Conflicting Hepatitis C Test Results: What Should You Trust? - Gastroenterology and Hepatology

More Info

---

When faced with conflicting Hepatitis C test results, it can be quite confusing and concerning. Your situation, where your husband has received both positive and negative test results for Hepatitis C, raises important questions about the reliability of these tests and the implications for his health.

1. Understanding Conflicting Test Results: The discrepancies in your husband's test results can be attributed to several factors. Hepatitis C testing typically involves two main types of tests: antibody tests (like Anti-HCV) and viral load tests (like HCV RNA). The antibody test detects the presence of antibodies to the Hepatitis C virus, indicating whether someone has been exposed to the virus. However, these tests can yield false positives or false negatives. False positives can occur due to cross-reactivity with other antibodies or conditions, while false negatives can happen if the person is in the early stages of infection, where antibodies have not yet developed.

In your husband's case, the positive results from the blood donation center could be false positives, especially if subsequent tests from different medical facilities returned negative results. This is not uncommon; studies suggest that a significant percentage of low-positive antibody tests can be false positives. Therefore, it is crucial to confirm the presence of the virus through a more specific test, such as an HCV RNA test, which directly measures the viral load in the blood.

2. Risk of Infection from Blood Exposure: Regarding the risk of Hepatitis C transmission through contact with infected blood, it is important to note that Hepatitis C is primarily transmitted through blood-to-blood contact. If your husband has a small cut and comes into contact with blood from someone who is Hepatitis C positive, the risk of transmission is indeed present, but it is generally considered to be low. The estimated risk of transmission from a single exposure to infected blood is around 1.8% to 3%, depending on various factors such as the amount of blood and the presence of any open wounds.

It is also worth noting that Hepatitis C is not transmitted through casual contact, such as hugging or sharing utensils. The virus requires direct access to the bloodstream, which is why the risk from minor skin contact is significantly lower.

In summary, the conflicting test results suggest that further testing is necessary to clarify your husband's Hepatitis C status. A follow-up with an HCV RNA test would provide a more definitive answer regarding whether he is currently infected with the virus. Additionally, while the risk of transmission from minor blood exposure exists, it is relatively low, and maintaining good hygiene practices can further reduce any potential risk. If you have ongoing concerns, consulting with a healthcare provider who specializes in infectious diseases or hepatology would be beneficial for personalized guidance and management.