Knee Lumps: Diagnosis and Treatment Options Explained

Q: Knee Lumps: Diagnosis and Treatment Options Explained

Hello： Based on your description, your mother has developed a lump next to her knee. <br>After examination by two orthopedic surgeons and X-ray imaging, no abnormalities were found. <br>It can be preliminarily concluded that this tumor is likely a soft tissue tumor, most commonly

Tumor near the knee?

Hello Dr.
Lee,
I would like to ask you a question.
My mother has developed a lump near her knee (specifically in the area where the knee bends).
She has seen two orthopedic surgeons, both of whom performed X-rays.
One doctor mentioned that it was due to gas accumulation and recommended physical therapy.
The other doctor suggested it was a cyst and that it needs to be surgically removed.
We are quite confused.
Should we seek further diagnostic tests? Which specialty should we consult? If it is indeed a cyst, what would be the appropriate management? Should we continue seeing an orthopedic surgeon, specifically one who specializes in joint issues? Thank you for taking the time to address our concerns!

A-Ling, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2009/04/24

Dr. Li Wenlin reply Orthopedics

Hello: Based on your description, your mother has developed a lump next to her knee.
After examination by two orthopedic surgeons and X-ray imaging, no abnormalities were found.
It can be preliminarily concluded that this tumor is likely a soft tissue tumor, most commonly a ganglion cyst, also known as a water tumor.
However, there may be other possibilities.
To further differentiate the diagnosis, you can request an ultrasound examination.
If the ultrasound shows that the tumor contains fluid, the diagnosis can be almost certain.
If the orthopedic surgeon is unwilling to arrange this, you may consider seeking care at another hospital or from a different physician.
If it is indeed a ganglion cyst, it is important to consult an orthopedic surgeon for management, as ganglion cysts are benign tumors and surgical removal is not always necessary.
I recommend accompanying your mother to her follow-up appointment to communicate directly with the attending physician, which should help resolve your concerns.
Wishing you all the best!

Reply Date: 2009/04/24

More Info

When it comes to understanding knee lumps, particularly in the context of your mother's situation, it's essential to approach the diagnosis and treatment options with a comprehensive understanding of the potential causes and the appropriate medical pathways to follow.

Firstly, the lump near the knee could be attributed to various conditions, including but not limited to ganglion cysts, bursitis, lipomas, or even more serious conditions such as tumors. Given that two orthopedic doctors have provided differing opinions—one suggesting it is a gas-related issue that can be treated with physical therapy, and the other indicating it may be a cyst requiring surgical removal—it's understandable that you feel confused.

Diagnosis
1. Imaging Studies: While X-rays can provide some information about bone structures, they are not always sufficient for soft tissue evaluation. An MRI or ultrasound may be more appropriate for assessing soft tissue masses, such as cysts or other fluid-filled structures. These imaging modalities can help differentiate between a ganglion cyst, a bursitis, or other potential issues.

2. Physical Examination: A thorough physical examination by a specialist is crucial. The doctor will assess the size, consistency, and tenderness of the lump, which can provide valuable diagnostic clues.

3. Referral to a Specialist: Since there is uncertainty regarding the diagnosis, it may be beneficial to consult a specialist in orthopedic surgery, particularly one who focuses on joint disorders. A rheumatologist could also be consulted if there is a suspicion of inflammatory conditions.

Treatment Options
If the lump is indeed a ganglion cyst or a bursa (which can be inflamed and filled with fluid), treatment options may include:
- Observation: If the lump is not causing significant pain or functional impairment, a watchful waiting approach may be appropriate.

- Aspiration: If the lump is a cyst, aspiration (removing the fluid with a needle) can provide relief and confirm the diagnosis. This procedure is often done in an outpatient setting.

- Injection Therapy: Corticosteroid injections may help reduce inflammation if bursitis is diagnosed.

- Surgical Removal: If the lump is persistent, painful, or causing functional issues, surgical excision may be warranted. This is particularly true if it is confirmed to be a ganglion cyst or if there is a concern about other types of masses.

Next Steps
Given the conflicting opinions from the two orthopedic doctors, it would be prudent to seek further evaluation. Here are some steps you can take:
1. Request Advanced Imaging: Ask for an MRI or ultrasound to get a clearer picture of the lump's nature.

2. Consult a Specialist: If you haven't already, consider seeing a knee specialist or an orthopedic surgeon with experience in soft tissue masses.

3. Keep a Record: Document any changes in the lump, such as size, pain level, or any associated symptoms, as this information can be helpful for the physician.

4. Consider a Second Opinion: If you feel uncertain about the diagnosis or treatment plan, seeking a second opinion from another orthopedic surgeon or a specialist in joint disorders can provide additional clarity.

In summary, while the lump near your mother's knee may be benign, it is essential to pursue further diagnostic evaluation to ensure an accurate diagnosis and appropriate treatment plan. Consulting with a specialist and possibly obtaining advanced imaging will help clarify the situation and guide the next steps in management.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Knee Osteochondroma: Causes, Symptoms, and Treatment Options

One day while sitting and watching TV, I noticed a lump near my knee when I had my legs stretched out on the sofa. I found it quite strange, so I went to the public health center and was told it is a knee chondroma. I would like to inquire about the causes of this knee chondroma ...

Dr. Shi Guozheng reply Orthopedics
Miss Yang, the issue you are inquiring about may be an osteochondroma, which is a benign and quite common tumor of the knee joint. If it is solitary, it is generally benign. The growth of the tumor is usually slow, and if it reaches a certain size, it may compress surrounding tis...

Knee Effusion: Understanding Symptoms, Diagnosis, and Treatment Options

I got up from the bathtub and heard a pop in my knee, which immediately caused pain and swelling. I went to see a rehabilitation specialist and had an ultrasound, which indicated knee effusion. Despite ongoing rehabilitation treatment, there has been no improvement; I cannot bend...

Dr. You Dianqi reply Orthopedics
Hello, it is advisable to visit the orthopedic outpatient clinic for evaluation. Thank you.

Understanding Knee Bumps: Causes, Symptoms, and Treatment Options

Hello, Doctor! When I was in elementary school, I fell while playing sports, and shortly after, I felt a bone protruding from my knee. Since it didn't hurt, I didn't see a doctor. However, when I became aware of the bone protrusion, it became very painful when I knelt d...

Dr. Shen Boquan reply Orthopedics
Hello Ms. Dai, I am unsure whether your current discomfort is due to pain or bone protrusion. Pain from bone protrusion can be alleviated through rest or anti-inflammatory pain medications. Surgical removal may be necessary to address the protrusion. Avoiding kneeling or squattin...

Understanding Pain and Treatment Options for Knee Tumors

There is an 8 cm tumor near the growth plate of my left knee. It was accidentally discovered at the hospital a year ago. Initially, it didn't hurt and I didn't feel much, but now it hurts at any time, sometimes to the point where my entire leg feels numb, especially aro...

Dr. Li Yongheng reply Orthopedics
Your symptoms suggest that you may have a bone tumor. However, an 8 cm tumor is not small, so you should return to the hospital for a re-evaluation as soon as possible. If there are any changes, surgical treatment may be necessary. Please remember to follow up promptly, and I wis...