Phosphatidylserine (PS), fish oil, ginkgo biloba?
Recently, I saw on television that "phosphatidylserine (PS), fish oil, and ginkgo biloba" can enhance memory and promote faster neural connections for both adults and children.
I also noticed similar health supplements being sold.
I would like to ask: (1) Is there any medical basis for the claim that these health supplements can enhance memory? (2) What are the differences between the contents of two typical health supplements, where a contains 150mg of 70% PS phosphatidylserine (equivalent to 105mg of 100% PS phosphatidylserine) per 3 capsules, along with 100mg of 99% taurine, 275mg of microalgae DHA, ginkgo biloba extract, and fish oil, while b contains 100mg of soybean extract (70% phosphatidylserine) PS, 200mg of salmon extract powder (DHA), 50mg of L-glutamine, 50mg of taurine, 50mg of lecithin, and 50mg of Siberian ginseng extract? (3) If I usually eat out and my nutrition is likely unbalanced, what health supplements should I consider taking? (I am currently taking a multivitamin and fish oil as follows): Fish oil [1 Tablet] per serving: Energy 7.55 kcal, Protein 0.17g, Fat 0.72g, Saturated fat 0.22g, Trans fat 0g, Carbohydrates 0g, EPA 180mg, DHA 120mg, Vitamin E 1.0mg.
Multivitamin Each Serving Contains 1g [1 Tablet]: Protein 0.1g, Fat 0g, Carbohydrates 0.8g, Sodium 0.4mg, Vitamin A 750µg, β-Carotene 1500µg, Vitamin C 100mg, Vitamin D 10µg, Vitamin E 20mg, Vitamin K 25µg, Vitamin B1 1.5mg, Vitamin B2 1.7mg, Niacin 20mg, Vitamin B6 2mg, Folic acid 400µg, Vitamin B12 6µg, Biotin 30µg, Pantothenic acid 10mg, Calcium 200mg, Phosphorus 100mg, Magnesium 100mg, Iron 18mg, Iodine 150µg, Zinc 15mg, Copper 2mg, Manganese 3.5mg, Chloride 36.3mg, Potassium 40mg, Selenium yeast 25µg, Chromium yeast 6.5µg, Molybdenum yeast 160µg, Marigold extract (containing lutein) 2mg.
qaz, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2008/04/27
Dr. Hou Fangmin reply Pharmacology
1.
These three products have been medically proven to promote cerebral blood circulation; however, their effectiveness and intensity in enhancing memory vary from person to person.
Recently, many schools have been encouraging middle school students to take ginkgo biloba, but it is advisable to avoid its use in younger individuals, as it can cause vasodilation.
For older adults, ginkgo biloba may help prevent dementia.
My recommendation is to consider phosphatidylserine (PS) and fish oil in small amounts.
If you choose to use ginkgo, it is best to have a physician prescribe it for appropriate use.
2.
Each type of "health supplement" has different claimed effects based on its formulation and composition.
In addition to examining the ingredients, one must also consider the minimum effective dosage.
Furthermore, individual dietary preferences, habits, and physical conditions will influence the types of additional nutritional supplements needed.
For those who frequently eat out, I suggest supplementing with a comprehensive multivitamin, which contains various vitamins to compensate for any deficiencies from dining out.
It may also be beneficial to consult a nutritionist at a hospital to tailor the most suitable nutritional supplementation for you.
Thank you, and I wish you peace and happiness.
Reply Date: 2008/04/27
More Info
Enhancing memory through dietary supplements has become a popular topic, especially with the rise of products like phosphatidylserine (PS), fish oil, and ginkgo biloba. Let's explore the medical basis for these claims, the differences between specific supplements, and recommendations for those with dietary imbalances.
1. Medical Basis for Memory Enhancement:
The assertion that certain health supplements can enhance memory does have some scientific backing. Phosphatidylserine is a phospholipid that is crucial for maintaining cellular function, particularly in the brain. Research has indicated that PS may help improve cognitive functions, including memory, especially in older adults. Fish oil, rich in omega-3 fatty acids (DHA and EPA), has also been linked to brain health. Omega-3 fatty acids are essential for neuronal function and may help reduce cognitive decline. Ginkgo biloba is often touted for its potential to improve blood circulation, which could theoretically enhance cognitive function. However, the effectiveness of these supplements can vary from person to person, and while some studies show positive results, others do not establish a clear benefit.
2. Differences Between Supplement Formulations:
When comparing the two formulations you provided (a and b), there are notable differences in their composition:
- Formulation A contains 150 mg of PS (70% PS phosphatidylserine), 100 mg of taurine, 275 mg of DHA from microalgae, ginkgo extract, and fish oil. This formulation appears to focus on a higher concentration of DHA, which is beneficial for brain health, along with ginkgo, which may support cognitive function.
- Formulation B includes 100 mg of PS (70% PS), 200 mg of DHA from salmon extract, 50 mg of L-glutamine, 50 mg of taurine, 50 mg of lecithin, and Siberian ginseng extract. This formulation offers a broader range of ingredients, including L-glutamine, which is important for neurotransmitter synthesis, and ginseng, which may help with energy and cognitive function.
The choice between these formulations may depend on individual health goals and dietary needs. For instance, if someone is looking for a higher DHA content, formulation B may be more suitable.
3. Nutritional Needs for Those with Unbalanced Diets:
For individuals who frequently eat out and may not have a balanced diet, supplementation can be beneficial. A multivitamin is a good start, as it can help fill nutritional gaps. Additionally, focusing on omega-3 fatty acids through fish oil is advisable, as these are often under-consumed in typical diets. Other beneficial supplements could include:
- Vitamin B Complex: Essential for energy metabolism and cognitive function.
- Antioxidants: Such as vitamins C and E, which can protect brain cells from oxidative stress.
- Magnesium: Important for nerve function and may help with memory.
- Zinc: Plays a role in neurotransmission and cognitive function.
In conclusion, while there is some evidence supporting the use of phosphatidylserine, fish oil, and ginkgo biloba for enhancing memory, individual responses can vary. It is essential to consider personal health conditions and dietary habits when choosing supplements. Consulting with a healthcare professional or a registered dietitian can provide personalized recommendations based on individual nutritional needs and health goals. Remember, a balanced diet rich in whole foods is the best foundation for cognitive health.
Similar Q&A
How to Improve Memory: Do Ginkgo Biloba and Other Remedies Help?
Is ginkgo biloba effective for improving frequent forgetfulness? If so, is it more effective to consume it as a tea or to take it in supplement form? Are there other methods or foods that can help improve memory, as I would like to avoid being forgetful frequently? Thank you.
Dr. Liao Huiling reply Pharmacology
1. There are many commercial ginkgo products available, but since they are classified as dietary supplements, their efficacy cannot be guaranteed. 2. Forgetfulness is not a disease, but if it is caused by an underlying medical condition, one should seek formal medical treatment...[Read More] How to Improve Memory: Do Ginkgo Biloba and Other Remedies Help?
Herbs to Boost Memory and Focus: Traditional Chinese Medicine Insights
What herbs can enhance memory, improve alertness, increase concentration, and boost reaction time?
Dr. Zhuang Yihui reply Traditional Chinese Medicine
In Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM), the brain is considered the sea of marrow. Nourishing the kidneys can replenish essence and enhance marrow, leading to sufficient brain power and naturally improved memory. For instance, the popular formula Liu Wei Di Huang Wan contains ingr...[Read More] Herbs to Boost Memory and Focus: Traditional Chinese Medicine Insights
Can Ginkgo Biloba Improve Memory in Seniors with Hypertension?
Dr. Ouyang, my father is 84 years old and has experienced a decline in memory over the past six months. I have heard that ginkgo biloba may improve memory, but I am unsure if this is true. Could you please clarify? Thank you! (My father has hypertension and is currently on medica...
Dr. Ouyang Wenzhen reply Geriatrics
Hello: One of the pharmacological effects of Ginkgo biloba is its antiplatelet aggregation action. The Ministry of Health and Welfare in Taiwan has approved its (conventional medicine) indication for peripheral blood circulation disorders. There have been varying opinions on the ...[Read More] Can Ginkgo Biloba Improve Memory in Seniors with Hypertension?
Understanding Memory Loss: Insights and Solutions for Students
Hello Doctor, I am currently attending university, and I have noticed a significant decline in my memory over the past two to three years. A few years ago, I was reckless and experimented with drugs, specifically the Class II drugs MDMA and ketamine, among others. Due to my past ...
Dr. Lin Zijing reply Neurology
After briefly forgetting something, one can remember it again after a reminder; this situation is more akin to issues with attention. To prevent memory decline, here are several methods: 1. Concentration: When memorizing, focusing intently and eliminating distractions will ...[Read More] Understanding Memory Loss: Insights and Solutions for Students
Related FAQ
(Pharmacology)
Herbal Medicine(Pharmacology)
Chronic Diseases(Pharmacology)
Oral Contraceptives(Pharmacology)
Drug Classification(Pharmacology)
Drug Interactions(Pharmacology)
Psychiatric Medications(Pharmacology)
Drug Interactions(Traditional Chinese Medicine)
Weight Loss Products(Pharmacology)
Dietary Therapy(Traditional Chinese Medicine)