When to Remove Ear Tubes in Young Children: Risks and Recommendations

Q: When to Remove Ear Tubes in Young Children: Risks and Recommendations

Dear Sir/Madam： 1. A four-year-old child had tympanostomy tubes inserted. At five years and two months (one year and two and a half months later), the tubes have not yet fallen out. When should they be removed? A. Approximately within one year. 2.

Timing for the removal of the tympanostomy tubes in young children (forwarded from the Director's mailbox)?

When a four-year-old child has tympanostomy tubes placed in their ears and they have not fallen out by the age of five years and two months (one year and two and a half months later), the tubes should typically be removed if they remain in place for longer than six to twelve months, depending on the specific clinical situation and the child's ear health.

Potential complications or sequelae from prolonged presence of tympanostomy tubes may include persistent otorrhea (ear discharge), tympanic membrane perforation, or cholesteatoma formation.
Regular follow-up with an otolaryngologist is recommended to monitor the condition and determine the appropriate timing for removal.

Liu, 30~39 year old female. Ask Date: 2009/06/16

Dr. Ye Dawei reply Otolaryngology

Dear Sir/Madam:
1.
A four-year-old child had tympanostomy tubes inserted.
At five years and two months (one year and two and a half months later), the tubes have not yet fallen out.
When should they be removed? A.
Approximately within one year.

2.
What are the sequelae? A.
Generally, there will not be any serious long-term effects.

Dr.
Yeh Da-Wei, Head of the Department of Otolaryngology, Hsinchu Hospital.

Reply Date: 2009/06/16

More Info

When it comes to the removal of ear tubes (also known as tympanostomy tubes) in young children, there are several factors to consider, including the child's age, the duration the tubes have been in place, and the overall health of the child's ears. Typically, ear tubes are inserted to help alleviate issues such as recurrent ear infections or fluid buildup in the middle ear. They allow air to enter the middle ear and prevent the accumulation of fluids behind the eardrum, which can lead to infections and hearing loss.

In general, ear tubes are designed to stay in place for about 6 to 12 months, although they can sometimes remain longer. If the tubes have not fallen out on their own after about 1 to 2 years, as in your case, it is advisable to consult with an ear, nose, and throat (ENT) specialist. The decision to remove the tubes is often based on the following considerations:
1. Duration of Tube Placement: If the tubes have been in place for more than 1 to 2 years, it is usually recommended to evaluate their necessity. Prolonged presence of tubes can lead to complications such as ear canal infections or scarring of the eardrum.

2. Ear Health: If the child has been free of ear infections and has normal hearing, this may indicate that the tubes are no longer needed. However, if there are ongoing issues, such as persistent fluid or infections, further evaluation is necessary.

3. Child's Age and Development: As children grow, their ear anatomy changes, and they may become less prone to ear infections. If the child is older and has not had recent issues, this may also support the decision to remove the tubes.

4. Potential Risks of Prolonged Tube Presence: Leaving ear tubes in for an extended period can lead to complications such as:
- Chronic Ear Drainage: Continuous drainage from the ear can occur if the tubes do not function properly.

- Eardrum Perforation: Prolonged use can lead to a hole in the eardrum, which may require surgical repair.

- Scarring: The presence of tubes can cause scarring of the eardrum, which may affect hearing.

5. Follow-Up Care: Regular follow-up appointments with an ENT specialist are crucial to monitor the condition of the tubes and the child's ear health. The doctor may perform a hearing test and an examination of the eardrum to assess whether the tubes are still beneficial.

In conclusion, if your child has had ear tubes in place for over a year and a half without any recent ear infections or complications, it is advisable to consult with an ENT specialist for a thorough evaluation. They can provide recommendations on whether the tubes should be removed and discuss any potential risks associated with prolonged tube presence. Regular monitoring and proactive management are key to ensuring your child's ear health and preventing any long-term complications.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Eardrum Perforation in Children: Treatment Options and Recovery

Dear Doctor, My child, who is currently 5 years old, previously underwent adenoidectomy due to respiratory and sleep issues. About a year and a month after the tympanostomy tube placement, during a follow-up visit, we discovered that one of the tubes had fallen out, with one ear...

Dr. Li Jiaxuan reply Otolaryngology
Generally, if there are no chronic diseases, healing typically occurs within three months. However, if there is already scarring around the perforation of the eardrum, the chances of healing are low, and the physician may recommend surgery. If you prefer to postpone surgery for n...

Understanding Ear Infections in Children: Antibiotics and Prevention Tips

Hello Dr. Chen, I would like to ask about a one-year-old child who is frequently treated with antibiotics for otitis media. Could this have an impact on their health? How can we prevent the occurrence of otitis media? Is the administration of immunoglobulin effective?

Dr. Chen Junliang reply Otolaryngology
Hello, Miss: Due to the more horizontal position of children's Eustachian tubes, they are more prone to otitis media. Otitis media requires treatment for 2-3 weeks; otherwise, it can easily lead to middle ear effusion, which may affect hearing. When medications are administe...

Post-Surgery Recovery: Addressing Concerns About Ear Tube Removal in Children

Hello Dr. Cheng, my child underwent a preauricular sinus excision on March 2nd and had the sutures removed during a follow-up visit on March 16th. Now the surgical site is discharging pus and appears swollen. Does this indicate that the surgery was not completely successful?

Dr. Zheng Jueyi reply Otolaryngology
Hello, if the wound is oozing pus or is swollen, it may still be infected. It is recommended to return to the original surgeon's clinic for further examination.

Understanding Hearing Tests for Infants: Concerns and Next Steps

Hello, doctor. My child is 9 months old and was hospitalized in May for otitis media and bronchiolitis. A certain physician said he was discharged in good condition and did not require follow-up. However, without ongoing treatment, we later discovered a perforated eardrum, which ...

Dr. Xiao Kaiwen reply Pediatrics
Generally, a perforation of the eardrum caused by otitis media, if it does not affect the middle ear cavity (such as the ossicles) or the inner ear, should not impact hearing once the eardrum has healed. Hearing tests for infants can initially be conducted at home, such as produc...