Tuberculosis Diagnosis and Treatment: Key Questions Answered - Pulmonology

Share to:

Pulmonary tuberculosis


Hello: Recently, I sought medical attention due to a lower respiratory tract infection (cough with sputum) that had not improved for 10 days.
After an X-ray, there were signs of calcification, and the doctor suspected tuberculosis.
Currently, all three sputum tests and bronchial washings have returned negative results, and the bronchoscopy showed everything to be normal.
The tissue samples were also negative.
Since I am a rheumatoid arthritis (RA) patient and have previously taken corticosteroids, I am currently on methotrexate (MTX).
The doctor has prescribed first-line medication.
I would like to ask: 1.
Given that all tests are negative, should I start medication at this time? 2.
According to CDC treatment guidelines, shouldn't the doctor prescribe antibiotics for a week first? 3.
I need to travel to Thailand in late April, and the doctor informed me that if I do not take the medication, I may not be able to travel abroad.
Is that true? 4.
If I start medication now but the culture results are negative, will there be any adverse effects from the medication? Thank you!

Panghuang Wuzuo de Ren, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2008/03/30

Dr. Yang Wenda reply Pulmonology


Hello,
1.
The chest X-ray shows calcification; it is best to have X-rays from more than six months ago for comparison to confirm that the calcified lesion has not changed (stable, to determine it as inactive, and antibiotic treatment is not necessary).

2.
Currently, sputum tests are all negative, indicating non-open pulmonary tuberculosis, so there should be no restrictions when traveling abroad.

3.
For RA patients who are currently taking steroids and immunosuppressants, there is a possibility of decreased immune function, which may lead to the reactivation of dormant tuberculosis bacteria.
If there is a persistent cough or unexplained fever lasting more than two weeks, it is recommended to repeat the chest X-ray.

4.
Whether treatment is necessary at this time should consider comparing older films and whether your cough symptoms do not improve with general treatment; further discussion is advised! Alternatively, consult a tuberculosis specialist for further evaluation.

Best wishes!

Reply Date: 2008/03/30

More Info


When it comes to diagnosing and treating tuberculosis (TB), especially in the context of your specific situation, there are several important considerations to keep in mind. Tuberculosis is a serious infectious disease primarily affecting the lungs, but it can also impact other parts of the body. The diagnosis and treatment of TB involve a combination of clinical evaluation, laboratory tests, and imaging studies.

1. Negative Test Results and Initiating Treatment: You mentioned that your sputum tests and bronchial washings were all negative for TB. In general, a negative result from these tests can be reassuring, but it does not completely rule out the possibility of TB, especially if there are clinical signs or risk factors present. Given your history of rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and the use of immunosuppressive medications like methotrexate, your immune system may not respond typically to infections, including TB. Therefore, if your physician suspects active TB based on clinical findings or imaging (like the calcification seen in your X-ray), they may recommend starting treatment even if the initial tests are negative. This is particularly true if there is a high suspicion of latent TB infection or if you have been exposed to someone with active TB.

2. CDC Guidelines on Antibiotic Treatment: According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) guidelines, it is common practice to start empirical treatment for TB in patients with a high clinical suspicion of the disease, even before definitive microbiological confirmation is obtained. This is particularly critical in cases where the patient is at risk of severe disease or complications, such as those with underlying health conditions like RA. The rationale is to prevent the progression of the disease and to limit the risk of transmission to others.

3. Travel Considerations: Regarding your upcoming travel to Thailand, if there is a concern for active TB, your physician may advise starting treatment to ensure that you are not contagious during your travels. TB can be transmitted through the air, and if you were to be diagnosed with active TB while abroad, it could complicate your travel plans and health management. Therefore, it is prudent to follow your physician's advice regarding treatment prior to your trip.

4. Potential Side Effects of Treatment: If you begin TB treatment and subsequently receive negative culture results, it is important to discuss the potential side effects of the medications with your healthcare provider. First-line TB medications, such as isoniazid, rifampin, ethambutol, and pyrazinamide, can have side effects ranging from mild (nausea, fatigue) to severe (liver toxicity, allergic reactions). Your physician can monitor you closely for any adverse effects, especially considering your underlying RA and current medications.

In summary, the decision to start TB treatment should be made collaboratively with your healthcare provider, taking into account your clinical presentation, risk factors, and the results of your diagnostic tests. It is essential to weigh the potential benefits of early treatment against the risks of side effects, especially in the context of your existing health conditions. If you have further concerns or questions, do not hesitate to discuss them with your physician, who can provide personalized guidance based on your specific situation.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Tuberculosis: Symptoms, Diagnosis, and Treatment Insights

Hello Doctor: My mother had tuberculosis, and my second brother died of lung cancer, so I undergo regular chest X-ray examinations every year. In August of this year, I experienced slight chest discomfort and a mild cough. In September, I went to the health bureau for a chest X-r...


Dr. Zhou Ziguang reply Pulmonology
(1) It is indeed possible for some patients with pulmonary tuberculosis to have normal sputum tests (i.e., non-open cases), and diagnosis requires other clinical evidence. (2) Common side effects of anti-tuberculosis medications include liver function abnormalities, impaired visi...

[Read More] Understanding Tuberculosis: Symptoms, Diagnosis, and Treatment Insights


Understanding Tuberculosis: Diagnosis, Transmission, and Symptoms Explained

Hello, doctor: 1. Can an X-ray definitively determine if someone has tuberculosis (TB) of the lungs? 2. A few months ago, my family member was diagnosed with mild open pulmonary tuberculosis and was hospitalized for treatment. They have now been discharged and are continuing m...


Dr. Jiang Zhenyuan reply Pulmonology
Hello, Xiao Xiang: I am glad to receive your letter. 1. X-rays are an important tool for diagnosing tuberculosis (TB). Although X-rays have some limitations, most lesions can be visualized. However, to confirm the diagnosis, sputum tests are still necessary. 2. After treatmen...

[Read More] Understanding Tuberculosis: Diagnosis, Transmission, and Symptoms Explained


How to Determine If You Have Fully Recovered from Tuberculosis

Dear Dr. Chou, I would like to ask you a question. Six months ago, I was diagnosed with tuberculosis (not pulmonary tuberculosis) during surgery for lymphoma in my neck. I have been undergoing medication treatment for almost six months now. I am unsure how to determine whether I...


Dr. Zhou Ziguang reply Pulmonology
Hello Wenwen: Generally speaking, if the pathological report from the surgical specimen shows typical pathological manifestations of tuberculosis, it is considered extrapulmonary tuberculosis (in this case, lymphatic tuberculosis). The current policy is to treat for one year, and...

[Read More] How to Determine If You Have Fully Recovered from Tuberculosis


Understanding Suspected Tuberculosis Infection: Key Questions and Answers

Dear Doctor: My friend has been coughing for several days with frequent phlegm and sometimes experiences itching in the trachea. After seeking medical attention and undergoing tests, the sputum culture came back positive, and the CT scan results indicated changes in the lungs tha...


Dr. Zhou Ziguang reply Pulmonology
Hello: 1. Pulmonary infection with tuberculosis bacteria may not be detectable if there are no bacteria in the sputum. Generally, in such cases, clinicians make a comprehensive judgment, diagnosis, and treatment based on symptoms, medical history, other imaging studies (CT or che...

[Read More] Understanding Suspected Tuberculosis Infection: Key Questions and Answers


Related FAQ

Tuberculosis

(Pulmonology)

Mycobacterium Tuberculosis

(Pulmonology)

Pneumothorax

(Pulmonology)

Breathing

(Pulmonology)

Pulmonary Fibrosis

(Pulmonology)

Tuberculosis

(Internal Medicine)

Bronchiectasis

(Pulmonology)

Ct Scan

(Pulmonology)

Lung Nodule

(Pulmonology)

Allergies

(Pulmonology)