Medication Issues in Alzheimer's Disease
My father-in-law is receiving treatment for dementia at Hualien Tzu Chi Hospital.
Recently, the doctor mentioned that there has been no improvement with the medication, and since the drugs are expensive, it feels like a waste to continue them.
He prescribed two medications that require out-of-pocket payment: Witgen (for treating Alzheimer's disease) and Cirzodone (for treating low mood).
However, when I checked the National Health Insurance Administration website today, I found that these medications are covered by insurance.
Why is the doctor asking us to pay out of pocket?
Xiao Fen, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2009/03/18
Dr. Lin Zijing reply Neurology
Currently, the medications used to treat Alzheimer's disease primarily include donepezil (Aricept), rivastigmine (Exelon), galantamine (Reminyl), and memantine (Witgen).
Health insurance regulations require that these medications be prescribed only after blood tests, memory assessments, and brain imaging (CT scans) are conducted, followed by a written application that must be approved before a prescription can be issued.
Once approved, the patient can take the medication for six months, after which a reassessment of memory is required to apply for another six months of medication.
If the memory assessment score declines by more than 2 points, the medication cannot be continued.
Therefore, there are several situations in which medication cannot be prescribed, such as: 1.
The physician did not apply; 2.
The application was submitted but not approved; 3.
Reassessment reveals a decline in score; 4.
The patient's dementia is more severe, and medication may not lead to improvement; 5.
The patient's dementia is not purely Alzheimer's disease, etc.
These specifics should be discussed with a physician for clarification.
Reply Date: 2009/03/18
More Info
Understanding the complexities of Alzheimer's medication costs and insurance coverage can be quite challenging, especially when dealing with the emotional and financial burdens of caring for a loved one with dementia. In your case, it appears that your grandfather is being prescribed Witgen (Memantine) for Alzheimer's disease and Cirzodone (likely a brand name for an antidepressant) for mood stabilization. The fact that these medications are not covered by insurance can be frustrating, particularly when you see that other medications for Alzheimer's are listed as covered.
The primary reason your grandfather may be required to pay out-of-pocket for these medications could be due to several factors related to the healthcare system and the specific requirements for medication coverage under the National Health Insurance (NHI) in Taiwan. Here are some key points to consider:
1. Eligibility for Coverage: In Taiwan, certain medications for Alzheimer's disease, such as Donepezil, Rivastigmine, and Galantamine, require specific diagnostic criteria and tests to be met before they can be prescribed under the NHI. This often includes blood tests, cognitive assessments, and brain imaging to confirm the diagnosis and severity of the condition. If these steps were not completed, or if the physician did not submit the necessary paperwork for approval, the medications may not be covered.
2. Severity of Condition: If your grandfather's Alzheimer's disease is classified as severe, the physician may determine that the potential benefits of the medication do not outweigh the costs, leading to a recommendation against its use. In such cases, the physician may opt for medications that are not covered by insurance, believing they may be more appropriate for the patient's condition.
3. Alternative Treatments: The physician may also consider that the prescribed medications may not provide significant improvement in cognitive function, leading to the conclusion that they are not worth the expense. This can be particularly true if previous treatments have not yielded positive results.
4. Insurance Policy Limitations: Each insurance policy has specific guidelines regarding what is covered. It is possible that the medications prescribed do not meet the criteria set forth by the NHI, which can lead to the requirement for self-payment.
5. Communication with Healthcare Providers: It is crucial to have open communication with your grandfather's healthcare providers. They can provide clarity on why certain medications are recommended and the rationale behind the decision to prescribe medications that require out-of-pocket expenses. They may also be able to suggest alternative treatments that are covered by insurance.
6. Financial Assistance Programs: In some cases, pharmaceutical companies offer assistance programs for patients who cannot afford their medications. It may be worthwhile to inquire about such programs for Witgen and Cirzodone.
In conclusion, navigating the complexities of medication costs and insurance coverage for Alzheimer's treatment requires understanding the specific policies in place and the medical rationale behind prescribed treatments. Engaging with healthcare professionals and exploring all available options can help alleviate some of the financial burdens associated with these necessary medications. If you feel uncertain about the prescribed treatment plan, consider seeking a second opinion from another healthcare provider who specializes in geriatric medicine or neurology.
Similar Q&A
Choosing the Right Cholinesterase Inhibitor for Dementia Patients
Hello, doctor: May I ask how the choice of acetylcholinesterase inhibitors covered by health insurance, such as Donepezil, Rivastigmine, and Galantamine, is typically determined for patients? Is there a specific order for prescribing these three medications (from Donepezil to Riv...
Dr. Gao Chunde reply Neurology
Based on the patient's dementia symptoms and accompanying related symptoms, the physician will have appropriate options. As for the order, your first choice can actually be used for patients with moderate to severe dementia; many patients experience improvement all at once. ...[Read More] Choosing the Right Cholinesterase Inhibitor for Dementia Patients
Alternatives to Alzheimer's Medication: Options When Insurance Denies Coverage
Your mother has been using the medication (Aicardi) for dementia for some time. This time, the health insurance did not approve the medication. It is recommended to either purchase it out of pocket or consider discontinuing it, or if there are other alternative medications availa...
Dr. Gao Chunde reply Neurology
There are other dementia medications that can be considered. Since Aiyuxin has not been effective, it indicates that the dementia symptoms have continued to worsen to a certain extent after using this medication. You may want to discuss with your attending physician whether your ...[Read More] Alternatives to Alzheimer's Medication: Options When Insurance Denies Coverage
Why Is the Cost of Psychiatric Medication So High?
Why is the medication Yijian so expensive?
Dr. Zhang Zhehong reply Psychiatry
Hello, is the medication "Shida Brain Health" tablet 2mg? The pricing of medications is determined by many factors and is ultimately approved by the pharmaceutical company and the National Health Insurance Administration. If you have any questions, please discuss them w...[Read More] Why Is the Cost of Psychiatric Medication So High?
Caring for an Elderly Relative with Dementia: Tips and Medication Options
Your grandmother is 81 years old and has recently started to have difficulty recognizing the way home. The family is usually busy with work and has previously suggested hiring a caregiver, but there is a lack of trust in that option. How should we care for her? Is there any medic...
Dr. Gao Chunde reply Neurology
Dementia, aside from degeneration, can also be caused by identifiable factors that lead to cognitive decline and memory loss. In some cases, certain medications may be responsible for these symptoms. It is advisable to first consult a neurologist to identify and address any manag...[Read More] Caring for an Elderly Relative with Dementia: Tips and Medication Options
Related FAQ
(Neurology)
Medication(Neurology)
Alzheimer'S Disease(Geriatrics)
Medication Consultation(Neurology)
Ankle(Neurology)
Medication Side Effects(Neurology)
Alzheimer'S Disease(Psychiatry)
Electroencephalogram(Neurology)
Memory(Neurology)
Face(Neurology)