Do Scar Removal Gels Really Work? Insights on Kanga Scar Gel

About scar removal gel?

Hello Dr.
Lu: I currently have a question regarding a product called Kanga Scar Gel, developed by Max Pharmaceuticals in Germany.
I have read a lot of information, and some people believe it is ineffective, while others think it is beneficial.
Additionally, there are physicians selling this product.
If it is indeed ineffective, does that mean Max Pharmaceuticals is misleading consumers? Isn't it a reputable pharmaceutical company? The product is not inexpensive either.
Please help me clarify this doubt.
Thank you.

yang, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2006/08/11

Dr. Lu Daokuan reply Plastic Surgery

Scar gels generally only help to fade scars and cannot completely eliminate them.
If your goal is merely to lighten the scars, then isn't that considered effective?

Reply Date: 2006/08/11

More Info

When it comes to scar removal gels, including products like Kanga Scar Gel developed by a reputable pharmaceutical company, the effectiveness can vary widely among individuals. Scar treatment products often contain ingredients that are intended to improve the appearance of scars, such as silicone, which has been shown in some studies to help flatten and soften scars. However, the results can be inconsistent, and not every product works for every person.

Kanga Scar Gel, like many other topical treatments, is designed to be applied directly to the scarred area. The active ingredients in such gels may include silicone, which is known for its ability to hydrate the scar tissue and create a protective barrier that can help in the healing process. Silicone gels have been widely studied and are often recommended by dermatologists for the management of hypertrophic scars and keloids. They work by providing a moist environment that can help to reduce scar formation and improve the overall appearance of the skin.

However, it is essential to understand that while some users report positive results, others may not see any significant improvement. This variability can be attributed to several factors, including the age of the scar, its type (e.g., surgical, traumatic, acne), the individual's skin type, and adherence to the application regimen. For instance, newer scars may respond better to treatment than older scars, which can be more challenging to treat.

Regarding the question of whether the manufacturer is misleading consumers, it is crucial to approach this with a balanced perspective. Large pharmaceutical companies typically conduct research and clinical trials to support their products, but marketing claims can sometimes exaggerate the efficacy of a product. It is not uncommon for products to receive mixed reviews from users, as personal experiences can differ significantly based on individual circumstances.

If you are considering using Kanga Scar Gel or any other scar treatment, it is advisable to consult with a dermatologist or healthcare professional. They can provide personalized recommendations based on your specific scar type and skin condition. Additionally, they may suggest complementary treatments, such as laser therapy, microdermabrasion, or chemical peels, which can enhance the results of topical treatments.

In summary, while Kanga Scar Gel may work for some individuals, its effectiveness is not guaranteed for everyone. The mixed reviews reflect the variability in individual responses to scar treatments. Consulting with a healthcare professional can help you make an informed decision and explore the best options for your scar management.

Similar Q&A

Best Scar Treatment Options for Uneven Skin Tone After Surgery

I previously fell down the stairs and sustained a skull fracture, resulting in a long scar from my forehead to the back of my head. After being discharged, I applied Mederma gel, which helped prevent the scar from becoming raised, but the scar is still lighter in color compared t...

Dr. Lu Daokuan reply Plastic Surgery
Silicone gel, such as ScarAway, provides a thin layer that can slightly reduce pressure on the wound, while Mederma contains various nutrients that help moisturize and nourish the scar during the healing process. Both have some effectiveness, but neither can achieve a completely ...

Debunking Scar Removal Products: Do They Really Work?

Recently, I saw a new scar removal product on a cable channel called "Super Time-Space Scar-Free," which introduced its miraculous effects. The news also reported on it, mentioning in the advertisement that it is effective even for skin burns from exhaust pipes. I am ve...

Dr. Liao Wenyu reply Dermatology
Hello: Essentially, there should be no such thing as a "miraculous scar removal medication." If that were the case, why would there be patients seeking cosmetic surgery for burn injuries? Liao Wenyu

Is Beauty Tape Effective for Scar Management After Surgery?

I just had a sebaceous cyst surgery on my cheek last week, and while searching for information about cosmetic tape online, I came across this article. I would like to ask the doctor about the accuracy of this information and whether silicone gel is recommended instead. Thank you....

Dr. Wu Yuxin reply Dermatology
Each physician has different practices, and there is no truly absolute correct method. For example, I typically apply cosmetic adhesive for two weeks after suture removal, and then switch to silicone gel, continuing for at least six months.

Can Scar Creams Be Used on Cancer Surgery Wounds?

Hello, my wound has been healing for over a year (the wound from breast cancer). I used silicone gel sheets for about six months, but after that, the scar became red and thick, and sometimes it itches. I want to apply scar ointment but I'm worried about potential side effect...

Dr. Xu Wenming reply Pharmacology
Hello: Regarding the situation where a wound scar becomes red and thick, it is similar to a keloid after surgery. It is recommended to continue using silicone gel sheets or applying scar ointment, such as the scar gel you mentioned, or to return to the clinic to consult with a su...