Choosing Between Clear Skin Laser and Dye Laser for Acne Scars - Dermatology

Share to:

What are the differences between the Clear and Brilliant laser and the dye laser?


Dear Doctor:
1.
I have red acne scars on both cheeks (not a few), and there are red pigment deposits in lines on both sides of my nose, along with dark circles (melanin deposits).
Should I consider using a photorejuvenation laser or a dye laser for these issues?
2.
Based on the areas mentioned, how much does a session of photorejuvenation laser cost? How much does a session of dye laser cost?
3.
Could you please let me know which doctor performs the laser treatments? Thank you for your response...
I appreciate it.

capri_wu, 20~29 year old female. Ask Date: 2009/06/23

Dr. Huang Ruiyun reply Dermatology


Hello: The red color is treated with dye laser, while the black color is treated with Q-switched laser.
(Our hospital's contract for laser treatment in the dermatology department is scheduled to end on August 6 and will not be renewed).
The phone number for our beauty center is 003-5326151, where you can call for consultations and appointments.
The physicians performing the laser treatments include one dermatologist and one plastic surgeon.
Wishing you peace and good health.

Reply Date: 2009/06/23

More Info


When considering treatment options for acne scars and skin discoloration, such as the red acne scars on your cheeks and the pigmentation around your nose and under your eyes, both Clear Skin Laser (also known as non-ablative laser) and Dye Laser (pulsed dye laser) can be effective, but they serve slightly different purposes and have distinct mechanisms of action.

1. Choosing Between Clear Skin Laser and Dye Laser:
- Clear Skin Laser: This type of laser is typically used for overall skin rejuvenation. It works by targeting the deeper layers of the skin without damaging the surface, promoting collagen production and improving skin texture. It is particularly effective for treating enlarged pores, fine lines, and some types of pigmentation.

- Dye Laser: The pulsed dye laser is specifically designed to target blood vessels and redness in the skin. It is particularly effective for conditions like rosacea, port wine stains, and red acne scars. Given that you have red acne scars, the Dye Laser may be more beneficial for addressing the redness and improving the overall appearance of your skin.

2. Cost of Treatments:
- The cost of laser treatments can vary significantly based on geographic location, the specific clinic, and the expertise of the practitioner. Generally, a session of Clear Skin Laser can range from $300 to $600, while a session of Dye Laser may cost between $400 and $800. It’s important to consult with your dermatologist or the clinic to get an accurate estimate based on your specific needs and the extent of the treatment required.

3. Choosing a Practitioner:
- It is crucial to have these procedures performed by a qualified dermatologist or a licensed medical professional who specializes in laser treatments. You should inquire about the practitioner’s experience, the type of laser equipment used, and any before-and-after photos of previous patients. This will help ensure that you receive safe and effective treatment tailored to your skin type and concerns.

Additional Considerations:
- Skin Sensitivity: After laser treatments, your skin may become temporarily more sensitive. It is essential to follow post-treatment care instructions provided by your dermatologist to minimize risks and enhance healing. This may include avoiding sun exposure, using gentle skincare products, and possibly incorporating soothing agents like aloe vera or hyaluronic acid.


- Combination Treatments: Depending on the severity of your acne scars and pigmentation, your dermatologist may recommend a combination of treatments. For instance, using a Dye Laser to target redness followed by Clear Skin Laser for overall skin texture improvement could yield better results.

- Long-term Care: After achieving desired results from laser treatments, maintaining a good skincare routine is vital. This may include using products with ingredients like retinoids, vitamin C, and sunscreen to protect your skin and prevent further discoloration or scarring.

In conclusion, both Clear Skin Laser and Dye Laser have their unique benefits, and the choice between them should be guided by your specific skin concerns and the advice of a qualified dermatologist. It’s essential to have a thorough consultation to discuss your goals, treatment options, and any potential risks or side effects associated with the procedures.

Similar Q&A

Understanding Skin Treatments: Choosing Between Laser and Needle Therapy

Hello Dr. Huang, I have been unsure about which treatment would be best for my symptoms. I have a lot of hyperpigmentation from my teenage years, along with some pitted scars and enlarged pores. Since the cost of laser treatments is quite high, it is not something I can afford as...


Dr. Huang Ruiyun reply Dermatology
Hello: If you do not have sufficient financial resources as a backup, I suggest that you do not consider scar treatment at this time. Hyperpigmentation does not require treatment as it will fade over time. Currently, the most effective treatments for indented scars are dermabrasi...

[Read More] Understanding Skin Treatments: Choosing Between Laser and Needle Therapy


Comparing Fractional and Ruby Laser for Acne Scar Treatment

Which is more effective for acne scars, the fractional laser or the ruby laser? Also, after undergoing laser treatment, should I apply sunscreen for a lifetime or just during the recovery period?


Dr. Zhou Hongzhang reply Plastic Surgery
1. The fractional laser and the erbium chromium laser each have their advantages. Both are effective for acne scars, but the choice may depend on the condition and the patient's needs. The erbium chromium laser is more commonly used for pigmentation removal. 2. After laser t...

[Read More] Comparing Fractional and Ruby Laser for Acne Scar Treatment


Laser vs. Intense Pulsed Light: Which is Better for Acne Treatment?

In the past few days, I have been considering undergoing laser or intense pulsed light (IPL) treatment for acne. When I inquired at the clinic, the doctor mentioned that both options could be suitable for my current condition and advised me to think it over. I would like to ask: ...


Dr. Jiang Zheen reply Dermatology
Theoretically, the treatment of acne primarily involves topical and oral medications. Laser and intense pulsed light (IPL) therapies mainly target post-acne pigmentation or scarring. Generally, IPL is milder and has a slower effect, and both treatments are not very suitable for a...

[Read More] Laser vs. Intense Pulsed Light: Which is Better for Acne Treatment?


Effective Laser Treatments for Acne Scars: What You Need to Know

(1) After undergoing five chemical peels, I still have some acne scars that need treatment. Basically, aside from my face, my skin is in excellent condition. On the upper third of my cheeks, there are small red scars that are not very deep (they have faded significantly), but upo...


Dr. Zheng Lizhen reply Dermatology
Hello Ying-Yan! It is recommended that you visit the dermatology outpatient clinic in person, where the physician can observe and determine which type of laser treatment is suitable for improving your current condition. Wishing you and your family peace and happiness from the Tao...

[Read More] Effective Laser Treatments for Acne Scars: What You Need to Know


Related FAQ

Acne Scars

(Dermatology)

Laser Surgery

(Dermatology)

Intense Pulsed Light

(Dermatology)

Laser Spot Removal

(Plastic Surgery)

Scar

(Plastic Surgery)

Resurfacing

(Dermatology)

Hyperpigmentation

(Dermatology)

Isotretinoin

(Dermatology)

Tattoo

(Dermatology)

Freckles

(Dermatology)