Symptoms: Is It Pneumothorax or Costochondritis? - Pulmonology

Share to:

What are the symptoms of pneumothorax?


Last night, I felt pain near my left chest close to my arm while sleeping, and I also felt a bit of tightness in my breathing.
However, after getting up, the pain subsided, but I still felt a bit of tightness.
In the afternoon, when I lay flat, the pain returned.
I applied an anti-inflammatory pain relief cream (since I am thin and have little muscle, I have experienced this pain before and a doctor diagnosed it as costochondritis, so I was prescribed the cream), but it didn’t help.
When I take deep breaths while standing, it also hurts, but it doesn’t hurt with normal breathing.
Is this a pneumothorax or just costochondritis? Does pneumothorax cause constant pain? Is costochondritis characterized by pain when pressure is applied?

Xiao Wang, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2006/09/02

Dr. Qu Changke reply Pulmonology


Hello, Xiao Wang: There are many causes of chest discomfort, not just pneumothorax, muscle pain, or pleuritic pain.
Furthermore, regarding pneumothorax, the symptoms can vary from person to person.
Therefore, it is advisable to visit an outpatient clinic.
Please see a specialist.

Reply Date: 2006/09/02

More Info


When considering the symptoms you've described, it's essential to differentiate between pneumothorax and costochondritis, as both can present with chest pain but have different underlying causes and implications.

Pneumothorax occurs when air leaks into the space between the lung and the chest wall, leading to a collapse of the lung. Symptoms typically include sudden sharp chest pain and shortness of breath. The pain may worsen with deep breaths, coughing, or movement. In cases of a tension pneumothorax, the symptoms can escalate quickly and may include severe respiratory distress and a rapid heart rate. However, if the pneumothorax is small, symptoms might be mild and could resolve on their own. It's important to note that pneumothorax pain is often persistent and can be exacerbated by certain movements or positions.

On the other hand, costochondritis is an inflammation of the cartilage that connects a rib to the sternum. This condition often presents as localized pain that can be sharp or aching and is typically reproducible with palpation of the affected area. The pain may worsen with certain movements, deep breaths, or coughing, but it usually does not cause significant shortness of breath. Costochondritis can be a result of physical strain, repetitive trauma, or even viral infections.
In your case, the pain being localized to the left side near the arm, the sensation of tightness during breathing, and the fact that it worsens when lying down could suggest costochondritis, especially given your history of muscle strain and the fact that you have previously been diagnosed with muscle-related pain. The pain associated with costochondritis is often positional and can be aggravated by certain movements, which aligns with your experience of pain when taking deep breaths or lying down.

To further clarify:
- Pneumothorax: Pain is often sharp and sudden, accompanied by difficulty breathing. It can be persistent and may require medical intervention, especially if it worsens.

- Costochondritis: Pain is typically localized, can be reproduced by pressing on the affected area, and may vary with movement or position. It usually responds well to anti-inflammatory medications.

Given your symptoms and the ineffectiveness of the topical anti-inflammatory medication, it would be prudent to seek medical evaluation. A healthcare provider may recommend imaging studies, such as a chest X-ray, to rule out pneumothorax, especially if your symptoms persist or worsen.
In summary, while both conditions can cause chest pain, the characteristics of your pain and associated symptoms lean more towards costochondritis. However, due to the potential seriousness of pneumothorax, it is crucial to consult a healthcare professional for an accurate diagnosis and appropriate management.

Similar Q&A

Could My Symptoms Indicate a Pneumothorax?

Hello Doctor: I would like to ask about my condition. I previously visited Pingtung Hospital because I was experiencing shortness of breath and pain in my chest and abdomen (the area around my ribs also hurts). I feel very fatigued, and breathing is exhausting. It also feels like...


Dr. Jiang Rongren reply Pulmonology
Pneumothorax typically presents with chest pain in addition to shortness of breath, and it commonly occurs in tall, thin individuals. If there is suspicion of this condition, it is advisable to seek medical attention. Diagnosis can be confirmed through auscultation and chest X-ra...

[Read More] Could My Symptoms Indicate a Pneumothorax?


Understanding Pneumothorax: Symptoms, Causes, and Diagnosis

Hello, doctor: Since I was in junior high school, I have occasionally experienced difficulty breathing, which I initially thought was due to nasal congestion. However, during high school, it seemed to worsen, and I have been experiencing intermittent pain in my left or right ches...


Dr. Jian Shuntian reply Pulmonology
This condition is not a pneumothorax, which refers to the presence of air in the pleural cavity, causing chest pain and shortness of breath or difficulty breathing. The symptoms you described are rather nonspecific. It would be advisable to visit a hospital with a thoracic depart...

[Read More] Understanding Pneumothorax: Symptoms, Causes, and Diagnosis


Understanding Chest Pain: When to Seek Medical Attention

Hello Doctor: The night before last, I had a slight cough due to an itchy throat, and then I started to feel a tight pain in my left chest. The pain persisted throughout the next day, but it seemed to be more pronounced with certain positions. This morning when I woke up, the pai...


Dr. Zhou Ziguang reply Pulmonology
Hello: If there are no symptoms, no asthma, the likelihood of a pneumothorax is quite low. However, to rule out the possibility of a pneumothorax, a chest X-ray is still necessary.

[Read More] Understanding Chest Pain: When to Seek Medical Attention


Understanding Chest Discomfort: Is It Pneumothorax?

Hello, doctor. Recently, I've been experiencing a feeling of tightness and mild pain in my right chest, especially when swallowing, which then shifts to the center of my chest. Could this be a pneumothorax?


Dr. Yang Wenda reply Pulmonology
Hello: The diagnosis of pneumothorax primarily relies on X-rays. Typically, a more severe case may present with a sensation of shortness of breath, and the location of discomfort does not change. This is for your reference!

[Read More] Understanding Chest Discomfort: Is It Pneumothorax?


Related FAQ

Pneumothorax

(Pulmonology)

Chest Discomfort

(Pulmonology)

Rib Pain

(Pulmonology)

Difficulty Breathing

(Pulmonology)

Chest Tightness

(Pulmonology)

Sharp Chest Pain

(Pulmonology)

Respiratory Disease

(Pulmonology)

Computed Tomography

(Pulmonology)

Pulmonary Obstruction

(Pulmonology)

Wheezing, Coughing

(Pulmonology)