Painless Bronchoscopy for Lung Tumor Biopsy: Costs and Accuracy - Pulmonology

Share to:

Lung tumor


Doctor: I would like to know about painless bronchoscopy for biopsy.
Is it performed in the same way as a regular bronchoscopy, entering through the nose for the biopsy? Is the cost considered out-of-pocket? There is a 7 cm tumor that has not been biopsied yet.
The doctor has determined it to be malignant.
How accurate is this assessment? If I go to another hospital for a CT scan, is there any harm to the body?

Weiwei, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2006/12/19

Dr. Zhuang Ziyi reply Pulmonology


Hello: 1.
A painless bronchoscopy refers to the use of short-acting anesthetics to alleviate the discomfort experienced by patients during the bronchoscopy procedure, and there is no absolute relationship between whether the bronchoscope is inserted through the nasal cavity or the oral cavity.
The anesthesia portion must be paid out-of-pocket, as health insurance does not cover it; insurance only covers the cost of the bronchoscopy examination.
2.
Tumors larger than 3 centimeters in the lungs have a 90% likelihood of being malignant.
It is reasonable to infer malignancy based on tumor size, but a biopsy is still necessary for a definitive diagnosis, as the treatment approaches differ between benign and malignant tumors.
Even malignant tumors may require different treatment strategies depending on the type of cancer cells involved.
3.
Getting a CT scan at another hospital poses no harm to the body; it merely wastes more time and delays diagnosis and treatment.
4.
Reference: Murray and Nader’s Textbook of Respiratory Medicine, 4th ed.
Respiratory Medicine, 3rd ed.
Sincerely, Dr.
Zhuang Zi Yi, Internal Medicine.

Reply Date: 2006/12/19

More Info


Painless bronchoscopy, also known as sedation bronchoscopy, is a procedure used to examine the airways and lungs, often for the purpose of obtaining biopsies from lung tumors. This technique is particularly beneficial for patients who may experience anxiety or discomfort during traditional bronchoscopy, as it utilizes short-acting anesthetics to minimize pain and discomfort.

Procedure Overview
In terms of the procedure itself, painless bronchoscopy can be performed through either the nasal or oral route, similar to traditional bronchoscopy. The choice of entry point often depends on the specific circumstances of the patient and the location of the tumor. The use of sedation allows for a more comfortable experience, but it is important to note that the sedation aspect typically incurs additional costs, as it is often not covered by insurance. The basic bronchoscopy procedure may be covered, but the sedation may be considered an out-of-pocket expense.


Costs
The costs associated with painless bronchoscopy can vary significantly based on the healthcare facility, the region, and whether the procedure is performed in an outpatient or inpatient setting. Patients should inquire about the specific costs with their healthcare provider or insurance company. Generally, the cost of the bronchoscopy itself may range from a few hundred to several thousand dollars, depending on the complexity of the case and the need for additional imaging or interventions.


Accuracy
Regarding the accuracy of the biopsy, bronchoscopy is a highly effective method for diagnosing lung tumors. For tumors larger than 3 cm, there is a high likelihood (around 90%) that they are malignant. However, while the procedure is generally accurate, the definitive diagnosis relies on the histopathological examination of the biopsy samples. It is crucial to obtain a sufficient tissue sample to determine the nature of the tumor accurately, as treatment options differ significantly between benign and malignant tumors.


Follow-Up Imaging
If a patient has already undergone a CT scan and is considering further imaging, such as a repeat CT scan or X-ray, it is essential to understand that these imaging modalities involve exposure to radiation. However, the risk associated with a single follow-up scan is generally low, especially when weighed against the potential benefits of early diagnosis and treatment. The decision to pursue additional imaging should be made in consultation with a healthcare provider, considering the patient's overall health status and the urgency of diagnosis.


Conclusion
In summary, painless bronchoscopy is a valuable tool for diagnosing lung tumors, providing a more comfortable experience for patients while maintaining high accuracy. While the costs may be higher due to sedation, the benefits of obtaining a definitive diagnosis can outweigh these concerns. Patients should engage in open discussions with their healthcare providers about the necessity of additional imaging and the associated risks, ensuring that they are well-informed about their options moving forward.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Lung Cancer Diagnosis and the Need for Biopsy Confirmation

Hello Dr. Yang: I have undergone X-ray and CT scans, which confirmed that I have a malignant tumor approximately six centimeters in size in my left lung, and it has already metastasized to all lung lobes. However, the attending physician stated that the diagnosis report can only ...


Dr. Yang Wenda reply Pulmonology
Hello Mellow: The bronchoscopy examination can indeed be quite uncomfortable (unless one opts for a painless endoscopy at their own expense, which may not be available at every hospital). Additionally, I am unsure about the distance of the tumor from the chest wall. If it is clos...

[Read More] Understanding Lung Cancer Diagnosis and the Need for Biopsy Confirmation


Exploring Lung Tumor Diagnosis: Beyond Bronchoscopy for 7cm Growth

Doctor: My father was recently diagnosed with a 7 cm lung tumor. He has decided not to go to the hospital for further examinations after hearing the news. His blood tests came back normal, and he rarely coughs. Overall, he seems to be doing well. I would like to ask if a lung bio...


Dr. Qu Changke reply Pulmonology
Hello Weiwei: The methods for obtaining tissue samples for pathological examination of lung tumors primarily include bronchoscopic biopsy, ultrasound-guided percutaneous biopsy, and CT-guided percutaneous biopsy. However, bronchoscopic examination is essential for staging.

[Read More] Exploring Lung Tumor Diagnosis: Beyond Bronchoscopy for 7cm Growth


Understanding Lung Biopsy: Pain, Risks, and What to Expect

Hello Doctor: My mother is 62 years old and has been undergoing regular chest X-ray examinations every year because my grandmother had tuberculosis and my uncle passed away from lung cancer. Two months ago, she started coughing and experiencing chest pain. She went to the health ...


Dr. Zhou Ziguang reply Pulmonology
Based on the described situation, it appears to be an unexplained lesion in the left lung, thus further examination is necessary. Bronchoscopy should not be performed under excessive anesthesia; it can also include a biopsy, but there is a possibility that the targeted area may n...

[Read More] Understanding Lung Biopsy: Pain, Risks, and What to Expect


Waiting Times for Bronchial Cancer Biopsy in Northern Taiwan Hospitals

Hello doctor, my grandfather underwent a positron emission tomography (PET) scan abroad, and the report suggests a suspicion of bronchial cancer. A biopsy is needed for further testing, but the wait time for the biopsy abroad is over a month and a half. I would like to know how l...


Dr. Huang Yiwen reply Pulmonology
Dear Ms. Feng: The scheduling for examinations in Taiwan varies by hospital, but they can all be completed within a week. Changhua Hospital is concerned about you.

[Read More] Waiting Times for Bronchial Cancer Biopsy in Northern Taiwan Hospitals


Related FAQ

Lung Cancer

(Pulmonology)

Lung Nodule

(Pulmonology)

Bronchi

(Pulmonology)

Postoperative Lung Adenocarcinoma

(Pulmonology)

Computed Tomography

(Pulmonology)

Ground-Glass Nodule

(Pulmonology)

Ct Report

(Pulmonology)

Sharp Chest Pain

(Pulmonology)

Pneumothorax

(Pulmonology)

Pulmonary Fibrosis

(Pulmonology)