Differences Between Hemorrhoidectomy and Rectal Prolapse Treatment Explained - Surgery

Share to:

What are the differences between complete excision of internal and external hemorrhoids and the treatment of rectal prolapse?


Hello, Dr.
Shen.
I underwent a complete excision of internal and external hemorrhoids at the end of last year.
When I applied for insurance reimbursement, the claims department indicated that a complete excision of internal and external hemorrhoids must include treatment for rectal prolapse in order to qualify for a higher reimbursement amount.
Therefore, I would like to inquire about the differences among the following three procedures in terms of surgery and treatment: 1.
Partial excision of internal and external hemorrhoids 2.
Complete excision of internal and external hemorrhoids 3.
Treatment for rectal prolapse.
Thank you for your response.

ms, 40~49 year old female. Ask Date: 2009/02/18

Dr. Shen Mingyin reply Surgery


Hello: As the name suggests, partial excision of internal and external hemorrhoids involves removing only a portion of the internal and external hemorrhoids, while complete excision entails the total removal of the pathological internal and external hemorrhoids.
The difference lies in the extent of the surgical procedure.
In medical terminology, prolapse refers to the protrusion of the rectum, which is a different condition from hemorrhoids; however, I am unsure of the definition of prolapse as defined by the insurance company.
Thank you for your inquiry, and I wish you peace! Dr.
Ming-Yin Shen

Reply Date: 2009/02/18

More Info


When discussing the differences between hemorrhoidectomy and rectal prolapse treatment, it's essential to understand the distinct conditions these procedures address, as well as their surgical techniques and recovery processes.


1. Hemorrhoidectomy (Partial and Complete)
Internal and External Hemorrhoid Removal:
- Internal hemorrhoids are located inside the rectum, while external hemorrhoids are found under the skin around the anus.
- A partial hemorrhoidectomy typically refers to the removal of only the problematic internal or external hemorrhoids, which may involve excising only the most symptomatic tissue.

- A complete hemorrhoidectomy involves the removal of all internal and external hemorrhoids, which is often indicated for severe cases where symptoms are persistent and debilitating. This procedure can be performed using various techniques, including traditional excisional methods or newer techniques like stapled hemorrhoidopexy.

Surgical Process:
- The surgery is usually performed under local or general anesthesia, depending on the extent of the procedure and the patient's condition.

- Recovery from a hemorrhoidectomy can involve significant pain, bleeding, and discomfort, especially in the first few days post-surgery. Patients are often advised to take sitz baths, use topical analgesics, and maintain a high-fiber diet to ease bowel movements.


2. Rectal Prolapse Treatment
Understanding Rectal Prolapse:
- Rectal prolapse occurs when the rectum protrudes through the anus, which can happen due to weakening of the pelvic floor muscles and connective tissues. This condition can be associated with chronic constipation, straining during bowel movements, or other factors that increase intra-abdominal pressure.

Surgical Treatment:
- Treatment for rectal prolapse typically involves surgical intervention to restore the rectum to its normal position and may include procedures like rectopexy (fixing the rectum to the surrounding tissues) or resection (removing a portion of the rectum).

- Unlike hemorrhoidectomy, which focuses on removing swollen blood vessels, rectal prolapse surgery aims to correct the anatomical displacement of the rectum.

Recovery and Considerations:
- Recovery from rectal prolapse surgery can vary based on the specific technique used but generally involves a longer recovery period compared to hemorrhoidectomy. Patients may experience discomfort, changes in bowel habits, and the need for physical therapy to strengthen pelvic floor muscles.


Key Differences
- Indications: Hemorrhoidectomy is indicated for symptomatic hemorrhoids, while rectal prolapse surgery is for correcting anatomical issues related to the rectum.

- Surgical Techniques: Hemorrhoidectomy focuses on excising swollen blood vessels, whereas rectal prolapse treatment involves repositioning or repairing the rectum.

- Recovery: Recovery from hemorrhoidectomy can be painful but is generally shorter than recovery from rectal prolapse surgery, which may require more extensive rehabilitation.


Insurance Considerations
Regarding your insurance claim, it’s important to clarify with your insurance provider the specific definitions and classifications they use for these procedures. If your surgery involved both hemorrhoidectomy and rectal prolapse correction, it may warrant a higher reimbursement rate due to the complexity and extent of the surgical intervention. Providing detailed documentation from your surgeon that outlines the procedures performed and their necessity can help support your claim.

In conclusion, while hemorrhoidectomy and rectal prolapse treatment may seem related, they address different conditions and involve distinct surgical approaches. Understanding these differences can assist in navigating insurance claims and ensuring appropriate care and recovery. If you have further questions or concerns, consulting with your surgeon or a healthcare professional specializing in colorectal surgery would be beneficial.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Rectal Prolapse: Causes, Symptoms, and Treatment Options

Hello: Please tell me what is rectal prolapse? How does it occur? How is it treated? Thank you.


Dr. Wang Qichao reply Surgery
Generally speaking, the term "prolapse" is commonly used to refer to hemorrhoidal prolapse, but it is important to distinguish it from rectal prolapse. Hemorrhoids, more appropriately referred to as anal cushions, serve to protect the anal canal during defecation and as...

[Read More] Understanding Rectal Prolapse: Causes, Symptoms, and Treatment Options


Understanding Hemorrhoids vs. Rectal Prolapse: Symptoms and Treatment Options

Hello, Doctor You: I have experienced symptoms similar to hemorrhoids since childhood, where they protrude during bowel movements. This has been ongoing for over 20 years, and sometimes there is bleeding. After bowel movements, I can push them back in. I have visited several cli...


Dr. You Bailing reply Surgery
Severe hemorrhoids can lead to rectal prolapse. However, since the physician at Chung Rong has found no signs of prolapse, this should be considered quite reliable. I believe it is highly likely that you have hemorrhoids. I recommend taking warm sitz baths, avoiding constipation,...

[Read More] Understanding Hemorrhoids vs. Rectal Prolapse: Symptoms and Treatment Options


Effective Treatments for Prolapsed Hemorrhoids: A Guide

Hello doctor, I have a history of hemorrhoids. In the past, I only used topical medications and warm sitz baths, and I didn't have any major issues. However, recently, due to work, I have to stand for over ten hours a day, and I have been experiencing diarrhea for the past t...


Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
For hemorrhoids that are prolapsed and cannot be pushed back in, the most effective treatment is surgical removal. While conservative treatments can alleviate discomfort and bleeding symptoms, surgery is the only option if improvement of the prolapse is desired.

[Read More] Effective Treatments for Prolapsed Hemorrhoids: A Guide


Understanding Hemorrhoids: When to Seek Treatment and Potential Risks

Hello, Director Ke. I would like to ask: 1. I currently have some tissue around the anal area that looks like hemorrhoids. There is no significant swelling, pain, prolapse, or bleeding, and the sensation of a foreign body is mild. I only experience occasional anal fissures (with ...


Dr. Ke Fangxu reply Surgery
1. Surgery is not necessary for hemorrhoids if there is no persistent bleeding, severe pain, or significant prolapse; most cases can be improved through lifestyle modifications and changes in bowel habits. 2. Hemorrhoids do not progress to rectal prolapse or rectal prolapse. If...

[Read More] Understanding Hemorrhoids: When to Seek Treatment and Potential Risks


Related FAQ