Orthopedics)