the Pros and Cons of ETC Treatment for Severe Depression

Pros and Cons of ETC Therapy

1.
What are the symptoms of major depressive disorder?
2.
What is the difference between major depressive disorder and dementia?
3.
After 1.5 to 2 months of medication for major depressive disorder, there has been some improvement, but the condition remains unstable.
The physician has recommended ETC (electroconvulsive therapy).
Is this necessary? What should be taken into consideration?

Xiao Min, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2006/06/21

Dr. Shao Jinghan reply Psychiatry

Dear Ms.
Hsiao-Min,
Regarding your inquiry, I will respond in order and hope you find the information satisfactory.
1.
What are the symptoms of major depressive disorder? Major depressive disorder is classified in the DSM-IV as a single episode or recurrent depressive disorder.
Symptoms of major depressive disorder include: for at least two weeks, there must be at least one of the following:
1.
Depressed mood: feeling tearful or wanting to cry, occurring nearly every day.
2.
Anhedonia: loss of interest or pleasure in activities that were previously enjoyable.
One of these two symptoms must be present, along with at least four of the following symptoms:
3.
Psychomotor retardation or agitation.
4.
Significant loss of libido or appetite.
5.
Weight loss.
6.
Loss of energy or fatigue: occurring nearly every day.
7.
Insomnia or hypersomnia: occurring nearly every day.
8.
Diminished ability to think or concentrate, indecisiveness.
9.
Feelings of worthlessness, excessive guilt, or diminished self-esteem.
10.
Suicidal thoughts or behaviors.
In severe cases, psychotic symptoms may occur, such as delusions (e.g., feelings of guilt, poverty, or impending disaster) and hallucinations (e.g., hearing derogatory or accusatory voices).
2.
What is the difference between major depressive disorder and dementia? Approximately 10% of elderly patients with depression may exhibit cognitive impairment that can be mistaken for dementia, referred to as "pseudodementia." Typically, elderly patients with depression have a clearer onset and course of the illness, often actively complaining about cognitive difficulties.
Emotional changes are less prominent, and nighttime symptoms do not worsen as much.
They may be uncooperative with cognitive testing, often responding "I don't know," and forgetting both recent and distant events, but memory impairment is specific to certain periods, with attention still preserved.
In contrast, dementia patients exhibit the opposite pattern: they have poorer short-term memory, may struggle to answer questions despite effort, and demonstrate poor attention.
3.
After 1.5 to 2 months of medication for major depressive disorder, there may be some improvement, but the condition remains unstable.
The physician has suggested considering ECT treatment; is this necessary, and what should be noted? Generally, ECT remains one of the most effective treatments for severe depression.
If, as you mentioned, factors such as missed doses have been ruled out and the condition remains unstable, ECT may be considered necessary.
Contraindications for ECT include medical conditions that may affect anesthesia, such as respiratory infections or severe heart disease, and any intracranial conditions that may increase intracranial pressure.
Patients taking reserpine should not undergo ECT, and those on lithium must temporarily discontinue the medication before ECT.
Similarly, patients on MAOIs should also stop their medication prior to ECT.
Your inquiry is quite professional, and I hope this brief response meets your needs.

Reply Date: 2006/06/21

More Info

Electroconvulsive Therapy (ECT) is a treatment option for severe depression, particularly when other treatments, such as medication and psychotherapy, have not provided sufficient relief. Understanding the symptoms of severe depression, differentiating it from dementia, and evaluating the necessity and considerations for ECT can help patients and their families make informed decisions.

1. Symptoms of Severe Depression
Severe depression, classified as Major Depressive Disorder (MDD), manifests through a range of symptoms that significantly impair daily functioning. According to the DSM-5, the diagnosis requires the presence of at least five of the following symptoms for a minimum of two weeks:
- Depressed Mood: Persistent feelings of sadness, emptiness, or hopelessness.

- Loss of Interest or Pleasure: Marked disinterest in activities once enjoyed.

- Significant Weight Change: Either weight loss or gain, or changes in appetite.

- Sleep Disturbances: Insomnia or hypersomnia nearly every day.

- Psychomotor Agitation or Retardation: Observable restlessness or being slowed down.

- Fatigue or Loss of Energy: Feeling tired or lacking energy almost every day.

- Feelings of Worthlessness or Excessive Guilt: Harsh self-criticism or guilt over past actions.

- Diminished Ability to Think or Concentrate: Difficulty making decisions or focusing.

- Recurrent Thoughts of Death or Suicide: This can include suicidal ideation or attempts.

2. Distinguishing Severe Depression from Dementia
While both severe depression and dementia can present with cognitive impairments, they are fundamentally different conditions. Severe depression can lead to what is termed "pseudodementia," where cognitive deficits are primarily due to the depressive state rather than a neurodegenerative process. Key differences include:
- Onset and Course: Depression often has a clear onset related to life events and can fluctuate, while dementia typically has a gradual and progressive decline.

- Cognitive Function: In depression, cognitive impairments often improve with treatment of the mood disorder, whereas dementia is characterized by a steady decline in cognitive abilities.

- Awareness of Condition: Individuals with severe depression may be more aware of their cognitive difficulties and express concern, while those with dementia may lack insight into their condition.

3. The Necessity of ECT After Medication Adjustment
When a patient has been on antidepressant medication for 1.5 to 2 months with only partial improvement and ongoing instability, ECT may be considered. ECT is particularly effective for severe depression, especially in cases where:
- Rapid Response is Needed: ECT can provide quicker relief from severe symptoms compared to traditional medications.

- Suicidal Ideation: If a patient is experiencing suicidal thoughts, ECT can be a life-saving intervention.

- Medication Resistance: If the patient has not responded adequately to multiple antidepressant trials, ECT may be warranted.

Considerations for ECT
While ECT can be highly effective, there are important considerations:
- Medical Evaluation: A thorough medical evaluation is necessary to rule out contraindications, such as certain cardiovascular conditions or increased intracranial pressure.

- Informed Consent: Patients should be informed about the procedure, including potential side effects such as temporary memory loss or confusion.

- Post-Treatment Care: Ongoing psychiatric support and medication management are crucial following ECT to maintain improvements and prevent relapse.

In conclusion, ECT can be a necessary and effective treatment for severe depression, especially when other treatments have failed. Understanding the symptoms of severe depression, differentiating it from dementia, and weighing the pros and cons of ECT can empower patients and their families to make informed decisions about their mental health care. It is essential to maintain open communication with healthcare providers throughout this process to ensure the best possible outcomes.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Electroconvulsive Therapy: Benefits and Risks for Depression

Hello, doctor. My daughter's attending physician mentioned that electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) might help reduce her intense suicidal thoughts and actions. I would like to inquire about the common advantages and disadvantages (side effects) of ECT. Additionally, can ECT tru...

Dr. Lin Junyuan reply Psychiatry
Hello, although it is not possible to directly assess the patient's mental condition, electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) is usually considered after trying multiple oral medications (ensuring they are taken regularly and in adequate doses) without satisfactory results. The ECT ...

Overcoming Severe Depression: A Journey Towards Healing and Hope

I have been suffering from severe depression for three months. I regularly take antidepressants and antipsychotic medications. When I feel overwhelmed by work stress and exhaustion, I often think that I am useless and do not deserve to live in this world. I isolate myself and cry...

Dr. Liang Sunyuan reply Psychiatry
Hello Alice: Being in the midst of depression is very challenging, but with treatment, most people do recover. You have been undergoing treatment for three months and have noticed some positive effects, but negative and pessimistic thoughts still arise. This is a common phenomeno...

Understanding Chronic Depression: Treatment Options and Recovery Insights

Symptoms: I am 38 years old and was diagnosed with severe depression 18 years ago. It took 5 years to treat (though it was not completely resolved). I experienced relapses 8 years ago and 4 years ago. I am currently taking Western medication (Topiramate), which is effective but c...

Dr. Dai Wanxiang reply Psychiatry
Hello, in cases of severe depression during the first episode, if the dosage and duration of medication are adequate, there is a 60-70% chance of recovery within a few months. However, the course of the illness may recur in the future or become chronic, leading to persistent depr...

Can Depression, Anxiety, and OCD Be Fully Treated? A Patient's Journey

Hello Doctor: I am a patient with severe depression, and my anxiety test results were also close to severe. When I feel agitated, I tend to pick at my scalp, which has been a habit for several years. The doctor advised me not to pick, but I do it every day, sometimes causing blee...

Dr. Zhang Gengjia reply Psychiatry
Dear Sir/Madam, From your letter, it is evident that you are experiencing discomfort and distress due to the pressures of severe depression and obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD). 1. Facing an uncertain future, severe depression and anxiety disorders are common conditions in ...