Choosing the Right Surgeon for Hip Replacement: Key Considerations

Artificial hip joint

Dear Dr.
Shi,
I am the patient who consulted you last year on August 1st.
I underwent surgery to have an artificial hip joint implanted due to avascular necrosis of my right hip joint in early June of last year.
Later, at the end of June, I discovered that my left foot was also beginning to deteriorate, so I started receiving shockwave therapy, hyperbaric oxygen therapy, and taking Fosamax for treatment.
Currently, the doctors have advised that I should also have an artificial joint implanted in my left hip to alleviate the pain.
I would like to ask if it is possible for me to have the surgery at the hospital where I am receiving shockwave therapy, since the doctors performing the surgeries and the shockwave treatments are different.
Will having different doctors perform the surgeries on both legs lead to a discrepancy in leg length? Could the differing expertise of the surgeons result in the artificial joints being implanted at different lengths, causing one leg to be shorter than the other? The reason I am considering not going back to the original surgeon is that they seem to lack concern for their patients and have a poor attitude, which is why I am looking to change doctors.

From a professional standpoint, I would appreciate your advice, as I am still quite young and do not want to create lifelong regrets.
Additionally, I would like to know what the best materials for artificial joints are currently, and which types are most suitable for younger patients.
(I have a ceramic artificial hip joint in my right leg.) Is this type of material available at all hospitals?
Thank you for your assistance!

angela, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2007/03/02

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics

There is generally no particular issue with consulting different physicians, as long as the doctors are meticulous in ensuring that the legs are as equal in length as possible.
The materials for artificial joints are available at various hospitals, but it is still important to confirm with the physician before the surgery.
Since you are still young, it is crucial to carefully select both the physician and the hospital.
In general, more experienced physicians tend to achieve better outcomes after surgery; this is a common principle.

Reply Date: 2007/03/02

More Info

Choosing the right surgeon for hip replacement surgery is a critical decision that can significantly impact your recovery and overall quality of life. Here are some key considerations to keep in mind when selecting a surgeon for your hip replacement:
1. Experience and Specialization: Look for a surgeon who specializes in hip replacement surgeries and has extensive experience in performing them. Surgeons who perform a high volume of these procedures tend to have better outcomes. You can ask about their specific experience with the type of hip replacement you need, especially if you have unique circumstances such as avascular necrosis, which you mentioned.

2. Hospital Affiliation: The quality of the hospital where the surgery will be performed is also important. Research the hospital's reputation, infection rates, and overall patient satisfaction. A well-regarded hospital often has better resources and support for surgical patients.

3. Techniques and Technologies: Inquire about the surgical techniques the surgeon uses. Some surgeons may employ minimally invasive techniques, which can lead to quicker recovery times and less postoperative pain. Additionally, ask about the types of implants they use. For younger patients, durable materials like ceramic or highly cross-linked polyethylene are often recommended due to their longevity.

4. Communication and Comfort: It’s essential to feel comfortable with your surgeon. They should be willing to answer all your questions, explain the procedure in detail, and discuss potential risks and benefits. If you feel that your current surgeon is not attentive to your needs, it is perfectly reasonable to seek a second opinion or switch surgeons.

5. Postoperative Care and Follow-Up: Understand the surgeon's approach to postoperative care. Regular follow-up appointments are crucial for monitoring the success of the implant and addressing any complications early. Ask how they handle follow-up care and what their protocol is for managing any issues that may arise.

6. Patient Reviews and Testimonials: Look for reviews from other patients who have undergone hip replacement surgery with the surgeon you are considering. This can provide insight into their surgical outcomes and patient care.

7. Insurance and Costs: Ensure that the surgeon and the hospital are covered by your insurance plan. Discuss any out-of-pocket costs you may incur, especially if you are considering different types of implants that may not be fully covered.

Regarding your concern about having different surgeons for each hip, it is possible to have different surgeons perform the surgeries, but it is crucial to ensure that both surgeons communicate effectively about your case. This communication can help prevent discrepancies in leg length and ensure that both surgeries are performed with the same standards of care.

As for the materials used in hip replacements, ceramic implants are often favored for younger patients due to their durability and lower wear rates. However, not all hospitals may have access to the same types of implants, so it’s worth discussing with your chosen surgeon what options are available and what they recommend based on your specific situation.

In conclusion, choosing the right surgeon involves careful consideration of their experience, the hospital's reputation, the materials used, and your comfort level with the surgeon. Don't hesitate to seek a second opinion if you feel it is necessary, as this is a significant decision that will affect your mobility and quality of life for years to come.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Hip Replacement Surgery: Options and Insights for Patients

Doctor, I was on the basketball team in middle school, and perhaps I injured my hip joint while playing over a decade ago but didn't pay much attention to it. Recently, I've been experiencing frequent lower back pain and numbness in my thigh in the afternoons. I went to...

Dr. Hong Ximing reply Orthopedics
Hello: After the cartilage in the knee joint is worn down, it cannot regenerate. If a physician has diagnosed this condition, a total knee arthroplasty should be indicated, as it meets the criteria for replacement. This surgery is well-established in the country.

Choosing the Right Orthopedic Surgeon for Your Surgery Consultation

Hello, Doctor Shi. I apologize for continuously asking you questions! If I really want to consult for orthopedic surgery, can I see any orthopedic surgeon, or do I need to check if the doctor has specific expertise in a certain area? Thank you for your response!

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
You can either consult the original surgeon who performed your operation or seek out an orthopedic specialist who specializes in the foot and ankle.

Understanding Hip Pain: Is Revision Surgery the Right Solution?

Hello, doctor. I had a wide joint replacement surgery in 1999, but for the past few years, I have been experiencing daily pain and difficulty walking. I have had follow-up visits, but the doctor said that another surgery would suffice. May I ask, will another surgery really resol...

Dr. Yang Zhengfan reply Orthopedics
Dear Chen Xiaopang, what you mentioned is that hip joint revision surgery is more complex and troublesome than the first surgery. Is it not possible to use the "minimally invasive surgery" technique you referred to for the second replacement? This is a good question to ...

Should You Delay Hip Replacement Surgery for Osteoarthritis?

Doctor's diagnosis: OA (unspecified)/Osteoarthrosis/Osteoarthritis. Currently experiencing pain while walking, with a 2 cm leg length discrepancy. The doctor suggested that a total hip replacement surgery could be performed when the pain becomes unbearable, considering the p...

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
Based on your current condition, you should be able to undergo joint replacement surgery. Delaying the procedure too long could lead to significant bone wear, making the surgery more complicated. Moreover, you already have a leg length discrepancy. Under the National Health Insur...