Pancreatic Cancer: A Family's Journey and Medical Decisions - Oncology

Share to:

Pancreatic cancer


A mother who was usually healthy suddenly experienced severe jaundice.
An ultrasound examination by the doctor revealed enlarged liver and gallbladder.
A gastroscopy found a tumor about 1 cm in size at the head of the duodenum.
An emergency exploratory laparotomy was scheduled for the next day, and it was initially judged to be benign.
However, post-surgery evaluation determined it to be pancreatic head cancer, approximately 7 x 4 cm, leading to the removal of the pancreatic head and part of the duodenum.
Additionally, a portion of liver tissue was taken for examination, which later confirmed metastasis to liver cancer.

Before the surgery, I entered the operating room and noticed abnormalities in the liver.
I asked the physician whether there was metastasis, and if so, it should not be removed.
The doctor assured me that it should not be metastasis.
However, after the surgery, I was informed that the assessment indicated it was indeed metastasis.
Furthermore, I later learned that the National Health Insurance Bureau did not approve such procedures at regional hospitals, but the hospital did not inform us beforehand.

I would like to ask whether the urgent surgery performed by the physician and the hospital was appropriate and if it violated medical ethics.
Secondly, after researching pancreatic cancer, I learned that those with metastasis may only have 3 to 6 months to live.
My mother lived for about three months from diagnosis to death.
Would it have been better for her to not undergo the surgery initially? Was there a chance for recovery? During this time, my mother was unable to eat but remained mentally clear, though her physical strength declined.
Our family provided 24-hour personal care, choosing a private room to exclude people she did not like.
She later fell into hepatic coma and died from heart failure about a day later, with the family choosing not to resuscitate.

Thirdly, everything happened so suddenly that the family initially did not understand the illness and trusted the physician's expertise, leaving everything to fate, yet the outcome was as it was.
Fourthly, I do not wish to hold the doctor responsible; I just want to know if our actions were the best choice for my mother, as I have always felt regret that if we had gone to a teaching hospital from the beginning, the situation might have been different.

Fifthly, I kindly request a detailed response to clarify the doubts and pain my family has experienced over the years.
Thank you.

Xiao Yang, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2001/07/24

Dr. Yang Youhua reply Oncology


Hello, Little Lamb: The question you raised involves many surgical specialties.
Since the field of medicine is highly specialized, non-surgical specialists do not have the authority to comment on surgical-related professional issues.
Thank you for your understanding.

Reply Date: 2001/07/24

More Info


The journey through a diagnosis of pancreatic cancer can be incredibly challenging for both the patient and their family. In the case you presented, your mother was diagnosed with pancreatic cancer after a series of alarming symptoms, including severe jaundice and abdominal discomfort. The subsequent surgical intervention revealed a significant tumor, and unfortunately, it was later determined that there had been metastasis to the liver. This situation raises several important questions regarding the appropriateness of the medical decisions made, the nature of pancreatic cancer, and the overall treatment approach.

Firstly, regarding the decision to proceed with surgery, it is essential to understand that pancreatic cancer is often diagnosed at an advanced stage due to its subtle symptoms and the location of the pancreas deep within the abdomen. Surgical resection is typically the best option for localized tumors, as it can potentially offer a chance for a cure. However, if there is evidence of metastasis, as in your mother's case, the benefits of surgery become more complex. The initial assessment by the surgical team may have indicated that the liver abnormalities were not metastatic, leading to the decision to operate. However, if there were signs of metastasis that were overlooked, this could raise ethical concerns about the decision-making process and the communication of risks and benefits to the family.

In terms of the prognosis, pancreatic cancer is known for its aggressive nature and poor survival rates, particularly when diagnosed at stage IV, where metastasis has occurred. The average survival time for patients with metastatic pancreatic cancer is indeed limited, often ranging from a few months to a year, depending on various factors such as the patient's overall health, response to treatment, and the extent of disease progression. The decision to undergo surgery in the presence of metastatic disease is often a difficult one, and it is understandable to question whether a different approach might have led to a better outcome.

Your reflections on the possibility of seeking treatment at a teaching hospital are valid. Academic medical centers often have access to the latest research, clinical trials, and multidisciplinary teams that can provide comprehensive care for complex cases. If there is a lingering sense of regret about the choices made, it may be helpful to consider that the medical landscape is constantly evolving, and decisions are often made based on the information available at the time.

As for the emotional toll of this experience, it is crucial to acknowledge the profound impact that a cancer diagnosis has on families. The feelings of helplessness, confusion, and regret are common, and it is important to process these emotions. Engaging with support groups, counseling, or therapy can provide a safe space to explore these feelings and find a path toward healing.

In conclusion, while the decisions made during your mother's treatment may raise questions about appropriateness and ethics, it is essential to recognize the complexities involved in diagnosing and treating pancreatic cancer. The medical team operates within the constraints of available knowledge and technology, and while hindsight may offer clarity, it is often difficult to predict outcomes in such challenging cases. Moving forward, focusing on the memories and love shared with your mother, as well as seeking support for the emotional aftermath, can be a meaningful way to honor her journey.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Pancreatic Cancer: Symptoms, Diagnosis, and Expert Guidance

Doctor: Hello! Could you please help me with some questions? My father is 58 years old and has been in good health with few ailments until this year. Since the beginning of this year, he has been experiencing persistent upper abdominal pain, has lost over 10 kilograms, and has a ...


Dr. Huang Zhihui reply Surgery
Based on the examination report, it appears that your father may be suffering from chronic pancreatitis, rather than cancer. The physician may want to wait until all test results are available before providing you with a definitive diagnosis. In fact, even in the case of cancer, ...

[Read More] Understanding Pancreatic Cancer: Symptoms, Diagnosis, and Expert Guidance


Understanding Pancreatic Cancer Risk: Genetic Factors and Screening Guidelines

Hello, Doctor. I would like to ask you about my father, who was diagnosed with pancreatic cancer at the age of 39. At that time, he had very poor lifestyle habits and engaged in almost all bad habits (staying up late, excessive drinking, smoking, etc.). However, I have maintained...


Dr. Chen Shidian reply Gastroenterology and Hepatology
The hereditary rate of pancreatic cancer is not high (unless there are specific genes, which are generally not tested in Taiwan). If concerned, it is recommended to undergo an annual ultrasound examination (at one's own expense).

[Read More] Understanding Pancreatic Cancer Risk: Genetic Factors and Screening Guidelines


Understanding Pancreatic Cancer: Treatment Options and Dietary Adjustments

Hello, I am asking on behalf of my mother who is 50 years old, does not smoke or drink, and has a normal lifestyle. A month ago, she was diagnosed with pancreatic cancer that has metastasized to the ovaries and colon. Initially, she experienced abdominal pain and thought it was a...


Dr. Lai Yicheng reply Oncology
According to your description, your mother has pancreatic cancer with metastasis to the ovaries and colon, classified as stage IV cancer. Currently, she is post-surgery and receiving gemcitabine chemotherapy and thrombolytic therapy. To address your questions in order: 1. Accor...

[Read More] Understanding Pancreatic Cancer: Treatment Options and Dietary Adjustments


Managing Rising Cancer Markers: Treatment Options for Advanced Pancreatic Cancer

Hello, my father was diagnosed with stage IV pancreatic cancer in December, with vascular involvement making surgery impossible. His CA19-9 level is 340, and he has completed a regimen of 7 days of chemotherapy followed by 1 week off, and will continue with a regimen of 3 weeks o...


Dr. Hu Ziren reply Oncology
It is recommended to discuss with the attending physician for more appropriate guidance!

[Read More] Managing Rising Cancer Markers: Treatment Options for Advanced Pancreatic Cancer


Related FAQ

Pancreatic Cancer

(Oncology)

Pancreatic Cancer

(Gastroenterology and Hepatology)

Bile Duct Cancer

(Oncology)

Stomach Cancer

(Oncology)

Cancer Treatment

(Oncology)

Melanoma

(Oncology)

Ovarian Tumor

(Oncology)

Bladder Cancer

(Oncology)

Lymphadenopathy

(Oncology)

Blood Cancer

(Oncology)