Is Withdrawal Method Effective for Birth Control? Risks Explained

Is the withdrawal method effective?

Can the withdrawal method effectively prevent pregnancy? If ejaculation occurs and then intercourse continues shortly after without using a condom, but only with a tissue for cleanup, is there still a possibility of pregnancy?

a a, 10~19 year old female. Ask Date: 2007/02/13

Dr. Zhong Wenzhen reply Obstetrics and Gynecology

The withdrawal method, also known as coitus interruptus or external ejaculation, is not a reliable form of contraception due to a higher likelihood of conception.
Additionally, after ejaculation, there may still be residual sperm in the male urethra; simply wiping away the semen from the urethral opening and continuing intercourse can still result in pregnancy.
It is recommended to use oral contraceptives as a regular method of contraception for young individuals.
Wishing you safety.

Reply Date: 2007/02/13

More Info

The withdrawal method, also known as coitus interruptus, is a form of birth control where the male partner withdraws his penis from the vagina before ejaculation to prevent sperm from entering the reproductive tract. While it is a method that has been used for centuries, its effectiveness is often debated and can vary significantly based on several factors.

Effectiveness of the Withdrawal Method
The effectiveness of the withdrawal method is generally considered to be lower than that of other contraceptive methods. According to various studies, when practiced perfectly, the withdrawal method can have a failure rate of about 4%. However, with typical use, the failure rate can rise to approximately 22%. This means that out of 100 women using this method for one year, about 22 may become pregnant.

The primary reason for this relatively high failure rate is that it requires a great deal of self-control and timing from the male partner. Pre-ejaculatory fluid (pre-cum) can contain sperm, which means that even if withdrawal occurs before ejaculation, there is still a risk of pregnancy. Additionally, if the timing is not executed perfectly, sperm may be deposited in the vagina, leading to potential fertilization.

Risks Associated with the Withdrawal Method
1. Unintended Pregnancy: As mentioned, the primary risk is unintended pregnancy. This can lead to emotional and financial stress, as well as potential health implications for both partners.

2. No Protection Against STIs: The withdrawal method does not provide any protection against sexually transmitted infections (STIs). For couples who are not in a monogamous relationship or are unsure of their partner's sexual health, this method can pose significant health risks.

3. Reliance on Male Partner: The effectiveness of this method heavily relies on the male partner's ability to withdraw in time. This can lead to anxiety and pressure during intercourse, which may affect sexual enjoyment and intimacy.

4. Potential for Miscommunication: Couples may have different understandings of what constitutes "successful" withdrawal, leading to potential conflicts or misunderstandings about contraceptive practices.

Concerns About Continuing Intercourse After Ejaculation
Regarding your specific question about continuing intercourse shortly after ejaculation without using a condom, there is indeed a risk of pregnancy. If the male partner ejaculates and then continues to engage in sexual activity without a barrier method, there is a possibility that sperm may still be present in the urethra or that pre-ejaculatory fluid may be released during subsequent arousal. This can lead to sperm entering the vagina and increasing the likelihood of pregnancy.

Conclusion
In summary, while the withdrawal method can be a viable option for some couples, it is not the most reliable form of birth control. Couples should consider their comfort levels, the importance of preventing pregnancy, and the potential risks involved. For those seeking more effective and reliable methods of contraception, options such as hormonal birth control, intrauterine devices (IUDs), or condoms may be more suitable. It is always advisable to consult with a healthcare provider to discuss the best contraceptive options based on individual circumstances and health needs.

Similar Q&A

Is Withholding Ejaculation Harmful? Exploring Safe Contraceptive Methods

Hello Dr. Lai, I would like to ask you about contraception. My girlfriend and I do not plan to have children, and she is currently taking birth control pills for contraception. However, we still worry about the possibility of pregnancy, so I often practice withdrawal before ejacu...

Dr. Lai Ronghao reply Urology
Hello: It is recommended that if you are taking oral contraceptives, you should take them on time; otherwise, there is still a possibility of pregnancy. Additionally, you can use condoms for contraception or consider an intrauterine device (IUD). However, there is still a chance ...

Understanding Contraception: Is Condom Use Enough to Prevent Pregnancy?

Hello, doctor: I recently started having sexual intercourse and have been very concerned about contraception. I would like to ask, under general circumstances, if a male uses a condom throughout the entire duration of intercourse (putting it on before any genital contact and keep...

Dr. Yang Wangjun reply Obstetrics and Gynecology
Hello: No contraceptive method is 100% effective. Typically, the success rate of condoms is around 92-95%; the success rate of intrauterine devices (IUDs) is about 97%; and if taken consistently, the success rate of birth control pills exceeds 99.7%. On the other hand, the succes...

Pregnancy Risk with Withdrawal Method During Menstrual Cycle

Your girlfriend's menstrual period started on January 20 and intercourse occurred on January 24 with withdrawal (pull-out method). Her period ended on January 26. Since her menstrual cycle can vary by 1 to 2 days but typically lasts 5 to 7 days, the likelihood of pregnancy i...

Dr. Zhang Kunmin reply Obstetrics and Gynecology
Hello, based on your description, if your menstrual cycle is from day 1 to day 20, the chances of pregnancy are low. It is advisable to take appropriate contraceptive measures to avoid any concerns. Thank you! Wishing you peace and health, Dr. Chang.

Can You Get Pregnant with Double Condoms and Withdrawal Method?

Doctor, I’m sorry to ask: if I had intercourse with my boyfriend on the last day of my period, and he wore two condoms and practiced withdrawal, is there still a chance of pregnancy? If we consistently use condoms and withdrawal every time, is there still a risk of pregnancy? Wil...

Dr. Cai Yonglong reply Obstetrics and Gynecology
1. This method is unlikely to result in pregnancy (extremely unlikely). 2. Taking birth control pills suppresses ovulation; it is recommended to use them for 5-6 months, then stop for 1-2 months to allow the ovaries to recover.